West Side Rag
  • TOP NEWS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • CONTACT
  • TOP NEWS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • CONTACT
West Side Rag
No Result
View All Result
Get WSR FREE in your inbox

Search the site

No Result
View All Result

Get WSR FREE in your inbox

More Siblings Will Get Priority for Middle School Admission — But Is It Fair to Only Children?

April 22, 2022 | 12:54 PM
in NEWS, SCHOOLS
11
MS 54, Booker T Washington, 103 W 107th St, via NYC DOE.

By Julia Stern

At a District 3 Community Education Committee (CEC3) meeting earlier this month on Zoom, representatives from the Department of Education (DOE) described plans to expand sibling priority in middle school admissions in order to keep families together.

Present at the meeting were Superintendent Christine Loughlin, Chief Enrollment Officer Sarah Kleinhandler, Executive Director Amy Basile, and Senior Director of Middle School Admissions Matthew Broggini.

Mr. Broggini explained that before this new expansion, only applicants who were siblings of current sixth-graders would receive sibling priority. Now, at schools where the final year is eighth grade, the DOE has expanded priority to middle school applicants with siblings in sixth or seventh grade.

For schools that continue through twelfth grade, middle school applicants with siblings in grades six through eleventh now have priority.

Priority applies to full siblings, half-siblings, step-siblings and foster siblings residing in the same household as the applicant.

The new policy covers the current admissions cycle for the 2022-2023 school year.

During the Q&A portion of a meeting, one parent asked, “Are there insights about how prioritizing keeping middle school siblings together affects diversity and equity?”

Mr. Broggini said that exact data was not currently available, but eliminating screening criteria and relying on the lottery system has made schools better reflect the diversity of the district. He affirmed that the DOE remains committed to equitable practices, but did not provide data about whether sibling priority expansions would limit diversity.

Another parent worried that the new sibling-priority expansion would disadvantage children without siblings, and jokingly asked to create a support group for her only child navigating the admissions process. This parent also expressed frustration about the policy changing after applications for middle schools closed, as they were not aware of the new expansion during the application process.

The meeting ended with another parent describing how demoralizing this year of middle school admissions was. “It feels like The Hunger Games,” she said.

guest
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

11 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Carlos
Carlos
3 months ago

The parent of an only child who was frustrated that this happened after the process closed clearly does not understand the process. You list the schools in your order of priority. They pull the names from the lottery. When they pull your name, they go down your list and place your child at the first available school on your list.

There is no way to game the system and there is nothing to do other than just list the schools in your order of preference. So this has absolutely no impact from that perspective.

0
Reply
Brandon
Brandon
3 months ago
Reply to  Carlos

Carlos,
What you have described doesn’t mention siblings at all. How does the new sibling priority come into play?

0
Reply
Carlos
Carlos
3 months ago
Reply to  Brandon

The sibling policy likely slightly decreases the odds of getting into some of the more desirable schools.

However, when making your list, the odds of getting into a school should not matter. You should still list them in your order of preference, as once they pull your number, they just go down your list.

So knowing that your odds have changed slightly makes absolutely no difference when making your list. As much as I have issues with the new process, it is incredibly straight-forward and people are over-complicating it.

0
Reply
Brandon
Brandon
3 months ago
Reply to  Carlos

Can you explain, or give me a link, that explains how it works? If it is still a lottery when a child’s name is drawn the school his sibling attends either has open spots or it doesn’t. So sibling priority can’t work within that system. OTOH, if they do the lottey first for siblings and fill many seats in desirable schools before first born and only children have their lottery, that would seem to be a big decrease in the odds of getting in.

I have looked on the DOE site and they just say “sibling priority is expanding to middle schools” without an explanation that I can find.

0
Reply
Carlos
Carlos
3 months ago
Reply to  Brandon

Brandon:
There are two issues here:
1. I raised the question of how this impacts parents of only children in the process of completing their list. As I explained above, it should have zero impact. They should make their list based solely on their order of preference, and the odds of getting into the school should not factor into that ordering.

2. As far as the question you raised about how the mechanics work for parents of siblings, I don’t know and that is a good question. In their case, how they order things might make a difference. I can make some educated guesses but don’t want to muddy things further. Hopefully there will be clear instructions. The DOE also should not just assume that all siblings want to attend the same school – I’m guessing most do, but there are plenty who do not so that optionality should be included.

