West Side Rag
  • TOP NEWS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT US
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT
West Side Rag
No Result
View All Result
SUPPORT THE RAG

Search the site

No Result
View All Result
Get WSR FREE in your inbox
SUPPORT THE RAG

EARLY-MORNING PROTEST PLANNED AGAINST NEIGHBORHOOD’S TALLEST TOWER

May 15, 2017 | 8:48 PM - Updated on June 5, 2022 | 11:33 PM
in NEWS, POLITICS, REAL ESTATE
24


A drawing of the proposed building at 200 Amsterdam Avenue in yellow by zoning expert George Janes.

Council member Helen Rosenthal and preservationist group Landmark West are leading a rally on Tuesday morning at 8:30 a.m. to oppose the construction of a 668-foot tall apartment building at 200 Amsterdam Avenue (69th Street).

The rally will take place in front of the site at 200 Amsterdam, which is now a bulldozed lot. It formerly held the Lincoln Square Synagogue, which has moved a block away.


The lot at 200 Amsterdam on Monday. Photo by Stephen Harmon.

The tower, which would be the tallest structure north of midtown, has been in the works for years and has received Buildings Department approvals. But opposition has recently intensified and opponents were planning to file an eleventh-hour zoning challenge on Monday to derail construction. They say it’s out of scale with the neighborhood.

A presentation by zoning expert George Janes, who spoke to opponents earlier this month, is here. Landmark West is helping raise money to fund the legal challenge, securing a $5,000 challenge grant.

The developers were able to piece together a complicated lot that allows them to build a higher building than if they had just used the smallish lot where the building is located. While the developers say it’s fully legal and compliant with city rules, opponents are doing their best to find any problems that can be challenged.


An analysis of the zoning lot by George Janes. Click to enlarge.

“There is reason to believe that the current proposal at 200 Amsterdam Avenue is non-compliant with the zoning code in several respects,” Rosenthal wrote in a statement.

Rosenthal’s opponent for the City Council race, Mel Wymore, also plans to attend the rally, and has criticized Rosenthal for responding too slowly. “We need forward-thinking leadership,” he added in an email to supporters.

Share this article:
SUPPORT THE RAG
guest

guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

24 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chase
Chase
8 years ago

you posted this late. shout it from the mountain tops!

0
Reply
bill
bill
8 years ago
Reply to  Chase

You can picket and protest all you want….This was already bought and paid for

0
Reply
robert
robert
8 years ago

You can yell and scream all you want. Our local pols and the usual group of self appointed community leaders will all be there. They will all raise a hue and cry, not to mention use it to fundraise and bash Trump. But guess what they have all the permits & approvals they need, they are already building!!!!! Unless they can prove that there is some kind of outright fraud in that process and/or the documentation this building is a done deal. A nano sized number of permits, of any kind, in the city are reversed after they are issued. The time to fight this was during the permitting process. Rather than fight them now and not getting anything how about talking to them about community space and/or access to the facilities the new building will offer.

0
Reply
Jay
Jay
8 years ago

Just a bunch of NIMBYs wasting time and money.

0
Reply
Jason
Jason
8 years ago

NIMBY’s is right. Posters to this site whine and cry over the amount of vacant space on the UWS, and then protest a developer who is developing vacant space. This building will bring with it more residents, which means more people shopping locally, which means more services will be required, which means less vacant space. You would think that means less whining, but if there is one thing that we can count on UWSiders doing, it’s just that.

0
Reply
Sean
Sean
8 years ago
Reply to  Jason

No. More people shopping online. People who will send their kids to private school. People who will use car services. People who will be in the Hamptons seasonally. They will hire a nanny and a dog walker who does not live in the city.

0
Reply
Sherman
Sherman
8 years ago
Reply to  Sean

With all the social engineering involving PS 199 soon a lot more parents will be sending their kids to private schools or leaving the city altogether (but I don’t mean to digress).

0
Reply
Bruce Bernstein
Bruce Bernstein
8 years ago
Reply to  Sherman

please clarify what you mean by “Social engineering.” do you mean efforts to desegregate?

0
Reply
Paul RL
Paul RL
8 years ago
Reply to  Jason

Agreed!

0
Reply
Chris Gault
Chris Gault
8 years ago
Reply to  Jason

Couldn’t say it better.

