West Side Rag
  • TOP NEWS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT US
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT
West Side Rag
No Result
View All Result
SUPPORT THE RAG

Search the site

No Result
View All Result
Get WSR FREE in your inbox
SUPPORT THE RAG

The Answer Column: It’s Been Closed for Two Years, So Why Is Artie’s Still Clogging Our Arteries?

March 27, 2019 | 8:13 AM
in FOOD, NEWS, OUTDOORS, REAL ESTATE
23

By Carol Tannenhauser

New York City sidewalks can feel like an obstacle course, especially when the weather warms and sidewalk cafes appear. It’s one thing to have your path obstructed by a lively group of outdoor diners, but what about an abandoned “enclosed sidewalk cafe,” like the one attached to the now-defunct Artie’s Delicatessen, on Broadway, between 82nd and 83rd?

WSR reader Douglas Cowan wants to know:

“How did Artie’s Restaurant get permission to enclose their outdoor space and take up half of the public sidewalk permanently? And now that the restaurant is gone, what happens? Can the public get the sidewalk back?”

For answers, we turned to Community Board 7, which is responsible for reviewing applications for licenses to operate sidewalk cafes on the Upper West Side. The process involves extensive documentation, zoning, permits, fees, public hearings, and approvals by numerous city agencies and the City Council. It also requires the payment of “consent” fees — the equivalent of rent for the use of public space. CB7 is an advisory board; its recommendations about the applications are sent to the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA), which licenses sidewalk cafes.

There are three kinds of sidewalk cafes: unenclosed, small unenclosed, and enclosed. CB7 Chairperson Roberta Semer said enclosed sidewalk cafes are no longer allowed on the Upper West Side. Existing ones are “grandfathered in.”

Linda Alexander, now co-chair of CB7’s Business & Consumer Issues Committee, remembers when Artie’s application was reviewed.

“The former Artie’s space was one of the last enclosed sidewalk cafes approved by CB7, going back more than a decade,” she wrote. “It is the same footprint as Artie’s original unenclosed sidewalk cafe, i.e. 9-feet from the building base, so it actually does not take up half of the 25-foot sidewalk, as suggested. But the sidewalk shed (scaffolding) covering the space certainly adds to the perception of it being oversized and exacerbates the reality of a pedestrian obstruction.”

According to the leasing agent, the scaffolding should come down in the next few months. The agent also said, “We are negotiating a deal with a new restaurant to take over the space.” A spokesperson for DCA told us that, at present, the cafe license is “inactive,” but, “after a restaurant closes, DCA allows its enclosed cafe to remain for a period of time to allow for its transition to a new owner. If the location remains unoccupied after that period, the landlord would be responsible for removing it.”

The leasing agent hopes the pending deal will close, though two before it didn’t. He also hopes the new operator will open the windows of the enclosed sidewalk cafe, giving it a “European” feel.

The bottom line, according to Semer, is that, “although enclosed sidewalk cafes are supposed to come down two years after a restaurant closes (Artie’s closed in April, 2017), that rarely happens. If the landlord doesn’t take them down, there’s really nothing CB7 can do.”

So, it looks like the cafe stays for now, with the hope that in the near future it will be easier and more pleasant to pass.

If you have a question for The Answer Column write it in the comments or send it to westsiderag@gmail dot com  Subject: Answer Column

Share this article:
SUPPORT THE RAG
guest

guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

23 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
prefer not to say
prefer not to say
6 years ago

Thanks for this article.
Artie’s site has also become a home for the homeless which has exacerbated the problem.

0
Reply
Amy
Amy
6 years ago

FWIW, the sidewalk in front of My Most Favorite Food on West 72nd is even worse.

0
Reply
AC
AC
6 years ago

Nice article Carol, but I would have liked you to dig deeper. Perhaps expanding on how Friedland’s political connections allow City Hall to turn a blind eye.

Semer is correct, “although enclosed sidewalk cafes are supposed to come down two years after a restaurant closes (Artie’s closed in April, 2017), that rarely happens. If the landlord doesn’t take them down, there’s really nothing CB7 can do.”

Local Community Government at its best!

CB7 should use its political clout to force the City to remove the eyesore.

0
Reply
Juan
Juan
6 years ago

Thanks for the very interesting update. My stomach really misses Artie’s. My wallet doesn’t miss it as much.

0
Reply
A
A
6 years ago

Anyone else think this is outrageous: “If the landlord doesn’t take them down, there’s really nothing CB7 can do.”

0
Reply
patrick
patrick
6 years ago
Reply to  A

CB7 is not an enforcement agency. The Department of Buildings should be the entity holding the landlord to account for this.

0
Reply
Harriet
Harriet
6 years ago

Perhaps the landlord is making more money renting Artie’s out to film The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, and he’s not in any hurry to rent it to a restaurant operator who will tear out the insides.

0
Reply
Henry W.
Henry W.
6 years ago

Just wondering about the definition of “enclosed” sidewalk cafe. Jacob’s Pickles regularly puts a roof and (removable) walls/doors around their sidewalk cafe (so that it’s fully enclosed), so I’m a bit curious how they can get away with that if there are no more permits for “enclosed” sidewalk cafes. And with their crowds waiting for a seat, there is virtually zero sidewalk space left.

