
By Gus Saltonstall
A car drove through the fencing of an Upper West Side train station early Monday morning, photos shared with West Side Rag show, and FDNY confirmed.
An Audi crashed through the black fencing outside of the West 72nd Street and Broadway train station and onto the pedestrian plaza around 3:15 a.m., an FDNY spokesperson told the Rag.
“I came upon this scene this morning at 3:55 AM at West 72nd St (I work early mornings),” Brian Merrill Garcia wrote to West Side Rag. “I can’t say how or what happened other than what is obvious in the photo. The tow truck was slowly pulling the Audi away from the impact area. Debris was everywhere. The railing was thrown all the way back over to the subway vent in the middle of the median walkway.”

The FDNY did not have more details on how the car crashed, but did tell the Rag that the driver abandoned the vehicle and fled the scene.
As of Monday at 9:30 a.m., the black fencing was still scattered outside of the West 72nd Street train station, and broken car parts lined the cement.


Subscribe to West Side Rag’s FREE email newsletter here. And you can Support the Rag here.






Wow that’s just insane! Glad no pedestrians were hurt. How out of control do you have to be driving for that to happen?!
This was probably a stolen car and the driver was speeding and lost control. That’s why there’s no driver in sight.
UWS Dad,
This was not a “bad driver”.
This was a criminal – who was driving a car.
under the influence of drugs and alcohol
Driver Ed classes for that driver! Lots of them
I hope you’re joking. Driving this dangerously, putting other people at risk, and fleeing the scene (avoiding testing for DWI) deserves serious jail time.
When e-bikes kill and maim people, the loudest car haters all make excuses for them that car drivers never do for this type of an incident. Almost no car drivers believe that there shouldn’t be consequences for this incident.
I think you’re conflating two different things. 1. People should be punished when they bike dangerously and 2. We should pass new laws and remove infrastructure to make biking more difficult for everyone.
So what changes would you support to make sure this doesn’t keep happening here? The existing laws obviously aren’t working.
https://www.westsiderag.com/2024/07/04/car-crashes-into-uws-bank-on-72nd-street-photo-video
https://www.westsiderag.com/2022/09/04/one-hail-of-a-ride-taxi-clips-and-flips
https://www.westsiderag.com/2020/08/15/arrest-made-after-nissan-flips-in-high-speed-rollover-on-72nd-street
There is accountability that doesn’t exist with e-bikes.
Can’t park that there, sir. You’re blocking a bike lane. And you don’t want to get THEM upset!
Ho ho ho pretty funny considering how many cyclists go through that stretch every day, would have been a real laff riot if he’d hit one.
not funny
The City keeps implementing changes that impact on lawful responsible drivers.
But the City does almost zero for the unlawful drivers – who are truly dangerous.
Drivers who are involved in criminal activity (drug sales, theft); under the influence; unlicensed; super speeders etc.
Like the July 2025 Canal Street driver who killed two when she was super-speeding and crashed – gun, drugs, alcohol, stolen car.
And she had a criminal case pending from April when she crashed in Broolyn injuring a pedestrian.
ok. I think we’d all prefer fewer accidents but what exactly are you recommending here? You can’t have cops everywhere at all times.
Tell me again how protected bike lanes are the danger to everyone, please, I dare you. This car was barely stopped by that flimsy fence. Should rip the whole mess down and put in legit bollards.
They keep emergency vehicles from being able to get through traffic when the number of lanes is reduced.
Well, since you dared me. Protected bike lanes are a danger to everyone. They should be called bicycle demolition derby lanes with high speed electric bikes they’re not just dangerous, they’re deadly. Happy.
Doug Ford is doing God’s work in Toronto!
Two things can be teue at once.
Absolutely we need more bollards at that intersection; the whole thing is a mess, should pedestrianize a large chunk of it.
No to pedestrianizing – buses need to get through
And all the cars trying to leave Manhattan. W72nd is one of the few entrances to the WSH. Closing the street to them would result in more cars in the neighborhood going up to 79th.
A stolen car?
Drunk driving is de facto legal in our neighborhood. The 20th precinct has made seven arrests for DWI all year. This is despite a drunk driver killing an Upper West Sider earlier this year. If a law isn’t enforced it doesn’t exist.
https://www.nyc.gov/assets/nypd/downloads/pdf/traffic_data/traffic-statistics/ts-en-us-020.pdf
No, one of those new disposable, recyclable Audis.