0
Reply
Sherman
Sherman
8 years ago
Reply to  Jason

You are 100% correct.

These same people are also protesting how unaffordable the UWS is.

The last time I checked my economic books an increase in supply causes prices to decrease.

It’s hypocritical to complain about how expensive housing is and then complain when more housing is being built.

0
Reply
wombatNYC
wombatNYC
8 years ago

can’t wait for the retail component of this new building. Ha ! Unfortunately, local and independent stores will not be able to pay the expected rent

0
Reply
West Side observer
West Side observer
8 years ago

“The time to fight this was during the permitting process.”
Quite right. This brouhaha is probably for the benefit of Ms. Rosenthal’s re-election campaign – no coincidence that her “Campaign Kick-Off” event takes place tonight.

0
Reply
Madeline Goode
Madeline Goode
8 years ago
Reply to  West Side observer

Helen has been completely absent on this issue and only jumped in now that she sees an opportunity. Where was her office years ago when this was coming together? Asleep. Or doesn’t care- or is catering to her super rich cohorts. I don’t trust a word she says- she has not been involved with this fight till she heard that 350 people showed up to a meeting to oppose it. Now she is racing to oppose it. If the appeal looses you can blame Helen, as she had the time to do something about this long before.

0
Reply
anon
anon
8 years ago

Can someone explain the rules around piecing together a lot? Some of this area appears to be in the Lincoln Towers land. Did Lincoln Towers sell their air rights? If Lincoln Towers ever wanted to build on this land (and I doubt they would) would that be allowed?

0
Reply
B.B.
B.B.
8 years ago
Reply to  anon

Don’t have time to sit down and write a detailed explanation. So these two links will have to do:

https://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20170411/REAL_ESTATE/170419967/developers-of-200-amsterdam-avenue-set-to-build-rare-tower-on-upper-west-side

https://www.cityrealty.com/nyc/market-insight/features/future-nyc/understanding-power-air-rights/2923

Between them you should be able to grasp the concept of air rights as applies to NYC zoning.

Just remember the Latin phrase “Cuius est solum, eius est usque ad caelum et ad inferos, “For whoever owns the soil, it is theirs up to Heaven and down to Hell.”

0
Reply
anon
anon
8 years ago
Reply to  B.B.

Thanks B.B. So it appears that Lincoln Towers, home to the people who complain about overcrowding at PS 199 and feel that their residents should get priority to that school, who complain about the lack of light that other nearby buildings have caused, sold air rights to their parking lots, grassy areas, and private road in order to allow this building to get higher and higher.

0
Reply
B.B.
B.B.
8 years ago
Reply to  anon

170 West End Avenue (Lincoln Towers) certainly did some sort of deal, the nature of which one cannot say. *LOL*

See: https://www.realdirect.com/e/200.AMSTERDAM-AVENUE.10023/

Scroll down to “Public Records” section, then click on various items. Besides “Sundry Legal Documents” you’ll find one or more easements granted by 170 West End Avenue.

0
Reply
ScooterStan
ScooterStan
8 years ago

What a PLEASANT SURPRISE to see that EIGHT out of NINE comments (thas’ 88.888888%) so far are Pro-200 Amsterdam!

But we “YIMBY” (YES In My Back Yard) types cannot think it is all over. The NIMBY, self-appointed preservationist, anti-everything brigade, joined by opportunistic political ‘wh-r-s’ (sorry…family publication) using this for their own purposes, will NOT accept defeat but will continue to do everything-and-anything to prevent 200 Amsterdam from happening.

“Aux Barricades”, YIMBY-types, and be prepared to fight back!

0
Reply
Bruce Bernstein
Bruce Bernstein
8 years ago

of course the vast majority of the people in the neighborhood are against this monstrosity. and apparently the zoning challenge by Rosenthal and Brewer has a good chance of being successful, at least acording to Crain’s.

but why don’t you guys who are so in favor of this call a mass meeting? let’s see how many turn out!

https://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20170516/REAL_ESTATE/170519920/upper-west-sides-tallest-tower-may-not-get-off-the-ground#utm_medium=email&utm_source=cnyb-realestate&utm_campaign=cnyb-realestate-20170516

0
Reply
Jay
Jay
8 years ago
Reply to  Bruce Bernstein

“of course the vast majority of the people in the neighborhood….”

