West Side Rag
  • TOP NEWS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT US
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT
West Side Rag
No Result
View All Result
SUPPORT THE RAG

Search the site

No Result
View All Result
Get WSR FREE in your inbox
SUPPORT THE RAG

Police Say Neighbor is ‘Person of Interest’ in Homicide

October 23, 2018 | 7:59 AM
in NEWS
34

Police investigating the homicide of Sue Trott say that a neighbor of Trott’s at 710 West End Avenue is considered a “person of interest” in the case.

“We believe that all the pieces of that puzzle are in that building,” Dermot Shea, the chief of detectives for the New York Police Department, told reporters.

Police did not name the person. The building between 94th and 95th Streets has a doorman and security cameras, and police say no one had signed into the building to see Trott, according to the Times.

Trott, who was 70, was found Sunday in her apartment with her throat slashed. She was a copywriter who had risen up in the male-dominated advertising world, the Times reported. She was inspirational to younger women in the field.

She was also known for loving and caring for animals, even starting her own dog-rescue organization. Trott would spread bird seed in the area — a practice that sometimes frustrated neighbors who thought it also brought rats to the area.

Aaron Biller, president of the local Neighborhood in the Nineties group, called Trott “a controversial figure in the neighborhood” because of her practice of spreading bird seed. “Susan was the “Bird Lady of the West 90s,” so called because she drew the ire of many in the neighborhood due to her passion and methodology for feeding birds, which undermined the City’s rat population control efforts,” he wrote in an email to us.

Others said that Trott was a popular neighborhood figure.

“Everyone loved her,” neighbor Cristine Delgado, 50, who occasionally walked with Trott at Riverside Park, told the Post. “She’s very, very friendly and protects animals.”

Share this article:
SUPPORT THE RAG
guest

guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

34 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kaz
Kaz
6 years ago

Biller’s comment seems like a weird, unnecessary dig at a woman who was just murdered.

0
Reply
Bandy
Bandy
6 years ago
Reply to  Kaz

Sounds like he is just being honest. Stating facts doesn’t mean he doesnt feel badly she was murdered. Do we know this is the only thing he said in his email? It’s an excerpt.

0
Reply
J
J
6 years ago
Reply to  Kaz

The first NYT article also had some unkind words about her from a different neighbor. Let’s be better to one another!

0
Reply
Sarah
Sarah
6 years ago

I share in the masses’ disdain for people who feed birds in the neighborhood, but this woman was murdered… have you no respect? Is it really necessary to spend so much of this “update” painting such a negative picture of this woman? One sentence about her accomplishments and the rest just entirely unnecessary and immature…

0
Reply
West Sider
Author
West Sider
6 years ago
Reply to  Sarah

Fair point, we’ve added more information about her.

0
Reply
geoff
geoff
6 years ago

this reads as if mr biller did not know ms trott well at all, despite his claim.

it reads like a textbook complaint to 311.

what gives, mr biller? plenty of good riddance?

and why, west side rag, would you stop at this?

0
Reply
Susan Kagan
Susan Kagan
6 years ago

“So shines a good deed in a naughty world ..” (Shakespeare)

0
Reply
Jean Mensing
Jean Mensing
6 years ago
Reply to  Susan Kagan

Shakespeare knew it all. Good quote from Susan Kagan

0
Reply
Freddie Katz
Freddie Katz
6 years ago

She was a lovely little pink and blonde eccentric always smiling wheeling her dog in the stroller. Who knew she was so accomplished? This whole discussion is laughably like the UWS, swwet eccentrics and curmudgeonly rats making the perfext ecosystem. That this little smiling lady had her throat slashed—and by a nighbor?!?— is unthinkable. May she rest in peace. I will miss our pleasant exchanges.

0
Reply
Scott Schaffer
Scott Schaffer
6 years ago

Printing Mr. Biller’s comment proves that this website is true to its name, a “rag”.

0
Reply
ScooterStan
ScooterStan
6 years ago
Reply to  Scott Schaffer

This excellent and carefully-edited local blog is a “rag” just because it dared to print a negative comment?

