West Side Rag
  • TOP NEWS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT US
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT
West Side Rag
No Result
View All Result
SUPPORT THE RAG

Search the site

No Result
View All Result
Get WSR FREE in your inbox
SUPPORT THE RAG

BANK COMING TO PRIME CORNER ON 86TH AND BROADWAY

April 28, 2014 | 9:07 AM - Updated on June 5, 2022 | 11:38 PM
in NEWS, POLITICS
61

old banana republic

We got three emails this weekend about the same storefront on the Northeast corner of 86th street and Broadway. That large space, which used to house Banana Republic, has been empty for months since Banana moved across the street to the former home of the Gap.

Work has been going on at the site for a few weeks now, but it wasn’t clear from the permits what was going in. On Sunday, however, construction workers told multiple people that the space is gong to become a Chase bank.

We haven’t measured the size of the storefront, but it looks like its close to running afoul of Borough President Gale Brewer’s law limiting the size of banks on Broadway to 25 feet. Maybe the space is going to be subdivided, or there’s a loophole in the law? We’ll check with Gale’f office.

Share this article:
SUPPORT THE RAG
guest

guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

61 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
BILL
BILL
11 years ago

up until the late 90’s I always remembered a bank on that corner,in fact my very first savings account I opened there when I worked at chock full o nuts )NY bank for savings)

0
Reply
Jon
Jon
11 years ago

Chase locations already exist on 96th and Broadway, 90th and Broadway, 86th and Columbus, and 79th and Broadway, not to mention ATM locations at the Duane Reade every other block. Is another location really necessary? And in violation of the recent rezoning laws, at that…

0
Reply
rumor
rumor
11 years ago

chase signing is an untrue rumor

0
Reply
Kenneth
Kenneth
11 years ago
Reply to  rumor

It is not just a rumor. The forman on the work site yesterday told me directly that it was becoming a Chase Bank.

0
Reply
UWS-er
UWS-er
11 years ago
Reply to  rumor

How do you know?

0
Reply
Sharona
Sharona
11 years ago

UGH. Make it stop already with the banks! I’d settle for a Olive Garden or something equally tasteless at this point!

0
Reply
Lisa
Lisa
11 years ago

What a shocker!! Another bank.

0
Reply
Carol Feldman
Carol Feldman
11 years ago

A huge bank on every corner of our neighborhood is just destroying it. In the evenings it is dark and no one is on the street because the banks take all the room from any interesting shops, cafes or restaurants.

0
Reply
nycissues.org
nycissues.org
11 years ago
Reply to  Carol Feldman

Stop! We do not have a bank or drug store at every corner! Yes, some blocks or neighborhoods have more than others. The opposite is also true, some neighborhoods have none.

0
Reply
Tom D
Tom D
11 years ago

The banks are the only ones that can afford the rents. Or as someone else suggested, maybe an Olive Garden or Red Lobster type place.

0
Reply
shari
shari
11 years ago

ugh! what we DON’T need is another bank. We need a furniture store, another clothing store (there was a rumor at one point that JCrew was going to go there), hell.. anything BUT another bank. Awful decision. Big UWS fail.

0
Reply
nycissues.org
nycissues.org
11 years ago
Reply to  shari

The current zoning ordinances for the UWS do not allow for more business space to be created. The regulations are archaic and do not reflect today’s business and residential needs. The UWS needs more small retail and business office space. The recent zoning changes only set limits in order to protect private interest groups. This keeps rents and property values high and prevents competition and excludes many deserving groups.

0
Reply
webot
webot
11 years ago
Reply to  shari

Unfortunately, I hear that many retailers (chains and locals) are balking at the new rules on the UWS for retail. Yet another layer of government bureaucracy.
I do not know if that is the case here, but high rents are just one factor is small business not opening and thriving on the UWS in particular.

Note: this is not a invitation for Bruce to attack me sand call me a names like Republican.

0
Reply
JT
JT
11 years ago
Reply to  webot

Can anyone explain what the new UWS zoning laws are? I am not familiar.

0
Reply
West Sider
Author
West Sider
11 years ago
Reply to  JT

Sure, we wrote about them here: https://www.westsiderag.com/2012/06/29/city-council-approves-upper-west-side-mom-and-pop-rezoning-by-wide-margin
Avi

0
Reply
Jason
Jason
11 years ago

I don’t understand the aversion to banks. If people we’re going to visit them, or put their money there, they wouldn’t open shop. They are clearly providing a service that people want and need.

0
Reply
Kate
Kate
11 years ago
Reply to  Jason

Everyone uses online banking and mobile banking. Who ever actually goes to brick-and-mortar banks anymore? Your argument is invalid. The banks aren’t fulfilling a need – they are sprouting up simply because they have the means to.