0
Reply
Beth
Beth
3 months ago
Reply to  Carlos

I agree. In my experience the number of children in a family is not a significant factor. What is problematic is the instinctive response some adults have to blame a sibling for the possibility that their child might not get into their desired school. Not like this is new, but this impulse is really offensive. Adults are in charge of the DOE (or at least we like to think they are adults), so to blame children for their actions is pathetic in my opinion.

0
Reply
Leon
Leon
3 months ago

This has almost no impact on equity. I wish people would stop obsessing over “equity” and instead obsess over bringing the weaker schools up to the level of the stronger schools (rather than bringing the stronger schools down to the level of the weaker schools).

The revised middle school process has just created more confusion. The populations of the schools haven’t changed very much, except there are now more misplaced kids either because the parents didn’t understand the process or they got shut out of their top choice. And it is ridiculous how late decisions come out – this should be resolved by February or March – it’s not that hard.

0
Reply
Tnic
Tnic
3 months ago

Can the first child join that suggested support group for only children? For the purposes of this policy they are treated the same as an only child.

And did the parent who suggested that group ever consider what it’s like to take two or three kids to two or three different schools? Those are the families that could use some support.

0
Reply
Juan
Juan
3 months ago
Reply to  Tnic

Though I won’t benefit from it, I am supportive of the sibling policy. That being said, I get really annoyed by people with multiple kids (especially those with three or more) who complain about how hard it is. No one forced them to have multiple kids.

0
Reply
Tnic
Tnic
3 months ago
Reply to  Juan

Apologies if my agreeing with the policy with a touch of sarcasm, was read as a complaint about having more than one child. And yes by middle school kids can travel by themselves, I should have used the word “attend” not “take” to mean the entire experience of supporting 2-3 schools, attending functions, fund raisers, etc and being involved parents in making the school a community. This new policy seems wise from that perspective.

0
Reply
Anon
Anon
3 months ago
Reply to  Tnic

Don’t kids travel to middle school without parents?

0
Reply

YOU MIGHT LIKE...

Here’s the Dish: Zaad’s Falafal Sandwich
COLUMNS

Here’s the Dish: Zaad’s Falafal Sandwich

August 16, 2022 | 12:29 PM
Upper West Side Real Estate Market Bulletin, August 2022 Edition
NEWS

Upper West Side Real Estate Market Bulletin, August 2022 Edition

August 16, 2022 | 11:32 AM
0
SHARES
62
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Previous Post

Silver Stars Fitness: Learn How To Relieve Achy Feet!

Next Post

To Celebrate Earth Day: An Incomplete List of Sustainable Stores on the UWS

this week's events image

Explore Your Favorite Subject

20th precinct 24th precinct american museum of natural history animals art bicycling bulletin central park closings columns community board 7 coronavirus crash crime development dogs events fdny fire food gale brewer helen rosenthal history jcc lincoln center monday bulletin morning bulletin nypd openings pedestrian safety photography photos politics public schools pupper west side real estate restaurants retail riverside park silver stars fitness snow sponsored subway upper west side uws

CITY NEWS

Brick Underground
City Limits
Eater
Gothamist
NY Daily News
NY Post
NY Times

LOCAL RESOURCES

Bloomingdale Neighborhood History Group
Central Park Conservancy
CB7
Community Education Council 3
Assembly District 67
The New York Historical Society
Riverside Park
West End Preservation

UWS Blogs

Bloomingdale History Central Park Blogger
North River Notes
Next Post
To Celebrate Earth Day: An Incomplete List of Sustainable Stores on the UWS

To Celebrate Earth Day: An Incomplete List of Sustainable Stores on the UWS

MAN ARRESTED FOR SEXUAL ABUSE OF A CHILD IN RIVERSIDE PARK

Prepare for an Arts-Filled Season in Neighborhood Parks

UWS Resident Charged in Subway Hammer Attack and Duane Reade Robbery on 111th St. – NYPD

Suspect Arrested For Recent String of Armed Robberies on the UWS

  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • ADVERTISE WITH US
  • THIS WEEK’S EVENTS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF USE
  • SITE MAP
Site design by RLDGROUP

© 2022 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • THIS WEEK’S EVENTS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • CONTACT US

© 2022 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.