West Side Rag
  • TOP NEWS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • CONTACT
West Side Rag
No Result
View All Result
Get WSR FREE in your inbox

Search the site

No Result
View All Result

Get WSR FREE in your inbox

AVAILABLE NOW!


HERE

Theodore Roosevelt Statue Dismantled in the Dead of Night

January 19, 2022 | 11:19 PM - Updated on January 23, 2022 | 6:01 AM
in ART, HISTORY, NEWS
56

By Carol Tannenhauser

Wednesday night at the American Museum of Natural History (80th and CPW), the work of dismantling and carting away the Equestrian Statue of Theodore Roosevelt continued.

The temperature was practically balmy around 9:30PM, and a small group had gathered — many from the Museum — to watch the proceedings, which took on a performative feeling. A guy straddling a bike with a large American flag flying from the back, narrated through a megaphone.

“You can’t erase history. God Bless America.”

“It’s bittersweet,” one of the Museum staffers said. “I walked past the statue every day.”

But so did millions of visitors, many of them children, who gazed up at Teddy on his steed, flanked by two half-clad men of minority races, who are walking. For decades it was deemed colonialist or racist by some, defiled by others, and finally, in the wake of the Black Lives Matter movement, the decision was made by the Museum, the City, and the Roosevelt family — “there’s a Theodore Roosevelt IV and V,” the staffer said — to send the statue to Medora, North Dakota, where the Theodore Roosevelt Presidential Library is scheduled to open in 2026.

Theodore Roosevelt will still be omnipresent at the AMNH, which contains the official New York State memorial to him, including the Museum’s Central Park West entrance, the Theodore Roosevelt Rotunda, and the Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Hall.

“The total removal of the statue will take a few weeks,” someone from the Museum said, “and the restoration of the steps will take until spring.” A plaque is planned, as well as an outline of the retired statue.

But why is this being done in the dead of night? The museum sent a statement explaining that “conducting this type of work at night is standard Department of Transportation procedure [and] a condition of obtaining a permit. The work was scheduled during nighttime hours for safety reasons and to minimize disruption to traffic and pedestrians.”

People sat on benches, listening to workers yell to each other, and watching machinery move to their commands.

“It’s like a Broadway show,” the man with the megaphone said.

The statue stood for 81 years. Photograph by Edward H. Blake via WikipediaCommons.

Thanks to Mark Alpert for the tip.

Share this article:
guest

guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

56 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
ST
ST
1 year ago

Will never forgive them.

1
Reply
Nani
Nani
1 year ago

That’s just awful. It’s art and a piece of history, it also could have led to critical discussions. Taking the sculpture away takes away from NYC as a cultural hub. What a shame.

1
Reply
Paul
Paul
1 year ago
Reply to  Nani

History?

In what “history” did TR, our first modern president, ride horses with an Indian in full headdress and a half-clad African-American walking alongside?

The precise reason for removal is that the statue is offensive to the concept of “history.”

0
Reply
Isaac
Isaac
1 year ago
Reply to  Nani

Ha be realistic – agree with removal or not, NYC’s status as a cultural hub is in no way influenced by the presence of that statue.

0
Reply
Papa Ra'Della
Papa Ra'Della
1 year ago

Maybe next time don’t make such a racist sculpture. Just sayin

0
Reply
SNY
SNY
1 year ago
Reply to  Papa Ra'Della

Wouldn’t it be great if one of New York great art benefactors (M. Bloomberg or S.Cohen, perhaps?) commissioned, say, JEFF KOONS to replace the Theodore Roosevelt statue in front of the AMNH?
Imagine a giant green reflective metallic DINOSAUR
by Jeff Koons on Central Park West?
He can create his greatest art commission since Michael Jackson’s “Bubbles” …or his fabulous giant sculptural Poodle that’s in front of the Guggenheim Bilbao in Spain!

0
Reply
Phoebe
Phoebe
1 year ago
Reply to  SNY

Yuck

0
Reply
uwsmom
uwsmom
1 year ago
Reply to  SNY

love this idea!

0
Reply
WIll
WIll
1 year ago

Good.

0
Reply
Josh P.
Josh P.
1 year ago

The “dead of night” headline feels pretty unfair. The implication is that the museum is trying to hide something by removing the statue while no one is looking, when they have discussed the statue and it’s potential removal for months, if not years. One of the first things you see when you walk in the museum is a big banner that says “addressing the statue.” It was removed at 9:30pm (not even that late!) because CPW is a busy street. Should they have aimed to inconvenience as many people as possibly by doing it during the morning rush?

