
This story was originally published by THE CITY. Sign up to get the latest New York City news delivered to you each morning.
By Gwynne Hogan, THE CITY
The NYPD has declined to prosecute numerous criminal summonses against demonstrators arrested across several New York City university campuses during pro-Palestinian demonstrations last month.
It’s unclear exactly how many summonses were cleared from the books over the past several weeks, though it’s likely in the hundreds. THE CITY spoke to several demonstrators who were told by attorneys their charges waived including people arrested at Columbia University on April 18, at New York University on April 22, at Columbia again on April 30, and the City University of New York’s City College that same night.
Despite the move, another 90 people facing misdemeanor and felony charges arrested at Columbia and City College inside barricaded buildings still have their cases pending before the courts, according to Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s office.
While NYPD’s attorneys act as prosecutors in summons court, the police department referred comment to the district attorney’s office, which in turn referred a request for comment back to the NYPD. New York criminal court sent out letters to some this month dated as early as May 2, informing them they didn’t have to return to court. The Office of Court Administration did not return multiple requests for comment on the dropped charges.
Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem, which alongside a team of pro bono attorneys is representing demonstrators at Columbia, NYU, City College, Fordham University, Fashion Institute of Technology and the New School, declined to comment.
‘A Way to Intimidate Protesters’
Between April 18 and May 8, the NYPD arrested more than 600 people involved in demonstrations in and around college campuses in New York City opposing Israel’s war in Gaza. The vast majority of the demonstrators were hit with summonses for trespassing and other low-level offenses like walking in a roadway or obstructing governmental administration.
Students and faculty arrested at Columbia and City College on April 22 began to get word that their summonses had been dropped through attorneys this week, several told THE CITY. Some of those who’d been arrested in earlier raids at Columbia on April 18 and NYU on April 22 got letters from the state court system and through lawyers earlier this month.
“No charges stuck, so it really does just seem like NYU was using the NYPD as a way to intimidate protesters,” said Zach Samalin, an assistant professor of English who was visiting the student encampment with his family on the evening of April 22 when he was arrested and charged with trespassing and spent hours in jail.
Earlier this month, he received a letter in the mail from the Criminal Court of the City of New York notifying him the NYPD did not file necessary paperwork with the court to move ahead with the charge against him, and that he didn’t have to return to court.
“That’s been sort of vindicating,” he said.
Notices from attorneys informed others of the dropped summonses. Among those off the hook are about 60 demonstrators arrested the night of April 30 who linked arms outside Hamilton Hall on Columbia’s campus in an attempt to block police from entering the barricaded building demonstrators had occupied.
Allie Wong, a 38-year-old student organizer who is working on a PhD in communications, was among those arrested that evening. She said Friday she had been advised a day earlier by attorneys at Neighborhood Defender Service that she and the group of 60 didn’t have to go to court this week, according to messages from attorneys reviewed by THE CITY.
Wong said that while she is relieved the trespassing charge against her is no longer pending, it makes her feel even more suspicious about Columbia’s justification to deploy police to break up the campus demonstration in the first place.
“If there was legitimate concern, why not take this to court?” she asked. “Scrutinize it in a way that any alleged crime deserves to be scrutinized.”
While many charges appear to have now been waived, 46 people arrested inside Hamilton Hall still face charges that include criminal trespass in the third degree, a class B misdemeanor, and are due to return to court in June, court records show.
At City College, following a 15-minute occupation of an administrative building, 22 people arrested there still face burglary in the third degree charges, a class D felony, as well as obstructing governmental administration, among others, and are also due to return to court in June, according to court records and the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office.
‘When You Cross Over That Line’
University leadership from Columbia to City College have faced blowback for the decision to involve the NYPD to tamp out campus protests, a move they justified citing safety concerns and vandalism. While the mayor and police touted officers’“professionalism” and “precision policing,” students have documented an array of injuries they say they suffered during the police crackdowns. The city’s Civilian Complaint Review Board is investigating complaints against 40 officers for their actions policing campus protests.
The apparent crackdown on pro-Palestinian demonstrations continued in Bay Ridge this weekend, where an annual Nakba Day protest was met by a show of force from officers with the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, who advocates said beat and shoved demonstrators and arrested around 40 people including credentialed members of the press.
The controversial counterterrorism unit, widely condemned for its uses of force on demonstrators during the George Floyd protests of 2020, is supposed to be phased out of protest policing according to the terms of a new settlement agreement with the NYPD. As part of that agreement, the department is currently developing new policies towards protest policing that include a multi-tiered response in which the police are supposed to accommodate protests “whenever possible.”
Asked about that Tuesday, Adams said the city supported the agreement even as he expressed skepticism about the new system, which is expected to be rolled out in the coming months.
“When you spit in the face of a police officer, there is no tier,” he said.
