
By Gus Saltonstall
An Upper West Side McDonald’s unexpectedly closed permanently over the weekend.
The McDonald’s at 2726 Broadway, between West 104th and 105th streets, shuttered on October 31, according to a sign on its door.
“This location will be closing permanently on October 31, 2026,” the poster reads. “We thank you for your business and we invite you to visit us at our other McDonald’s.”
There are multiple McDonald’s still open on the Upper West Side, including at 2549 Broadway, between West 95th and 96th streets, along with an outpost at 2049 Broadway, off the corner of West 71st Street. There is also a McDonald’s at West 125th Street and Broadway.
It is unclear why the McDonald’s closed so abruptly. The fast food chain did not immediately respond to West Side Rag’s request for comment.
The McDonald’s at 2726 Broadway has been open since at least 2009, but the Rag was unable to confirm its exact opening year. If anyone in the comments knows the answer to that one.
Subscribe to West Side Rag’s FREE email newsletter here. And you can Support the Rag here.






I saw them taking the sign down on Friday morning. I was thinking that they were just replacing it. I hope the staff got relocated.
You mean the staff for whom Mamdani pledged to raise the minimum wage to $30?
Thus our “affordability” crisis, and higher prices on food trickling down to the consumer. But it’s all Trump’s fault.
NYC Council “Road to $30 by 2030” Proposal
Introduced in the New York City Council (Bill Int. No. 757, the “New York City Minimum Wage Act”), local lawmakers have proposed a separate, aggressive municipal schedule that would phase out tip credits and push city minimum wages much higher:
• Large Employers (over 500 employees nationwide):
• January 1, 2027: $20.00/hour
• January 1, 2028: $23.00/hour
• January 1, 2029: $26.00/hour
• January 1, 2030: $30.00/hour
Small Employers (500 or fewer employees nationwide):
• January 1, 2027: $19.00/hour
• January 1, 2028: $21.50/hour
• January 1, 2029: $24.00/hour
• January 1, 2030: $27.00/hour
• January 1, 2031: $29.00/hour
does this mean we can get rid of tipping finally??
Not until 2030! This is 2026. Focus
Yay ! Great news for the block.
I know right you and I know why!!!! Lol
I’m happy about that particular storefront.
Another empty storefront is “good news?”
Nope! Never good because they are empty for Years. Ridiculous!
How is another vacant store front “great news”?
Why is the closing of a McHomeless Shelter good for the block? Take a wild guess.
No offense but you are showing your NIMBY/
GLP1 , general health awareness among the young, illegal street vending, $15 “value” meal, rents, $20 minimum wage, atrocious service. Welcome to the future.
Totally absurd that you are introducing GLP1 treatments into a real estate issue. Can we not keep totally separate issues … separate???
Typical. I list 10 things and you only see the one.
new york doesnt have a $20 minimum wage dude this makes no sense.
I am sorry but what? I don’t think GLP-1s are a reason why a McDonalds is closing. And people have been well aware of healthy eating for decades and decades – there is a reason why McDonalds added a salad years ago. I think it is more increased competion from other fast food or casual dining places.
It’s a fact. Glp1 has been damaging to food consumption. Not only common sense but thousands of wall street analysts have discussed the subject.
It would bring more business, not less, to McDonald’s with their little hamburgers.
Food, sure. Yes. But if it is due to GLP1s, why is the McDonalds closing and not the Five Guys up the street?
People on GLP1 still eat and think they can eat whatever they want Because they are on the medication.
100%, I can personally attest!
Interesting. Until I went on GLP-1, I would avoid fast food like the plague. Now, I’m not afraid of chocolate shake and a quarter pounder once in a while. Oddly, I don’t even finish them, but that’s find with me! Lost about 70 lbs and have a much more comfortable relationship with food.
Man, I tried the GPL-1 diet for two months on the second month. I almost died. I had to go to emergency room. I was so constipated that if I didn’t go to the emergency room that day I would’ve died and I’m not supposed to take it again because it would just make that reaction happen all over again so people be careful. .
Thanks.
since we are on the subject, you should read https://www.amazon.com/dp/031661274X?lv=shuf&channelId=500&plpRedirect=mhFallback
Yeah, I would imagine people would just eat less of it, no need to binge.
They should close the one on 71st and Amsterdam!
Close ’em all.
That McDangerous is a disgusting convergence point for questionable folk. I would love to see that entire block ripped apart, it is a blight on the neighborhood.