0
Reply
Jsc
Jsc
1 year ago
Reply to  Josh P.

Completely agree. The scaffolding has been up for weeks. And it’s not like this could be taken down during museum hours – or at rush hour. There is no hush-hush nature to this.

0
Reply
Kim
Kim
1 year ago
Reply to  Josh P.

Totally agree with this. What were they supposed to do? Close down a lane of traffic on CPW during the day? That would have caused one huge traffic jam. The headline is really unfair.

0
Reply
Huh
Huh
1 year ago
Reply to  Josh P.

I don’t think they are trying to hide the fact that they are doing it. But aside from being less inconvenient for pedestrians and motorists, doing it without fanfare at night means fewer crowds of looker ons or protestors. Once the decision has been made, it must be easier and faster to just get it done with fewer disruptions .

0
Reply
72RSD
72RSD
1 year ago

Interesting to see the man with a flag and megaphone mentioned. He’s been a nuisance up and down 72nd street for months, putting anti-vax stickers on storefronts, bellowing anti-vax statements into his megaphone and pretending to manage traffic in intersections with his megaphone.

He’s becoming a loud bore, and I’m surprised the cops don’t stop him.

0
Reply
Claire
Claire
1 year ago
Reply to  72RSD

The cops are only ever interested in stopping and harassing one type of pedestrian and it ain’t the white man with the American flag.

0
Reply
Phoebe
Phoebe
1 year ago
Reply to  Claire

Great comment.
Aside: I’ve never seen that annoying man!

0
Reply
Dori
Dori
1 year ago

One man’s “racism” is another’s work of art. Get rid of everything that steps on one of your pet “isms” and we won’t have any human artwork left, because human beings aren’t perfect. Solution: Grow a thicker skin and realize that free speech, like other civil liberties, carries a price tag. It makes some people feel uncomfortable some of the time.

0
Reply
don kedick
don kedick
1 year ago
Reply to  Dori

Art belongs in museums–which is exactly where this work is going!

Not everyone deserves a statue, Dori. Freedom of speech doesn’t mean freedom from consequences.

0
Reply
Paul
Paul
1 year ago

Go to Egypt you see statues of pharaohs,, with African slaves to the south and Asian slaves to the north.
Erect a statue of a pharaoh today? There won’t be slaves.

Put a statue of TR on horseback if you want, in front of the museum. Just TR.

0
Reply
Peter
Peter
1 year ago
Reply to  Paul

You really think that would have gone over well? Keep TR on his horseback and cart off the other two?

0
Reply
Paul
Paul
1 year ago
Reply to  Peter

Sorry, Peter. That’s not what I said.

0
Reply
Phoebe
Phoebe
1 year ago
Reply to  Paul

Clarify

0
Reply
wombatNYC
wombatNYC
1 year ago

Roosevelt was a hero, adventurer and a great american . Too bad we’re too Woke as a society to allow that statute to stand. Ridiculous that we chose to remove it.

0
Reply
What is Imperialism
What is Imperialism
1 year ago

The museum IS Teddy Roosevelt, so removing the statue won’t do much anyways.

0
Reply
Crawdad
Crawdad
1 year ago

This is so dumb. They could have put a plaque explaining the context. Instead this globally iconic museum will have a giant bare spot right at the front entrance.

0
Reply
jmwinterfield
jmwinterfield
1 year ago
Reply to  Crawdad

I think they will just call that bare spot STAIRS.

0
Reply
notsofast
notsofast
1 year ago
Reply to  jmwinterfield

Exactly. Brilliant comment.

0
Reply
Mark Moore
Mark Moore
1 year ago

Was the statue really “dismantled”?

0
Reply
Cato
Cato
1 year ago

“Do you realize that the past, starting from yesterday, has been actually abolished? ….. Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book has been rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street and building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And that process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right.”

Oh, come on, you know who wrote that and where it’s from, right? And that’s my point — you know what’s going on here; you’ve probably read the road map.

0
Reply
Ye Olde Englife Teechere
Ye Olde Englife Teechere
1 year ago
Reply to  Cato

Very clever, Cato!
Of course, it’s from Orwell’s “1984”!
Also appropriate, in this case, is Huxley’s “Brave New World”, especially the source of that title: “Oh, brave new world that has such people in it” (“The Tempest”).
Yes, SUCH people: the SASfPC (Self-Appointed-Squad for Political-Correctness)

0
Reply
Vincent
Vincent
1 year ago

If this is the kind of thing that makes you upset, I wish you a long, enjoyable retirement in Florida.

0
Reply
Jack
Jack
1 year ago

Public monuments represent cultural values. If a group feels, after reasoned discussion, that a monument no longer represents their culture and values, they are free to take it down.

I personally disagree with the decision to alter monuments, but it’s their property and they are perfectly within their rights to do with it as they wish.