I had my worst bike accident at literally that very spot many years ago. I was riding in the bike lane on the left, and there was a cab stopped in traffic at just that exact spot in the leftmost lane. The person in the back opened the door to get out – and keep in mind that there was nowhere for them to go, since the fence was there – and I crashed, thankfully not to hard, right into the door, almost injuring or killing the person getting out. The crash wrecked my front basket, and injured my knee badly enough to need to go to the ER.
This is why passengers in cabs, Ubers, Lyfts, etc. should NEVER get out on the street side of the vehicle.
That said, I hope everyone involved in THIS incident was okay.
Is there a license plate? Was the car stolen or a ghost car, it’s one or the other.
The bumper is on the ground in front of the car and therefore because it was pulled off in the crash it can not be seen See my comment I just posted re reg of car
Plate or no plate, the car is registered to someone. But (and someone who knows more about how this works, legally, please weigh in) without visual evidence proving who the driver was, it’s hard to prosecute. That’s why fleeing can be effective.
I believe red light and speeding cameras issue administrative fines rather than moving violations with license points, because they can’t prove who was driving.
There have to be cameras in the area. They’ll figure out who drove the car.
There are plenty of surveillance cameras, especially in Manhattan to find whoever did this. It is very much doable. Look at how one is saying there should be absolutely no accountability for this.
Luckily, the proposed e bike charging station for that spot was vetoed. Tragedy narrowly averted.
If cars had license plates this wouldn’t have happened. Pass Priscilla’s Law now!!
I’m a long time resident of the UWS and read the Spirit weekly I would like to have another source of information
Maybe they were rushing to make a subway.
I did a double take when I saw the phrase “train station” in the headline (and again in the body of the article). “Train station” is what I would call Grand Central or Penn Station. Is it just me, or wouldn’t most New Yorkers call the place where this accident happened a “subway station”?
Maybe.
People from Brooklyn when going to Manhattan say I am going o the City.
This has nothing to do with the regular UWS anti anything but bikes that is never ending
It was at 03.15 which odds are means the car was stolen Take look at the windshield, There is only one sticker and looks to be from NJ. Besides being stolen I would not be surprised if it had been used in the commission of a crime. The driver may have also fled if they had warrants.
If they were drunk/high and it was their own car NYPD will arrest them shortly
I’m guessing not from Manhattan. If you are going to commit mayhem, do it in your own town.
Instead of focusing on accountability for dangerous driving, which no one is making excuses for, you use this as an opportunity to attack “outsiders” who don’t have the privilege of living in Manhattan and who help support Manhattan’s economy and Manhattan being the center of the largest metropolitan area in the country. Manhattan is not a college campus style bubble.
If there was a speed table at pedestrian intersections on Broadway, you wouldn’t have people speeding on it any time of the day
So many flee after an accident. One can only think they have some culpability such as dui or w/out a license.
As of now, as I’m first reading and learning about this, I can see the area from my apartment and it’s been all cleaned up and a temporary fence has been installed. It looks like the driver would have had to make a 90 degree turn to hit the fence like that; hard to figure out how it happened. (But there probably are surveillance cameras in the area that will reveal all!)
I wonder if / when this would have been reported if an eyewitness and had not directly reported it to the Rag. There are a lot of car crashes that get reported statistically but never get a write up in the media.
There are a lot of e-bike crashes too that never make the media!
Many people are on drugs, smoking legal joints, and drinking alcohol. These vices have to be stopped. This is not democracy: being free to kill others or damage their properties
Crossing the road at 71 street and Broadway is dangerous at all times. Traffic can appear from 3 different directions. Time to cross the road is to short . I am surprised there are not more accidents,
Then put your phone down, while you’re looking around, waiting to cross.
Presumably it was stolen?
There was a taxi crash at that station in December 1999. It went through the railing, injuring several people, including my neighbor who was a passenger. The taxi driver reported that he was cut off by another car.
http://www.huffpost.com/entry/taxi-crashes-into-subway_n_263345
Thank heavens no pedestrians were around to be killed or maimed!!! This car had to be moving at some speed to take down that fence! It feels like no place is safe for pedestrians, even in the wee small hours.
This is not the first time that a car has crashed through this fencing. They need to install better traffic barriers