The sad part is that it used to be quite cute years ago, with the spacious Starbucks and benign establishments like Wells Fargo, Pinkberry, Pokebab, and Paris Baguette. Sadly every single one of them closed. And that’s when the decline of that block started, amplified by the pandemic and increased crime.
Ugh. Paris Baguette is a fraudulent chain, another bank. Even McD’s is better than those. Their fried chicken, fish sandwiches, coffee and ice cream is great. Best french fries anywhere. They are affordable!
Hear, hear. I recently stepped inside that one for a snack and it was so crowded and loud that I just turned around and left. It just felt unsafe, for lack of a better word. You really start to understand why there was so much crime in that one, including the shooting a few years ago.
Sorry to burst your bubble but crime happens, shootings happens ALL OVER the Coty. It Has Nothing to do with McDonalds.
Shootings and other violent crime is statistically more likely with the crowd a McDonald’s attracts. The only “bubble” here is denying that correlation.
There was a shooting in there last year on Halloween evening as well. Can’t wait till this place closes
I agree, plus make it something that won’t appeal to a young after-school crowd! Speaking of which, Cafe 71, right across the street was having a lot of issues with the overflow of kids from McDonalds, and then Covid happened. It’s such a good space but I haven’t been over there lately. Does anyone know if it’s still vacant?
Still vacant
Why shouldn’t the after school crowd have a place to hang out?
Would you want your kids hanging out in a place where police are dispatched in flak jackets? Do you not remember when students were temporarily banned from that McD’s and the police had to step in to keep them from harassing patrons at Cafe 71 and the Broadway mall? Who’s supposed to solve that problem if their parents and schools aren’t going to get involved? Our neighborhood reps stood on that same corner demanding delivery bike enforcement, yet I’ve never seen them address any other safety issues in that area. 😣
It is but there have been folks working in there on and off for a while.
Thanks for the info, I hope it’s something amazing!
I am not in favor of empty store fronts, but this McDonalds will not be missed by their neighbors. This store installed extremely loud fans on their roof in the rear of the building, and neighbors have been filing noise complaints and trying to get the owners to stay within legal decibel limits for decades. They actually put up sound baffling that helped somewhat in perhaps 2010 or 2011, but then it was damaged by Hurricane Sandy in 2012 and never repaired in the subsequent 14 year.
When I saw the headline, I was so hoping it would be the one on my corner (71/Broadway). No such luck.
Me too!!
That’s the best one the food is fresh all the time
That’s what I was hoping for as well ugh. Such a disappointment. I hope this trashy place on 71st will close as well.
Thank god! As much as I as I don’t want to see empty storefronts, the crowd there has been creating a lot of trouble.
It appears to have opened in 2006.
https://www.columbiaspectator.com/2006/10/16/mcdonalds-opens-104th-st/
Nothing lost here. I just hope the staff can be relocated.
I can give you a Hint
105th st! Haaaaa
Good, maybe the hood will get something really useful, something we really need. Like a bank, CVS, or Metro PCS store.
Or maybe the building that rents those storefronts will lower the rent and design nice facades and evict McDonald’s and we can have a row of interesting, individually-owned businesses. What a dream.
Haha
There’s a CVS on 103 & Bway & another at 110 & Bway. Do we need one on every block?
bitter laugh
Phone stores are no better
How about a book store?
The was a bookstore nearby. It closed.
Why is it good? Are you gonna eat money bills, medicine or chew a cell phone for your lunch?
McDonald’s doesn’t serve food. Just ultra-processed food-like additictions.
All better than that McD’s. An empty storefront is better
Some people have responded that they’re happy it closed because it was attracting people who were creating trouble. Imagine if we had a 35,000 police force who were actually allowed to police our neighborhoods. Instead, Mayor Dipshit keeps telling them what not to get involved in.
You know Mayor Adams is gone, right?
Lol police never cared. Have you heard the story of them not interfering with a knife suspect because they didn’t want to get hurt. They’re useless
Did all these problems suddenly materialize in the past year?
Can you point to any specific laws that were consistently broken here, and which laws the mayor told the 33,500 uniformed NYPD officers not to get involved in?
I remember when the Mcdonalds opened on 95/96th st in the early 70’s. I was around 10 y.o ,the lines were all the way down to WE Ave. Cheeseburger,fries and soda came to 98 cents. How far we’ve come.
That was a fairly wild location, if not quite up with the “portal to a wacko hell dimension” W. 3rd or “home of the machete fights” Delancey & Essex spots.
