West Side Rag
  • TOP NEWS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT US
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT
    • GET WSR FREE IN YOUR INBOX
    • SEND US TIPS AND IDEAS
West Side Rag
No Result
View All Result
SUPPORT THE RAG
No Result
View All Result

Favorite WSR Stories

  • Openings & Closings: Settepani at the Davis Center; Bar Manje; Natural Pilates; SoBol; Vive la Crepe
  • The Race to Replace Longtime UWS Leader Jerry Nadler Is Very Crowded
  • A Lifetime on the UWS: A 90-Year-Old Author’s New Memoir Reflects on a Changing New York
Get WSR FREE in your inbox
SUPPORT THE RAG

UWS’ Absolute Bagels Line Changes Direction

April 16, 2024 | 11:16 AM - Updated on April 17, 2024 | 4:25 AM
in ABSURDITY, FOOD
61
The Absolute Bagels line formulating from south of the door, opposed to its longtime north of the door. Photo Credit: Mark Hurst.

By Gus Saltonstall

Change has come to one of the Upper West Side’s most famous lines.

For the past two weekends, Absolute Bagels on Broadway between West 107th and 108th streets, has seen its line form on the southern side of its door, instead of on the usual northern side of the business.

The change is due to the recent closure of the next-door Garden of Eden market at the end of March. With the supermarket’s fruit stands no longer in operation, Absolute Bagel customers have started lining up in the now-empty space underneath the still-standing awning — which is especially helpful on rainy days.

“In fact, the line from Absolute Bagel — which for 20 years has always lined up north outside the shop — today was lined up *south*,” Mark Hurst wrote to West Side Rag on the first weekend after the Garden of Eden closure.

Here’s how the line looked for decades.

The longtime northern side of Absolute Bagels line. Photo Credit: Google Maps.

One Upper West Sider expressed worries that the new line direction would make the in-store experience at Absolute Bagels less efficient.

“You go in a clockwise direction right now in the store, but with the line now going the other way, the people in line are going to be blocking the people trying to leave the store,” Gabriel Kramer-Garcia, a nearby resident of the bagel shop, told the Rag. “It’s already hard enough to get a bagel on a Sunday morning there, now it just got a little harder.”

A different longtime customer kept his analysis of the line direction change brief.

“It changes nothing, there is still a line,” Upper West Sider and Absolute Bagels regular Joey Viviano said.

Subscribe to West Side Rag’s FREE email newsletter here.

Share this article:
SUPPORT THE RAG
Leave a comment

Please limit comments to 150 words and keep them civil and relevant to the article at hand. Comments are closed after six days. Our primary goal is to create a safe and respectful space where a broad spectrum of voices can be heard. We welcome diverse viewpoints and encourage readers to engage critically with one another’s ideas, but never at the expense of civility. Disagreement is expected—even encouraged—but it must be expressed with care and consideration. Comments that take cheap shots, escalate conflict, or veer into ideological warfare detract from the constructive spirit we aim to cultivate. A detailed statement on comments and WSR policy can be read here.

guest

guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

61 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mark Moore
Mark Moore
1 year ago

This is the pinnacle of Upper West Side reporting right here.

136
Reply
Dave
Dave
1 year ago
Reply to  Mark Moore

wahahahahahaha.. 🙂 agreed!

4
Reply
Carmella Ombrella
Carmella Ombrella
1 year ago
Reply to  Mark Moore

Slow news day? 😀

11
Reply
Peter
Peter
1 year ago

My god, the travesty!

12
Reply
Jean
Jean
1 year ago

Gotta love the Westside Rag!

25
Reply
Steve UWS
Steve UWS
1 year ago

When one door closes …

14
Reply
Ish Kabibble
Ish Kabibble
1 year ago

Thanks Trump

11
Reply
Bill H
Bill H
1 year ago

Absolutely the wrong way of good eatin’

3
Reply
marie Ames
marie Ames
1 year ago
Reply to  Bill H

Yes, Bill. I hesitated to say it. Delicious
but too many (400) calories AND little
nutrition; empty calories they say
We eat to stay healthy but this is not the way

1
Reply
Carnival Canticle
Carnival Canticle
1 year ago
Reply to  marie Ames

I bagel to differ.

26
Reply
Meg D
Meg D
1 year ago

I love everything about this piece. The West Side Rag is a great reminder we all live in a bunch of small towns. And people hate change, no matter how small.

50
Reply
Michael Wong
Michael Wong
1 year ago

This belongs on The Onion.

31
Reply
Sid
Sid
1 year ago

It has lined up on the southside every time I’ve gone in the past few years…

0
Reply
Cyrus
Cyrus
1 year ago

I love this article, including the obligatory complaint about the line change of direction. FWIW, I’ll stand in line in the median of the West Side Highway for an Absolute Bagel. Just sayin’

14
Reply
West Ender
West Ender
1 year ago
Reply to  Cyrus

But would you stand *on* line?