0
Reply
Glen
Glen
6 years ago

The DOB should take the addition down and hit the LL with the cost of the removal by way of a lien until it is paid. The DoB does that with residential sidewalks in the outer boroughs.

0
Reply
WombatNYC
WombatNYC
6 years ago

It would be nice if 2nd Ave Deli would take over this space or something similar

0
Reply
Leon
Leon
6 years ago
Reply to  WombatNYC

Excellent idea! 2nd Ave Deli would be ideal. Ben’s would also work.

0
Reply
Ana
Ana
6 years ago

Artie’s had the best fries. I miss stopping in on Sundays for brunch with my son.

0
Reply
Tim Butler
Tim Butler
6 years ago

Your headline would seem to be a reference to Artie’s Artery, a fictitious music club from the movie Buckaroo Banzai. If this is the case, you have my undying admiration.

0
Reply
drg
drg
6 years ago

Its a double whammy.
The extra outside enclosed space allows the landlord to deduct even more losses against his income, so he makes extra money from keeping the space vacant.

BTW…. sarcasm alert.

0
Reply
PedestrianJustice
PedestrianJustice
6 years ago

Another enclosed sidewalk cafe to watch is the one at the old Saffron Indian restaurant at 75th and Columbus.

I think they closed in November 2017 and it’s still vacant. That two-year clock is ticking…

0
Reply
BlingBling
BlingBling
6 years ago

they should make it a bank!!
or CVS or Duanne Reade!!!

We don’t have enough of these.

0
Reply
Keith
Keith
6 years ago

The community board may not have enforcement power, but they should be able to persuade the appropriate authorities (DoB?)to force compliance. Isn’t the CB supposed to advocate for the community?

0
Reply
William Sharfman
William Sharfman
6 years ago

Possibly we could all ask Helen Rosenthal why the landlord could not be pressured if not compelled to extinguish that obnoxious enclosed intrusion on public sidewalk space. I never thought it a reasonable installation in the first place, rather a usurpation of public space, and now there has long been no commercial reason for it, but it’s an eyesore as well as a pedestrian barrier. A consortium supporting a lawsuit to get the landlord to remove it might well be successful.

0
Reply
DrM
DrM
6 years ago

The endless, minuscule things readers here find to complain about never cease to amaze me. People. You live in NYC. It’s crowded. How has this escaped you? C’mon back Mrs. Maisel! Continue to make the rest of the world jealous of where we live!

0
Reply
Sheldon Burke
Sheldon Burke
6 years ago

Two years is nothing! A restaurant called Chez Laurence was located on the southeast corner of Madison Ave. & East 38th St. and it closed over 25 years ago. The space has never been rented to another tenant and it’s still vacant.

0
Reply
Janet Hutter
Janet Hutter
6 years ago
Reply to  Sheldon Burke

I’ve worked 2 blocks from this corner for about q0 years and have often wondered about this.

0
Reply
Pedestrian
Pedestrian
6 years ago

Sadly Community Boards are impotent. Kept hamstrung by dismissive mayors and dismissed by agencies as obstacles. The Mayor has made it clear that he doesn’t cRe what CBs say. He has managed to enact Charter Revision that will lint their ability to effect change and protect neighborhoods within their jurisdictions and allow the well resources developers to run rough shod over residents. Failure to enforce sidewalk cafe regulations are just one example of this situation.

Against this despressing back drop CB7 under the chair Roberta Semer has persevered on many fronts including supertalls to pressure sometimes disinterested electeds to listen to taxpayers and residents. We all need to support our CBs and tell our City Council members that CBs need more power and respect and they need it now.

0
Reply
Regina
Regina
6 years ago

Speaking of scaffolding, HiLife has been under a scaffold for FIVE years and Sofia Storage is still not removing it though they are the reason for the structure existing. Why is that? Are there no time limits for scaffolding? They are a blight on our neighborhood. Please advise.

0
Reply

YOU MIGHT LIKE...

20-Year-Old Dies After Stabbing On Broadway; Two Teens Arrested
NEWS

Bicyclist Killed in Central Park After Collision With Pedestrian

June 20, 2025 | 5:33 PM - Updated on June 21, 2025 | 9:35 AM
Igor! The Epitome of Upper West Side Hospitality
COLUMNS

Igor! The Epitome of Upper West Side Hospitality

June 20, 2025 | 1:56 PM - Updated on June 21, 2025 | 9:52 AM
Previous Post

Unauthorized Toe Sculpture Remains, And Has Now Received a Pedicure

Next Post

Cathedral of St. John the Divine Wants to Add Copper Roof

this week's events image
Next Post
Cathedral of St. John the Divine Wants to Add Copper Roof

Cathedral of St. John the Divine Wants to Add Copper Roof

Springtime PSA:  How to Be a Helpful WSR Commenter and Support Our Site

Springtime PSA: How to Be a Helpful WSR Commenter and Support Our Site

Residents Question Details of Congestion Pricing As New Tolls Gain Steam in Albany

Residents Question Details of Congestion Pricing As New Tolls Gain Steam in Albany

  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWSLETTER
  • WSR MERCH!
  • ADVERTISE
  • EVENTS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF USE
  • SITE MAP
Site design by RLDGROUP

© 2025 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • THIS WEEK’S EVENTS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT US
  • WSR SHOP

© 2025 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.