It was pretty bad – not as bad as the “Methdonalds” at 8th ave and 35th street but quite dicey being open 24 hours and all . They needed a burly security guard -(like in Times Square) — as for the staff a McDonald’s job can be an entry level job to work in restaurant industry. If the franchisee doesn’t support the staff and create a safe or inviting atmosphere- it won’t thrive.
Not a regular consumer of the Golden Arches product but buy the cheapest breakfast deal now and then – I’m still living ! lol
Fake news. Delaney was a hatchet.
That McDonalds had HVAC problems for years. They have a shelter right around the corner.. and is centrally located where there are a lot of shelters/SRO’s/Projects. They had a tough crowd.. and also homeless people camping outside. It was 24/7 for a while at a point.. so I can imagine the amount of dangerous encounters that’s never made the news. Drugs usage and users camping around the bathrooms. The layout of the store didn’t make it easy for surveillance . There was a point where McDonald’s rewards system was great for saving.. but all those deals disappeared and the menu got expensive.., making it not so affordable much longer for the majority of customer in that particular area.
Why don’t shelters have common living rooms for residents to hang out (when they’re not looking for work, of course). People who have homes don’t get kicked out during the day – why do shelters? If they’re not willing to supervise their residents, shelters shouldn’t be put in.
That location, like most of the McDonalds NYC outposts, was a magnet for crime and disruption. The only “nice” one is the new 125th location which is very clean and modernized.
All of the McDonald’s should be closed they’re selling poison food to the general public. Our government doesn’t care about us only the tax dollars so that they can live lavish lifestyles. Burger King, Wendy’s and all the rest of them too. Europe don’t have the same ingredients as america. Their foods are safer and healthier than here in America. Shut down all of the fast food restaurants.
WHY IS THE STORE CLOSING
You all can rejoice all you want, but i will miss that McDonald,s. It was a great place to get something cheap & quick at all hours without spending twenty dollars. I do not like the McDonald,s at 96th St. They have too many people loitering in there & not enough employees.
I remember when this place first opened, I wanted to use a coupon for a buy one get one free big mac and the girl at the register had a nasty attitude. The issue that this McDonalds suffered from was that the food sometimes was lacking in quality compared to the mcdonalds on 96th st. The food either had old lettuce or was luke warm by the time that I brought it home. The store always had a long wait for food to be prepared, and the floor was always sticky with spilt soda, or the floor was to soaked with it being recently mopped to the point that you felt as if you were going to slip on the floor. The front of the store was constantly occupied with addicts and panhandlers. There’s one individual in particular that was featured in the West Side Rag in August 2025 “green” that hung out in front of that McDonalds that would always make his way to the building that I lived in specifically to the floor that I lived on and would hang out with other addicts and would throw the staircase doors all day and into the middle of the night. green was passed out in my hallway blocking the path to my incinerator one morning and when I filed a complaint with 311, they responded by stating that they don’t deal with those types of matters. As for the McDonalds the delivery app drivers would constantly show up to the counter and try to force the customers out of the way to pick up their delivery order with no regard for the personal space other customers who were waiting for their orders.
2005 was the year 3 yrs after I moved to manhattan
Good riddance. That block has been a disaster for at least a decade. Basically a homeless shelter until the scaffolding recently came down next to McDonalds. I wish the owners of those buildings would engage in some civic duty and allow tenants into those stores that improve the neighborhood. Heck, they might even be profitable.
Sorry to hear this. I have been there maybe once or twice. It was in relatively good shape. I’m not a huge McDonald’s fan but occasionally I crave it and it is nice to have and occasionally it is a good place to take kids. If you use the app you can get good deals – you’re an idiot if you pay full price.
I hate how preachy every here is. Some people lost their jobs. Not good. And not everyone wants to eat super healthy food from non-chains for every meal.
Also, people have to exist somewhere. Sometimes I wish many WSR commenters could experience a short spell of true homelessness and see what it’s like to have everyone treat you like toxic waste wherever you go.
So glad to see this den of criminals and chaos. McDonalds in general needs to clean up their image as a magnet for some of the worst in our communities.
If you know this McDonald’s, you know it’s filled with homeless people and junkies. It’s very hard to eat. Hopefully they find a home or safe space but I understand why the place closed.
The homeless and the addicted are people. Maybe you should get to know them and help them out.
You’ve got to be kidding! Perhaps you can now focus on ‘helping’ folks at the 71st McDonalds.