“They didn’t stop everyone for protesting. They stopped those who went over the line. That is the difference,” Adams said of the Saturday protest, where all but four of the 41 people arrested were charged with low-level summonses and issued desk appearance tickets for disorderly conduct, obstructing governmental administration and resisting arrest. (Two were charged with second and third degree assault and another two were given tickets for reckless endangerment and criminal mischief.)
“We’re not going to wait until you harm someone,” Adams said. “When you cross over that line, there’s no tier to that.”
THE CITY is a nonprofit newsroom that serves the people of New York. Sign up for our SCOOP newsletter and get exclusive stories, helpful tips, a guide to low-cost events, and everything you need to know to be a well-informed New Yorker. DONATE to THE CITY
The NYPD was wise in dropping the charges against protesters exercising their right to cry out against this horrific and criminal war. The students, along with some professors and others, shifted the public conversation around this terrible assault that is being propagated against Palestinians with American tax-payer dollars. It is not just the students but many, many American citizens of all ages who are horrified that their country supports such an vicious war against innocent people.. Let us hope for a cease-fire and a change in the Israeli government.
Yes, and let’s also hope for a change in Hamas and similar groups who have clearly stated that they are only interested in the destruction of Israel and who have refused, over the years, all plans for a two-state solution that have been offered them.
Most of the people who are publicly calling for a ceasefire don’t care about the suffering of Muslims. They just want to demonstrate how morally superior they are to the world. While they complain about the Israeli government, Muslims area workers on the UWS who have nothing to do with the protests and denounce Hamas get profiled and targeted by cops and civic and community leaders ignore them or don’t do as much as they should. Gaza is five thousand miles away yet there’s Muslims on the UWS suffering, fix that!
I think this was handled perfectly by the police. The universities were unable to get the protestors to leave, and they were intimidating Jews and interfering with the normal activities at the universities. So the police were called in to restore normalcy. Counter to the opinion of the protestors, they were not there to “intimidate.”
The goal of this process was not to maximize the number of arrests. Perhaps the protestors actually wanted to be arrested so they could get bonus points in their poor attempt at pretending to be 1960s protestors (despite generally having no idea what they were protesting). But the goal was to only arrest and prosecute those who truly broke laws such as breaking and entering, destruction of property and hate crimes (harassing Jews based on their religious identity is a hate crime).
The self-appointed spokespeople for the protests continue to embarrass themselves more and more. This was handled so poorly. Has Israel been a perfect citizen? No. Is Netanyahu evil? Yes. Would respectful protests about this have been meaningful? Likely yes as long as they first acknowledged the horrors of October 7 and how Hamas is hurting the Palestinians more than Israel is. But they got carried overboard by a number of ignorant bad actors and refused to distance themselves from them.
And in the process they have severely damaged some once wonderful universities.
“No charges stuck, so it really does just seem like NYU was using the NYPD as a way to intimidate protesters,” said Zach Samalin, an assistant professor of English .
What a warped interpretation of the dismissal of the charges, especial by an “English” professor. The reason charges were dropped was because the sheer number of cases that would have needed to have been prosecuted would have overwhelmed the system. The evidence against all of these perpetrators for trespassing and disturbing the peace was (and is) overwhelming. It’s shameful that these cases were dismissed. It’s simply another sign of a broken justice system that criminals view with contempt and disregard.
I think the quality of some professors is what led to these disruptions in the first place. Clearly, their “Middle Eastern studies” are sorely lacking in historical perspective.
It’s clearly that the police were totally out of line and never should have interfered with the peaceful protesting.
It wasn’t peaceful when I walked through Columbia’s campus…If it were, I might agree with you. Were you there in person, rather than in spirit and mind?
I’m not sure this article is accurate. It wouldn’t be the NYPD “dropping charges”. I would be the DA.
Yes, the DA.
Why are charges being dropped? No punishment for crimes? These people blocked buildings, entrances, destroyed property.
I don’t understand how the encampments are an exercise in free speech. I feel like I am in the Twilight zone.
Nothing wrong with any of this political demonstrations protest… They have the right and the freedom to do so under the first amendment of the constitution in the United States of America 🇺🇸 as I did back in the 1960s against the Vietnam war.
I fully support the protesters 100%.
And yes, the New York City police were totally out of line.
How can you claim to understand the meaning of the 1st Amendment when the protestors were on private property and had no inherent right to be there in conflict with the rules of the property owner?
No charges. Just walk away. Justice was not served here. These were not peaceful. These were filled with hate. Would have served these “students” right to sit a couple of months in jail.
Hate and threats, in my personal experience from being on that campus. And, I am aware that there are a few more than just me who experienced the same threatening protesters. And this was both outside the gates and on the campus. But, then again, we choose the believe what is convenient or conveniently in line with our beliefs.