3
Reply
neighbor
neighbor
1 year ago

and then the Garden of Eden space will be renter and …

0
Reply
Sarah
Sarah
1 year ago

Not a sparrow falls on the UWS but the Rag is there to report on it, and some alte kakers to complain about it.

17
Reply
Irena
Irena
1 year ago

I actually enjoy this kind of small, story. It’s a break from some of the heavier stuff and in real life, this kind of thing is what people actually talk about. Every piece on WSR doesn’t have to be “breaking” news of monumental import. We get a nice mix here and I enjoy that.

44
Reply
Dave
Dave
1 year ago
Reply to  Irena

Kind of true… but the jokes on the UWSider …. not about lines per se

0
Reply
Sarah
Sarah
1 year ago
Reply to  Irena

Yes, I don’t think most of us are actually complaining. I’m sure it’s pleasant for the Rag staff to report on more trivial occurrences, too.

4
Reply
Dave
Dave
1 year ago
Reply to  Sarah

Yes, it shows their human side, and eliminates any pretense.

2
Reply
Eric
Eric
1 year ago
Reply to  Dave

UWSiders are pretentious enough without help from the WSR.

1
Reply
Getreal
Getreal
1 year ago

If you don’t have a strong opinion on this, you are not really an UWSider..

19
Reply
Irv
Irv
1 year ago
Reply to  Getreal

If “Curb Your Enthusiasm” weren’t over this could be the first episode of year 13. I may have to start at “spite” bagel shop in response.

6
Reply
Seen It All
Seen It All
1 year ago
Reply to  Irv

Or Seinfeld! It just screams Seinfeld to me. I can imagine a whole episode around this. George complaining and Kramer having a major freak out.

12
Reply
Yamo
Yamo
1 year ago
Reply to  Seen It All

Maybe this is the bagel shop where Kramer worked, other than a 13 year strike!

0
Reply
Andrew
Andrew
1 year ago

With regard to the direction of the line, the only relevant information is whether |Bagels| = Bagels.

8
Reply
J Bean
J Bean
1 year ago
Reply to  Andrew

|Bagels| > Bagels

7
Reply
Leanne Hymes
Leanne Hymes
1 year ago

the fact you needed a google maps pic to show this is the real shame

4
Reply
wombatNYC
wombatNYC
1 year ago

I feel sorry for whoever lives in the apartment above. The smell might be great but the noise and rodents, not so much

2
Reply
Sarah
Sarah
1 year ago

This is such an archetypal WSR article that the only thing missing is the obligatory comment complaining about dangerous cyclists riding their bikes on the sidewalk. And these remain the best bagels in the city, if not the world!

14
Reply
Alexandra Horowitz
Alexandra Horowitz
1 year ago

ha! I love this. hyperlocal news. Thanks, Gus.

10
Reply
ScienceGuy
ScienceGuy
1 year ago

I believe thats how they line up for bagels in the southern hemisphere..

24
Reply
Martin
Martin
1 year ago

It’s Gale Brewer’s fault.

10
Reply
Raleigh Mayer
Raleigh Mayer
1 year ago

I’ve always wondered what it would be like to live in a small town.
Now I know .
(And I like it.)

4
Reply
BillW
BillW
1 year ago

Columbia Bagels was always my favorite in the Broadway bagel wars. It was open 24 hours and you could always get hot ones. I just never warmed up to Absolute.

6
Reply
first name unknown
first name unknown
1 year ago
Reply to  BillW

If you really go back that far, You must remeber the bar next door. — The Marlin. It was sort of like the current Dublin House on 79th, but with beer that cost $1. Lots of Columbia kids in there. Great Juke-box too.

2
Reply
BillW
BillW
1 year ago
Reply to  first name unknown

Almost – my friends all knew the Marlin. I think when I moved to the area, it was gone. There was a good Vietnamese restaurant. We went to the Abbey, Night Cafe, later the Ding Dong. Sadly no decent dive bars left other than the actual Dive Bars.

1
Reply
Sarah
Sarah
1 year ago
Reply to  first name unknown

I remember when the Marlin turned into a Mailboxes Etc.!

1
Reply
Sarah
Sarah
1 year ago
Reply to  BillW

I was a big Columbia Bagels fan too, back in the old WSM building days (though I sure don’t miss Dynasty!) . I especially liked the fact that Zabar’s got their bagels from them.

It took the closing of Columbia Bagels to send me down to Absolute, but I realized what I had been missing and I’ve been a raving convert since then. One door closes, a bagel hole opens!

2
Reply
BillW
BillW
1 year ago
Reply to  Sarah

Ah, Die Nasty! OK, I’ll try Absolute again. But my secret go to are the Bialys West Side Market gets.

1
Reply
ted
ted
1 year ago
Reply to  BillW

I miss Columbia Bagels. The guy and gal who were there during the day were great.