Where I draw the line is mob violence directed at statues, which was common in 2020 (and was avidly supported by many prominent figures). That merely privileges the loudest and most violent group of people, and is not the right way to make these decisions.

0
Reply
SJ
SJ
1 year ago

“Political correctness is fascism pretending to be manners.”

-George Carlin

0
Reply
EricaC
EricaC
1 year ago
Reply to  SJ

I can’t help but wonder whether your respect for George Carlin extends across the board.

0
Reply
Gym goer
Gym goer
1 year ago

From athletic point of view on the statue, two guys on sides have more attractive build. Long legs, thick chest and wide shoulders. Theodor riding on house is a shorty with thin skeleton.
Colonizer must have admired native Indian and imported African bodies.
Your vision is a refection of what you have in your mind. The statue didn’t look racial till someone said so.

0
Reply
Phoebe
Phoebe
1 year ago
Reply to  Gym goer

Good observation.
Having the statue there showed the truth, as it stood, from a viewpoint that existed (and still sometimes/somewhere still does) and taking it away removes opportunity for discourse.
A good plaque would have sufficed. Even a changing plaque could have been workable.
And to the person who commented about retiring to Florida: If we remain interested, we needn’t use that stigmatizing term at all. It’s anti-intellectual and agist. Talk about “woke.” There are many ways to be woke, but telling people to, figuratively, stay in the kitchen is just flat-earth nonsense.

0
Reply
Jaime Rosa
Jaime Rosa
1 year ago

As a native New Yorker, I believe the white supremacy ‘toys’ all need to all be replaced with the truth. Over 400 years of misinformation has given us all a false sense of ‘white supremacy’. The truth is marching on. Peace & love.

0
Reply
charles
charles
1 year ago

It is terrible the way people are trying to eradicate history. Is this the kind of society we want to live in?

0
Reply
Ian Alterman
Ian Alterman
1 year ago

It is one thing to be sensitive to history and culture. It is another to be overly P.C. Of course, the White supremacists and racists in the South use the same argument about the removal of Confederate statues; i.e., why not leave them and have a plaque or other way of leading to a discussion, etc., etc.? Are those here who are lamenting the removal of this statue also lamenting the removal of Confederate statues? Why one and not the other? Are they both victims of “cancel culture” or is one okay and the other not? I ask this for discussion purposes only.

0
Reply
Steevie
Steevie
1 year ago

Just from the standpoint of national self-preservation we ought to go very easy on the criticism of American historical figures. Our population knows very little history. And as you may have noticed, things seem to be coming apart. We are becoming 2 different countries.

0
Reply
wearedoomed
wearedoomed
1 year ago

The real tragedy here is that we have let the vocal minority, the smallest sliver of the population, the non-representatives take over the media and hence the country. The curious thing is that even with a diverse peer/work group, I have never actually encountered a real person behind these claims. It feels so manufactured.

0
Reply
Joe
Joe
1 year ago

I think they should tear the whole racist museum down and build public housing.
JMHO

0
Reply
Steven
Steven
1 year ago

Have JEFF KOONS design a fantastic replacement of the T. Roosevelt statue.
What about a giant green metallic DINOSAUR?
An art commission that would generate more excitement on CPW than the Macy’s balloons. And maybe NYC’s greatest art benefactors can fund it? (M.Bloomberg or S. Cohen?)
After all, there’s a giant Jeff Koons “Poodle” sculpture in front of the Guggenheim in Bilbao Spain. Imagine the excitement if the AMNH commissioning Mr. Koons for this project?

0
Reply
Kathleen
Kathleen
1 year ago
Reply to  Steven

Great idea, Steven!

0
Reply
Kathleen
Kathleen
1 year ago

Glad to see it gone, it was disgusting.

0
Reply
Carol
Carol
1 year ago

It depends on where your head is whether you liked the statue or not! I saw it as history. I saw it as Teddy creating the American Museum of Natural History encompassing Native Americans and Blacks – oppressed races – to build a foundation of natural history…..it was a beautiful statue – very apropos – I feel sorry for people who see only what they want to see. I saw many things in that statue.

0
Reply
Bruce E. Bernstein
Bruce E. Bernstein
1 year ago
Reply to  Carol

Did American Blacks in 1940, when the statue was installed, routinely walk around naked? Or did they do so when TR was President? Is that something you “see” in the statue?

Also, while TR was relatively enlightened for his era towards Blacks, you might want to check out his brutal and atrocious record towards Native Americans.

I’m not anti TR, but this statue is a big mess, and thanks to the Roosevelt family and Museum trustees for having it removed.

