Bruce Rutherford, one of the veterans who expects to move into new affordable housing at 330 West 95th street.
By Carol Tannenhauser
The city’s Human Resources Administration is turning the building at 330 West 95th street, a former homeless shelter, into permanent affordable housing for veterans. The building was supposed to open before Christmas, but as of this week, veterans who had chosen to live there were still waiting. An HRA spokesman never got back to us about when they can expect to move in.
We spoke to two homeless veterans who are excited about moving in.
“It changes you,” says one of the veterans who has secured a spot in the building. He has asked that we not use his name, so we’ll call him Johnnie.
Johnnie is talking about Iraq, where he served for six months in the U.S. Army during President George W. Bush’s troop “surge” in 2007. He was 20.
“It could be combat missions or transportation missions,” Johnnie explains. “It doesn’t matter what job you’re doing over there. You’re always on high alert. You wake up thinking, ‘What might happen today? Is a bombing coming? A mortar? Are we going to be attacked at the gate?’ Everyone experiences it differently. I wasn’t able to cope with it as much as I wanted to.”
Johnnie’s girl back home was making it harder. Psychologically unstable, she couldn’t handle his deployment, repeatedly threatening suicide. The stress of war and her unraveling were too much for Johnnie. Unable to function, he was discharged early — honorably — for “failure to adapt.”
Johnnie worked a series of menial jobs, living with his girlfriend in constant turmoil and conflict, until, in 2013, she “kicked” him out. His reaction surprised him.
“I felt free,” he recalls.
For the next three days and nights, before entering the NYC shelter system, Johnnie lived on a park bench. He remembers it as a time of reflection and self-discovery.
“I’m not money-driven,” he says. “I don’t ever want to work for anyone else again. I don’t ever want to do meaningless jobs again. Nowadays, I just be. I try my hardest to put positive energy in the universe and see what I get back.”
Johnnie’s plan, after moving into 330 West 95th street, is to go to school. “I have educational benefits that I intend to exploit,” he explains. “I’m going for interdisciplinary studies. Nothing specific. I just want to learn. Someone suggested I go to a community college first.”
“And who was that someone?” asks Bruce Rutherford, 57, smiling.
He had come into the room shortly after Johnnie.
“It was you,” Johnnie laughs.
“I think you will be better served than if you went straight into a four-year college,” Bruce explains.
He is drawing on a decade of experience as a public high school teacher. Bruce has a B.A. in English Literature and a Masters in Comparative Literature from CUNY. Yet, there he is, as a result of a failed business venture, overdue student loans, major depression, and unpaid rent, living in a homeless shelter with Johnnie and about 100 other homeless vets. (Bruce served in the Navy, on an aircraft carrier, after the Vietnam War.) The City has been scrambling to get them all permanently housed, in response to President Obama’s 2014 “Mayors Challenge to End Veteran Homelessness” by the end of 2015.
It looked like Johnnie and Bruce were going to make it, be in their own homes by the holidays. In early December, they “viewed” 330 West 95th street and decided to use their federal veterans housing vouchers, which pay up to 70 percent of their rent and guarantee the rest, to live there. They were screened — “rather extensively,” Bruce says, ”including criminal, substance abuse, and mental health histories” – and accepted by the nonprofits contracted to oversee the project and provide health and social services to the veterans.
Then, all communication stopped.
“We’re on pins and needles,” Bruce exclaims. “The application process took place over a month ago and we haven’t heard a word since. We’re in limbo.”
Still, Bruce thinks 330 West 95th street is worth the wait.
“It’s a beautiful, well-maintained building,” he explains. “It was constructed in 1910, so it’s pre-World War I. And it’s the UWS, a bastion of liberalism,” he laughs. “People tend to be pretty tolerant there.”
Bruce’s unofficial survey of articles about this somewhat controversial project put 65 percent of neighborhood residents in favor of it and 35 percent against.