Mcdonald’s franchise was held by Bruce Colley
Some possible closure reasons
1. Equipment on the roof is severely damaged (roof fans), with several complaints to repair as they were producing excessive noise.
2. Several complaints against the heavy e-bike traffic
3. Targeted union petitions against Colley’s Manhattan location
4. Colley’s West 71st also involved in a lawsuit, possibly that one is also at risk.
Colley has 25 to 30 McDonalds in NY
Can’t say when it opened but can proudly say while I grew up eating McDonald’s as a kid in Wisconsin, I have since 1971 not let a single burger bit, bun crumb or French fry pass my lips. Just my personal protest against manufactured food. 🙂
Damn. I was hoping it was the one on 71st and Amsterdam.
Fyi a new McDonalds is presently being built out on the NW corner of 116th and Lenox.
All McDonald’s & fast food establishments are disgusting for many reasons but mostly because they are totally unhealthy and the smell is so vile; I hold my breath walking past McDonalds. Good Riddance!
Was only a matter of time. No way they were going to survive without the Nut Box next door.
That Nut Box closed years ago. I doubt it affected their business at all
Thank you, God. Close all McDonald’s, Please
It is a shame because of the gentrification and displacement so prevalent in the area already, but to be fair, it’s no great loss. The place was infested with roaches! Sat down to order food with my homie last month and only saw them AFTER I had paid. What luck. The staff was admittedly pretty inept, too. Here’s hoping it doesn’t become another overpriced coffee shop or crepe spot.
I don’t see much compassion here for the homeless/ or nearly so people. So, here’s a question for those of you who live in the immediate neighborhood,: where do the homeless, or other very low – income folks get to buy an already cooked inexpensive meal, now?
Many of these comments seem to have racist undertones. Grow up.
I was waiting a long time down the comments list for someone to point out what was glaringly obvious, at least to two of us – the appalling racism underlying almost every comment. And add in economic elitism as well. Was the criticism really about after-school kids letting off steam after having been cooped up at a desk, or was it that the kids in question weren’t from Cathedral or Trinity?
I lived on W 105 St from Sept 1982 (rental studio betw Bdwy & WEA for 5 yrs, then 1-br co-op 3 doors west of Amsterdam) until we moved to Bklyn in Feb 2001. That McD’s was there most of that time. But so was a decent and cheap pizza joint on the same block, which was, concededly, not elegant in any of its storefronts or menus.
The neighborhood changed a lot over those years. That the boarded-up row houses on the south side of 105 betw Bdwy & Amstrdm became lovely homes, transformed by a local nonprofit through “sweat equity “ and sold below market to local residents, was a big positive. Replacing an unappealing storefront on Bdwy at 105 that sold ugly lingerie made of no materials known in nature, with an insanely overpriced “French” bakery/cafe,!was in theory a major improvement. Unfortunately, it was unaffordable for us to be a daily routine rather than a special occasion treat. Rather, it was a visceral signal that the West Hundreds had joined the rest of Manhattan in the inexorable climb that started with Billionaire Mayor Mike towards a place where only the 1% could live.
Not surprising. I like McD for the odd happy meal for the kiddos and going in there was downright unpleasant. The staff were for the most part either checked out or already on the edge. The clientele in there felt like it was mostly homeless folks or delivery people.
I guess I’ll get the random order of trash food from somewhere else now.
Born in B’lyn, lived on UWS over 60 years! Salvation is my Cabin in the Clouds in the Catskills so far away from the Rats Nest of Constant Bickering over everything that Overcrowding creates! I am so sorry that so many of my WS neighbors must live and dwell in such a “Twilight Zone” episode of depravity! I’m reminded of experiments with Rats fighting over every morsel of limited provisions, space and SANITY! I still love Y’all, despite your constant bickering! LIFE IS REALLY GOOD if you KNOW how to FIND IT! P.S. It’s in front of your RATIONAL nose/eyes and HEART! With Respect and Love, P.
Affordable eating disappears.
Never understood how loser George Costanza was unemployed, had apartment in the city and hot girlfriends.
That McD’s was a crap show. Kiosks broken or didn’t have receipt paper. I would order from the app only to arrive with my order cancelled. Sodas never in stock. No ice! Homeless people walking in and refilling their drinks for free. Constant uber/delivery people butting in line to get their orders in front of customers. I’m happy they’re gone.
It would be the one and only McDonald’s that I use frequently perfect