So good of you to speak for everyone. Please, show us a valid poll that shows any support for the NIMBYs blocking this fully permitted project.

I’m sorry that we have jobs and couldn’t show up to counter-protest. We’ll continue to let you waste your copious amount of time.

0
Reply
Bruce Bernstein
Bruce Bernstein
8 years ago
Reply to  Jay

i am basing my statement of “the vast majority” opposed on two facts:

1) the huge crowd that came out to the mass meeting to oppose the project

2) the fact that all politicians running for office, that i know of, are opposed. Apparently that is where the votes are.

Jay said:

“I’m sorry that we have jobs and couldn’t show up to counter-protest. We’ll continue to let you waste your copious amount of time.”

wow, that was pretty snarky. You assume the people who are opposed don’t have jobs? vs. the people who are in favor have jobs?

And what if many opposed are retired?

look, if you’ve got so many people in favor of it, let’s see a candidate run for office on that platform. “Build the Monster building!!”

0
Reply
Cato
Cato
8 years ago
Reply to  Jay

I, for one, am with Bruce on this and opposed to this colossal intrusion on the Upper West Side.

It will challenge the already overtaxed infrastructure, it will not bring anyone to the neighborhood but more bankers and international oligarchs, and it will not add retail.

And, PS, it’s grotesque.

That’s why so many people have already objected to it in prior postings. The predominance of monstrosity fans in comment to this particular posting shows little other than the fact that objectors have already spoken.

0
Reply
Alan Bettman
Alan Bettman
8 years ago

Helen Rosenthal’s entrance into this fight is “too little, too late” and strictly political. She sat on her developer feed hands for three years and now just 4 months before her re-election bid. she makes this token effort. Today’s so called rally was just for show. Rosenthal, in typical fashion, did not make any efforts to even organize the rally at 200 Amsterdam, but then crudely, directed people to her website to “sign up” I’m sure those people will be getting requests for donations in weeks to come. #SayHellNo2Helen

0
Reply

YOU MIGHT LIKE...

20-Year-Old Dies After Stabbing On Broadway; Two Teens Arrested
NEWS

Bicyclist Killed in Central Park After Collision With Pedestrian

June 20, 2025 | 5:33 PM - Updated on June 21, 2025 | 9:35 AM
UWS Weekend: Great Things To Do in the Neighborhood
COLUMNS

UWS Weekend: Great Things To Do In (and Around) the Neighborhood: Movies; Fanatics Fest; Guided Tours of NYC

June 20, 2025 | 7:51 AM
Previous Post

MORNING BULLETIN: BOOK CULTURE EXPANSION, MIDDLE SCHOOL SEGREGATION, ‘FORGOTTEN’ BROWNSTONES

Next Post

SILVER STARS FITNESS – THE SILVER STARS PERSONAL TRAINING MODEL IS TIME-EFFICIENT AND GETS RESULTS. SIGN UP NOW FOR WEST 72ND OR WEST 55TH YOGA AND TAI CHI CLASSES. SPACE IS LIMITED.

this week's events image
Next Post
SILVER STARS FITNESS: PREVENTING LOWER BACK PAIN AFTER AGE 50 (SPONSORED)

SILVER STARS FITNESS - THE SILVER STARS PERSONAL TRAINING MODEL IS TIME-EFFICIENT AND GETS RESULTS. SIGN UP NOW FOR WEST 72ND OR WEST 55TH YOGA AND TAI CHI CLASSES. SPACE IS LIMITED.

FORMER ISABELLA’S OWNER POSTS MESSAGE TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND LANDLORD RESPONDS TO CLOSURE

FORMER ISABELLA'S OWNER POSTS MESSAGE TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND LANDLORD RESPONDS TO CLOSURE

MORNING BULLETIN: GROW YOUR FOOD ON THE ROOF

SHAZAM! FOUR DATES FOR 2017 MANHATTANHENGE REVEALED

  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWSLETTER
  • WSR MERCH!
  • ADVERTISE
  • EVENTS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF USE
  • SITE MAP
Site design by RLDGROUP

© 2025 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • THIS WEEK’S EVENTS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT US
  • WSR SHOP

© 2025 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.