“I can understand the concerns,” Bruce says. “People are worried whether there will be any adverse effects on the neighborhood or their property values. A group of us talked about it. We’re going to be very vigilant and police ourselves. We don’t want to do anything that will reflect poorly not only on the residents of the building, but veterans in need in general.”
“We just want to know when we’re going to move in! We need some information so we can get on with our lives.”
Happy for them
With respect, if this is free housing for people who don’t want to work ever again, how is it not a homeless shelter?
He said that he didn’t want to work “for anyone else” again, implying that he wants to work for himself. He’s going to school it seems, to decide what he wants to do professionally.
Exactly Finnegan!!!
Thank you for this interview. These men defended our country. Whether you agree with why they were deployed is beside the point. They had no power in that decision and they deserve some small measure of support back. Giving them a place to live that is safe and comfortable will go a long way towards restoring their dignity and I’m guessing it will help them in many other aspects of their lives, including finding permanent employment.
Well said.
I wish them the best of luck. I hope this is the first step into a way for them to work to create a better life for themselves.
Some people are so bitter, as if caring about other people is such a nightmare. Welcome to New York, living and putting up with people from all walks of life is part of the package. Especially on the Upper West Side.
THANK YOU Avi and Carol Tannenhauser for this article.
To Bruce Rutherford and “Johnnie”: I live down the street in 230 Riverside. i look forward to WELCOMING you into the neighborhood.
from the article:
“Bruce’s unofficial survey of articles about this somewhat controversial project put 65 percent of neighborhood residents in favor of it and 35 percent against.”
this is more accurate than some of the nasty comments we have seen in the West Side Rag. it might even be higher than 65%.
I urge the WSR to post similar profile stories about OTHERS who use supportive housing in the neighborhood. these neighbors of ours are demonized and dehumanized by a few nasty (and ignorant) commenters. Please cover them as they are: as real people, our neighbors. they have problems just like all of us but also a lot to add to our community.
Mr.Bernstein, your graciousness and compassion is very much appreciated. I will always deem you as a true pillar of the community. Thanks, friend!
you’re welcome, Bruce “R”. i look forward to meeting you.
You obviously have been mentoring some of the younger vets and that gets a lot of “props” in my book! that’s service as well.
so pleased for them all!
Just want to say “welcome to the neighborhood”. We may pass on the street or never meet, but do know that I am so happy for you. Wishing all of our vets success in their new homes and their future. Thank you for being here/there to serve and protect…….
Why you’re most welcome, CMW!
We have enough of our share of homeless shelters in the 90s, more than any other area in the city. Also not sure it is a good idea to have across from an elementary school. There will be MANY MANY adverse effects!!!
Thanks for your concerns Mel;however, you obviously didn’t read the piece in its entirety. If you had, you would know that the address mentioned above IS NOT a homeless shelter, but permanent affordable housing for military veterans. Moreover, it further states in the piece that the screening process for prospective tenants has been extensive. Thus, your added comment about this dwelling being inappropriately near a school is rendered moot. And you clearly are ill-informed about this impending project.
Bruce Rutherford
Incredibly valuable reporting – thank you for this! Thank you to Johnnie and every vet who’s volunteered to serve in the military. It’s an honor to have you in the neighborhood.
Welcome to the neighborhood. Hopefully, it will be a good place for you to call home.
Thank you, Ann! Best wishes to you as well.
Excellent article. Excellent building usage. Excellent people. This makes me proud to be an UWS’er. WSR: More coverage like this please.
I think this is a good thing, and I welcome the veterans to the neighborhood. My only real concern is this particular landlord, who does not have a good track record. I am hoping he and the city do right by the veterans — they deserve proper housing and support in return for their service.
Keep us posted, WSR.
Agreed on all points.
Welcome to the UWS, geentlemen. Sending good wishes your way for all of your future endeavors!
Whoops, I meant “gentlemen!”
Thanks a bunch,Terri.