0
Reply
Mike
Mike
11 years ago
Reply to  Kate

Yeah, banks love to just burn money. The idea that they fill retail spaces just because they can afford it is insane.

0
Reply
se
se
11 years ago

Ooh, how exciting! Another dead storefront on evenings and weekends!

0
Reply
Deb
Deb
11 years ago

I asked the workers yesterday and they said it was going to be a Chase Bank – just what the neighborhood needs – ANOTHER BANK! Ridiculous!

0
Reply
mlm
mlm
11 years ago

Just what we need – 6 banks currently on Broadway between 86th and 90th Streets!!!!

0
Reply
Ralph Shapiro
Ralph Shapiro
11 years ago

It makes me sick. Is there that much money on the UWS that we need yet another bank to hold it all? Are there that many sick people on the UWS that we need another pharmacy? Adios neighborhood. Welcome to New Jersey!!!

0
Reply
Ed
Ed
11 years ago

As you know, we don’t get to vote for the type of business that opens up. But I personally would be happier with a bank than a lousy chain restaurant on that corner.

0
Reply
Tom
Tom
11 years ago

Maybe now at least that hideous overhead shed will come down from around that beautiful building.

0
Reply
Julie
Julie
11 years ago
Reply to  Tom

The shed is there for building restoration, not because of the corner storefront. I live in this building and will be very sad if the bank rumor is true. High rents are ruining our neighborhood. We’ve already lost the Popover!

0
Reply
moi
moi
11 years ago
Reply to  Tom

You wanna bet!! There”s scaffolding on every block on the UWS. And the City just sits back and does nothing.

0
Reply
Kenneth
Kenneth
11 years ago
Reply to  moi

The sidewalk shed is there (and at many other locations throughout the City) to comply with NYC laws that require their presence when facade work needs to be performed or is being undertaken above. It protects pedistrians from falling objects. (See NYC Local 11 for example). It has nothing to do with the rental. The sheds can be there for years while work is planned and executed. They are expensive to erect and remove. It is inexpensive to leave them in place.

0
Reply
Kenneth
Kenneth
11 years ago
Reply to  Kenneth

…NYC Local LAW 11…

0
Reply
webot
webot
11 years ago

I am curious, Is anyone bemoaning the loss of Banana Republic? It is after all a major chain store, owned by The GAP, Inc.

Was it better the the proverbial bank or big pharmacy?

0
Reply
Kenneth
Kenneth
11 years ago
Reply to  webot

They do not.
Why? Because it moved across the street.

0
Reply
Mike
Mike
11 years ago
Reply to  webot

Exactly. I don’t know what people think should go into that large retail space. The PC Richard next door is such a happening spot on nights and weekends, maybe they should have expanded.

0
Reply
Brian
Brian
11 years ago

We walked by yesterday and were excited to see some movement there, they were framing windows, etc. This is a big letdown.

0
Reply
wendy
wendy
11 years ago

There is already a large chase bank on 90th Street and Broadway – it doesn’t make sense….and what happened to the law limiting bank storefronts?

Why don’t they just make the Upper West side permanently zoned only for banks and drugstores. That should solve the pesky problem of any other business wanting to open on Broadway and make a go of it.

0
Reply
Mike
Mike
11 years ago
Reply to  wendy

That unit was vacant for a while. Right or wrong, those scrappy up and comers were priced out of that space. What sort of mom and pop place would make a go of it in that huge space?

0
Reply
Christina
Christina
11 years ago

Between 67th Street and 86th Street on the Upper West Side, there are 7 Chase banks and numerous other banks, some of which I’ve never heard of. We Certainly Don’t Need Another Bank… and you can bank on that! 🙂

0
Reply
Jason
Jason
11 years ago
Reply to  Christina

So to be clear, you oppose a service that the upper west side needs in such quantity, that Chase is making the economic decision to open another. Obviously Chase would not open unless it would be economically beneficial to them, which means, that people will patronize the bank and use its services, which means, that people want a bank there. Would you rather a less successful business take its place? What world is this?

0
Reply
Christina
Christina
11 years ago
Reply to  Jason

Jason…Also to be clear… it’s not the people who want the banks it’s the landlords! Probably the only ones who can afford the exorbitant rents.

0
Reply
webot
webot
11 years ago
Reply to  Christina

I do not love the bank overload either – I thought with the internet, brick and mortar banks would go the way of record stores or at least be limited.

But, really who else was going in there….take restaurants for example: Since it was not an existing restaurant, it would not be grandfathered in and therefore would have to up the new overreaching code, such as sprinkler for the whole building, not just the restaurant, ADA bathrooms, plus getting a liquor license, where there will be “community activists” fighting too limit them to midnight, no outdoor cafe, plus the 14 other city agencies that could derail the plans. etc. etc. Just too risky for most restuarantors,

0
Reply
Christina
Christina
11 years ago
Reply to  Jason

Ah no Jason. The 7 or so Chase banks among the numerous other banks around the upper west side can clearly accommodate people who are up here. Besides I’ve been to numerous banks that are never crowded with people or long lines. Just to Be Clear!!!