0
Reply
Joan Lurie
Joan Lurie
1 year ago

Our desire to erase our heritage is awful. Do people really forget that if we bury the past, we are doomed to repeat all our mistakes?

0
Reply
Paul
Paul
1 year ago
Reply to  Joan Lurie

Did TR ever sit on a horse flanked by a stereotypical Indian Chief in full headdress and a stereotypical proto-enslaved African American clad in a loincloth?

If so, we’re destroying history.

If not, the myth should be destroyed as any derogatory myth should be.

0
Reply
Bebee
Bebee
1 year ago
Reply to  Paul

Good riddance.

0
Reply
babrarus
babrarus
1 year ago
Reply to  Bebee

To you as well.

0
Reply
Context-man
Context-man
1 year ago

Don’t people understand TR is on horseback not because of race, but because of rank? He’s one of the most powerful men on earth, on an expedition, and is being guided by trackers on foot. A white George Washington was on horseback during the Rev. War, surrounded by white troops on foot (literal foot-soldiers). White supremacy / racism? Of course not. He was the general leading the troops!

0
Reply
Bruce E. Bernstein
Bruce E. Bernstein
1 year ago
Reply to  Context-man

Did Washington’s troops wear clothes?

0
Reply
notsofast
notsofast
1 year ago

I used to think the UWS was a “liberal” neighborhood. Can’t believe how naïve I was. I might as well move to Mississippi.

0
Reply
Bruce E. Bernstein
Bruce E. Bernstein
1 year ago
Reply to  notsofast

To @notsofast:

The UWS is not as progressive as it used to be, but neither is it as reactionary as the WSR comments would have you believe. For example, in the last election, if you polled comments on WSR, one would think Gale Brewer was extremely unpopular. But she won in a landslide. And the “law and order / lock ‘em up” candidate for DA got a tiny sliver of the vote.

So many of the comments above regarding this statue are unaware, at best, and over the line as racist, at worst. This is not representative of the UWS population as a whole. But it’s sad that even 20% of our population thinks this way, and is compelled to express it, always anonymously.

0
Reply
Carol Harris
Carol Harris
1 year ago

I wish I could move out of this city. I am a registered Democrat who HATES the democrat party and it’s leftward trend.
I LOVED that statue and see it’s removals a warning about times to come.

0
Reply

YOU MIGHT LIKE...

Artist and Teacher ‘Internationally Famous on the Upper West Side’
ART

Artist and Teacher ‘Internationally Famous on the Upper West Side’

February 1, 2023 | 2:11 PM
Crime On The Upper West Side Over the Decades
CRIME

Now There Are Nine: Two More Local Businesses Were Burglarized

February 1, 2023 | 9:57 AM
Previous Post

Mourning Michelle; ‘I Went to the Vigil Because Ms. Go Was an Upper West Sider and I’m an Upper West Sider’

Next Post

Linda Rosenthal’s Second FREE COVID-19 At-Home Test Kit and Mask Giveaway Is Friday, January 21st

this week's events image

Explore Your Favorite Subject

20th precinct 24th precinct american museum of natural history animals art bicycling bulletin central park closings columns community board 7 coronavirus crash crime development dogs events fdny fire food gale brewer helen rosenthal history jcc lincoln center monday bulletin morning bulletin nypd openings pedestrian safety photography photos politics public schools pupper west side real estate restaurants retail riverside park silver stars fitness snow sponsored subway upper west side uws

CITY NEWS

Brick Underground
City Limits
Eater
Gothamist
NY Daily News
NY Post
NY Times

LOCAL RESOURCES

Bloomingdale Neighborhood History Group
Central Park Conservancy
CB7
Community Education Council 3
Assembly District 67
The New York Historical Society
Riverside Park
West End Preservation

UWS Blogs

Bloomingdale History Central Park Blogger
North River Notes
Next Post
Linda Rosenthal’s Great Mask and Self-Test Giveaway

Linda Rosenthal's Second FREE COVID-19 At-Home Test Kit and Mask Giveaway Is Friday, January 21st

97th Street Key Food Moving Down a Block, But Way Up in Square Footage

97th Street Key Food Moving Down a Block, But Way Up in Square Footage

Get 4 Free At-⁠Home Rapid Antigen COVID-⁠19 Tests From the Federal Government; Sign Up Here

Get 4 Free At-⁠Home Rapid Antigen COVID-⁠19 Tests From the Federal Government; Sign Up Here

  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWSLETTER
  • WSR MERCH!
  • ADVERTISE
  • EVENTS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF USE
  • SITE MAP
Site design by RLDGROUP

© 2023 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • THIS WEEK’S EVENTS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • CONTACT US
  • WSR SHOP

© 2023 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.