2
Reply
Roxy
Roxy
1 year ago

The real issue here is – as controversial as this may sound- are these bagels worth the wait? Yes they’re good but that much better than say Tals on 90th or even Wu and Nussbaum on 113 and Broadway?

6
Reply
steve
steve
1 year ago
Reply to  Roxy

Very, very few things are worth that sort of wait, and bagels – even transcendentally magnificent ones – are not one of those things. I know that people have priorities, but is having a life one of them? Seriously, what is wrong with these people?

0
Reply
Sarah
Sarah
1 year ago
Reply to  Roxy

YES. Yes, they are. They are phenomenal, and while I enjoy Wu and Nussbaum plenty, Absolute is on another level.

6
Reply
ASIL
ASIL
1 year ago
Reply to  Sarah

I agree and go on off hours

7
Reply
Bill Williams
Bill Williams
1 year ago

Instead of worrying about which way the line is going, they should be worrying about why they line up for a nothing special bagel.

11
Reply
JustSayin
JustSayin
1 year ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

You’ll get flamed, but you’re 100% right. No better than many of the other bagel spots in the area. Certainly not worth a 30 min+ wait.

10
Reply
Corbin
Corbin
1 year ago
Reply to  JustSayin

You two must not like bagels very much

2
Reply
ASIL
ASIL
1 year ago

This is a cool story because sometimes people don’t understand that you can live in a big city but in a small neighborhood where people understand this. They love us, always so gracious and lovely to the customers. Their smiles are contagious.

8
Reply
JTJT
JTJT
1 year ago
Reply to  ASIL

I live a “couple towns over” – 116th in Harlem – and when in the area we try to stop by.

My kid actually damaged his braces on one of their bagels last summer, and still wants to go back.

2
Reply
Carol
Carol
1 year ago

Hilarious! Thank you!

4
Reply
Deb
Deb
1 year ago

Wonderful dramatic title. I love it.

2
Reply
The Waterboy
The Waterboy
1 year ago

This is about the level of drama I can stand these days when it comes to the news. Bravo, WSR!

3
Reply
The Waterboy
The Waterboy
1 year ago

I would also add: indisputably the best bagels in the city.

2
Reply
Laura
Laura
1 year ago

People poking fun of this coverage but when I saw the headline, I said “whoa!” out loud. Would’ve appreciated even a little more reporting: Did Absolute staff institute the change? Did it happen organically?

3
Reply
KevDog
KevDog
1 year ago

Bravo WSR! This article represents why I follow every week!

1
Reply
Mike Hooper
Mike Hooper
1 year ago

I suggested that they had plans to expand into the now empty store and stay open 24 hours a day – that got a real laugh from the Absolute Staff! They really are THE BEST!

1
Reply
Daniel Dubno
Daniel Dubno
1 year ago

The bagels are very good. It is absolutely tragic that Absolute Bagels is the only decent bagel place on the Upper West Side. They know what they’re doing… everybody else forgot, never knew, or died. A shonda.

0
Reply
Sal
Sal
1 year ago

Perfectly constructed and ENTERTAINING reporting, Gus….!! You made me laugh out loud…. We have LOVED Absolute Bagels since they opened…. and though we will miss Garden of Eden, we’re glad the weekend liner-uppers will be a bit more protected from the elements. And YES, they are THAT GOOD….!!

2
Reply
Mike
Mike
1 year ago

This is really interesting

0
Reply

YOU MIGHT LIKE...

Ruthless Advice for Upper West Siders: All of the Answers With None of the Expertise
ABSURDITY

Ruthless Advice for Upper West Siders: All of the Answers With None of the Expertise

January 6, 2026 | 8:30 AM
More Changes to the Upper West Side
ABSURDITY

More Changes to the Upper West Side

January 4, 2026 | 9:33 AM
Previous Post

UPDATE: Suspect Named In Teenage Girl UWS Attempted Rape Case, NYPD

Next Post

Summer on the Hudson 2024 Kicks Off May 1: Lots of Free UWS Events

this week's events image
Next Post
Summer on the Hudson 2024 Kicks Off May 1: Lots of Free UWS Events

Summer on the Hudson 2024 Kicks Off May 1: Lots of Free UWS Events

Why Well-Paid Maids is Committed to Using Safe Cleaning Products

Why Well-Paid Maids is Committed to Using Safe Cleaning Products

UWS School Continues To Fight Unwanted Relocation Ahead Of Final Vote

UWS School Continues To Fight Unwanted Relocation Ahead Of Final Vote

  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWSLETTER
  • WSR MERCH!
  • ADVERTISE
  • EVENTS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF USE
  • SITE MAP
Site design by RLDGROUP

© 2026 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • THIS WEEK’S EVENTS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT US
    • GET WSR FREE IN YOUR INBOX
    • SEND US TIPS AND IDEAS
  • WSR SHOP

© 2026 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.