0
Reply
Jason
Jason
11 years ago
Reply to  Christina

Who are we to tell residents, or Chase for that matter, that the other banks are sufficient? Isn’t that a business decision for Chase to make? If Chase thought it was sufficient, and thought that another bank wouldn’t add to their economic success, they wouldn’t open there. Who are we to tell residents to use the others? Shouldn’t they use what’s most convenient for them? Still a free country no??

0
Reply
Christina
Christina
11 years ago

I remember the original Banana Republic stores when they were cool safari themed. I know they probably did the right thing by changing it for financial reasons but boy it was so much more cooler than today. So were the catalogues! I know I’m veering off subject but someone mentioned Banana Republic and it reminded me of the store years ago on the Upper West Side.

0
Reply
dcortex
dcortex
11 years ago

What happened to the law limiting the size of Bank Storefronts?

0
Reply
nycissues.org
nycissues.org
11 years ago
Reply to  dcortex

I was enacted with many loopholes. Broadway as well is parts of Amsterdam and Columbus Avenues are exempt of any kinds of business storefront limitations.

0
Reply
WhatsUpDuck
WhatsUpDuck
11 years ago

The Belnord, as reported in the NYT for some time, is in a state of disrepair. A beautiful building, but one overrun by rats, with leaks, etc. (How many years has scaffolding surrounded that building?)

The owners probably wanted a tenant that could help them pay their repair bills, didn’t want to run any risks associated with an eatery, etc.

Either way, a huge disappointment.

0
Reply
nycissues.org
nycissues.org
11 years ago

There is no such thing as too many banks, drug stores or public facilities. Community action groups of the UWS and their favorite elected officials have created more harm by taking on causes that are insignificant and of low priority.

Limiting one type of business or group, only creates an imbalance somewhere else. Run like hell when a community action committee or group wants to stop normal business dealings on the UWS. Think about the unintended consequences of any action, zoning ordinance or legislation.

0
Reply
Edward
Edward
11 years ago

It is ironic that banks seem to want us to do as much of our banking online by incentivizing direct deposits, online transfers, online billpay, etc. yet they feel the need to open bricks and mortar stores every other block. And I’m sure some over-priced McKinsey or BCG consultant was paid a fortune to figure this out for them.

0
Reply
RF
RF
11 years ago

Other than stopping by the ATM, how many people actually still visit brick-and-mortar banks? Is it really enough to justify yet another Chase location when there are several others within walking distance? As far as I can recall, I’ve been inside a bank exactly twice in the past year–once to have something notarized, and the other because I needed cash and the ATM was out of service. On both occasions the banks were empty except for the people who worked there.

0
Reply
Jeff
Jeff
11 years ago
Reply to  RF

It’s about presence. Banks are mostly the same, and so they distinguish themselves by location – there’s tons of money on the UWS, and if people have to walk a few extra blocks to get to Chase, it is ceding many millions worth of deposits. Also, the big footprint conveys power, stability, etc.

0
Reply
nycissues.org
nycissues.org
11 years ago
Reply to  RF

There are many functions that need to be done in person and cannot or should not be done using an ATM. Not all customers have direct deposit or even a bank account to cash a pay check. In the beginning of the month, banks are the most crowded. Money orders, bank checks, and coins are one of the many services required by customers.

Many bank customers on the UWS would scream bloody murder if they had to take a bus or train to visit a branch. Banks compete for retail space, because they have to. The average number of people served by each bank on the UWS is in the thousands.

Banks are critical for business and residents. They are a gauge of economic health of the community. Many of the less wealthy parts of NYC have very few banks.

0
Reply
moi
moi
11 years ago

Another bank to undermine the beauty and character of the neighborhood. How lovely.

0
Reply
Cato
Cato
11 years ago
Reply to  moi

Let’s not lose sight of the fact that there is a Citibank directly across 86th Street from this site. Then, one short block south, a Wells Fargo ATM site on 85th and Broadway.

Perhaps Avi could run a poll — How many readers have done a transaction with a bank *teller* (not an ATM) in the past month or week? It would be interesting to see why banks think it economical to stake outposts on every corner.

0
Reply
NikFromNYC
NikFromNYC
11 years ago

Ha ha ha, after red tape killed Alamo theatre, your comeuppance arrives. After outlawing dancing on the UWS, and shutting down our only tube dress source of spunky ladies that was on 105th, you white guilt wives of bankers get a nightmarish mall of *banks* as your deserved award. You are what you eat, gold diggers.

0
Reply
Chris
Chris
11 years ago

This is all pretty simple. It is very difficult for ordinary retail tenants to afford the rents on the UWS, and the zoning rules do nothing but discourage people from locating here. Why would you – who knows what kind of regs local government will come up with next. So we are left with banks and drug stores.

Honestly I would prefer a well-lit bank walking home from dinner than another boarded up storefront, like the ones that plague Amsterdam and Broadway.

0
Reply
Brian
Brian
11 years ago
Reply to  Chris

No banks are lit up after business hours with the exception of the ATM portion.

0
Reply
Kenneth
Kenneth
11 years ago
Reply to  Brian

Maybe you could get TD Bank at Bway/88 to get back the big illuminated green sign the neighborhood pushed them to remove.

0
Reply
nycissues.org
nycissues.org
11 years ago
Reply to  Kenneth

Bright signage is definitely a no-no on the UWS, it keeps people up at night and reminds residents of Times Square.

0
Reply
AMC
AMC
11 years ago
Reply to  Brian

That’s exactly the impact to the neighborhood vibe. When you walk around the nabe in the evening, it does not feel alive with people eating and socializing, or even walking out of a cute boutique after shopping in the early evening. The banks close and leave vast space eerily void in the evening. It may as well be a creepy Gristedes with plastic bags blowing out front.

0
Reply
nycissues.org
nycissues.org
11 years ago
Reply to  AMC

The residents of the neighborhood are the reason no one is on the street. The UWS is gaining more families that do not socialize in the evening or at night. Even the few 24/7 stores such as Rite Aide, West Side Market and Gristedes do not get much traffic at night. There are no all night movie theaters and few clubs, Lincoln Center has no late show. Night life is also controlled by regulations and citizen noise complaints to police and community board. There just isn’t that much happening after 11PM on the UWS to keep businesses open.

0
Reply
webot
webot
11 years ago
Reply to  Chris

Agree with Chris.

I would like to see someone in the City council address these issues that impede business growth, which benefits the City as a whole.
Honestly, I have NEVER heard a City Council member is general or UWS rep in particular ever actually say anything about promoting business – its as if the idea of being pro business would be political suicide.
Instead of more rules, laws and regulations ( wage increases, sick pay, letter grades, more zoning – all just this year) How about a welcome matt to encourage the very risky idea of opening and/or expanding a business in New York – cutting red tape, eliminating redundant or conflicting requirements (even closing whole agencies) , an omnibudsman to guide a business through all the permitting, prosecution of unions and mafia shack downs, I can go on and on..

City council being pro business is good for the all – providing revenue, jobs, street life, opportunity. It does not negate your liberal credibility.

0
Reply
pjrod
pjrod
11 years ago

Banks are fine. They beat the heck out of big empty storefronts. I’d kill for a nice new bank where the Rite Aid used to be on 96th and Broadway

0
Reply
Christina
Christina
11 years ago
Reply to  pjrod

There’s a nice TD bank on 94th and Bway and a nice HBNC at 96th st. and amsterdam.and a nice Chase bank on 96th St. and another nice Citibank too. Enough with the banks! They are not so nice since overload!

0
Reply

YOU MIGHT LIKE...

20-Year-Old Dies After Stabbing On Broadway; Two Teens Arrested
NEWS

Bicyclist Killed in Central Park After Collision With Pedestrian

June 20, 2025 | 5:33 PM - Updated on June 21, 2025 | 9:35 AM
UWS Weekend: Great Things To Do in the Neighborhood
COLUMNS

UWS Weekend: Great Things To Do In (and Around) the Neighborhood: Movies; Fanatics Fest; Guided Tours of NYC

June 20, 2025 | 7:51 AM
Previous Post

WEEKEND HISTORY: BICYCLING IN THE 19TH CENTURY

Next Post

A MASTER CLASS AND MORE AT JUILLIARD (SPONSORED)

this week's events image
Next Post
A MASTER CLASS AND MORE AT JUILLIARD (SPONSORED)

A MASTER CLASS AND MORE AT JUILLIARD (SPONSORED)

CRAZY SPRING SKY: BRIGHT LIGHTS AND DOUBLE RAINBOWS

CRAZY SPRING SKY: BRIGHT LIGHTS AND DOUBLE RAINBOWS

ROSENTHAL HOLDING UWS TOWN HALL FORUM ON WEDNESDAY

ROSENTHAL HOLDING UWS TOWN HALL FORUM ON WEDNESDAY

  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWSLETTER
  • WSR MERCH!
  • ADVERTISE
  • EVENTS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF USE
  • SITE MAP
Site design by RLDGROUP

© 2025 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • THIS WEEK’S EVENTS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT US
  • WSR SHOP

© 2025 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.