The WSR is NOT intended to be a “Hagiography” (look it up). It is a NEWS site, and had it left out that slightly-negative comment about Ms. Trott, any number of its vigilant readers would have done a “Gotcha” comment for ignoring that fact.

You may recall that a certain president’s favorite “news” station is Fox-News, which laughingly called it self “Fair and Balanced”. Which is what news’ sources must be, presenting BOTH sides of a story, WITH attribution.

Unless, of course, you agree with that certain president and his clueless “base” in calling a free press “The Enemy of the People”

0
Reply
Westside Mimi
Westside Mimi
6 years ago

For the folks who are throwing shade on this poor woman, she did not deserve to be murdered, no matter how eccentric and annoying.

0
Reply
Chrigid
Chrigid
6 years ago

I think it’s kinda refreshing to have a mixed-bag description of her, like she was human and different people had different relationships with her (although one mention of birdseed/rats might have been enough).

0
Reply
leticia
leticia
6 years ago

One of the neighbors, a older female, made nasty comments about Trott on CBS news. People have no respect, the woman was murdered.

0
Reply
Ed
Ed
6 years ago

The negative background information is particularly relevant, because it could be a motive for the murder. A rat-hating neighbor may have had enough.

0
Reply
Steen
Steen
6 years ago
Reply to  Ed

Yes, Ed, that’s what I thought as well. I did not get the sense that people were denigrating her because of her habits, but trying to verbalize what might have caused someone to murder her. Obviously, it came out as being spiteful to some people, but I didn’t see it that way–it felt more like their minds were casting about for a “why,” which is a total human reaction to a horrifying thing.

0
Reply
dannyboy
dannyboy
6 years ago
Reply to  Ed

Ed, Very practical advice, that I will take to heart.

If I find myself in a situation where there’s been a murder, I will be sure not to make myself a suspect by providing the investigators with probable motive.

In this particular case, I believe it is the media that is exaggerating the negative impressions express by Ms Trott’s neighbors.

My wife was interviewed by the press about her reactions. They baited the interview with questions like “Doesn’t this incident make you afraid?” Of course they baited the wrong person, as she pointed out the stinkiness of that question coming from a journalist. The journalist wanted a story, but couldn’t get one from her.

0
Reply
Ed
Ed
6 years ago
Reply to  dannyboy

Yes Dannyboy, murderers often become suspects by pointing out their motives to the police. That has happened almost never.

0
Reply
dannyboy
dannyboy
6 years ago
Reply to  Ed

We disagree and I am correct.

Sorry

Next time.

0
Reply
Bill
Bill
6 years ago
Reply to  dannyboy

Had the exact same experience from a TV interviewer.
Asked, “Aren’t you scared?” Answered firmly NO.

0
Reply
dannyboy
dannyboy
6 years ago
Reply to  Bill

Good for you Bill.

I feel that these reporters do little investigative reporting and, at the same time, want to scoop their competition with immediate articles.

The results of that, as we see in this case, is that they report on the neighbors’ critique of the victim and look for an angle like “UWS is Terrified”.

I disdain this reporting because it replaces the ‘Who/What/When/Where and Why’ with sensationalism.

0
Reply
GetAGrip
GetAGrip
6 years ago

Unbelievable that some people can be so small and heartless and petty as to hold grudges over BIRD SEED when this beautiful and kind soul just had her life taken from her. Just unbelievable. And by the way people who begrudge the natural pleasures of feeding the birds are useless human beings as far as I am concerned. Go live in a concrete box where neither sweet elderly heros nor birdsong will “ruin” your days . . .

0
Reply
EricaC
EricaC
6 years ago
Reply to  GetAGrip

We should separate the rightness or wrongness of spreading birdseed from the rightness or wrongness of focusing so deeply on that when a woman has been murdered. Putting out seeds for birds in a rat-infested area is wrong for many reasons. But compared to being murdered – not even on the same scale. And if the worst that can be said about Ms. Trott is that she let her zeal for helping animals outweigh her concern for her neighbors objections, she did much better than many of us. I am very sorry that this happened to her, and I hope they catch the perpetrator and imprison him or her for life. How terrible.

0
Reply
Louise
Louise
6 years ago

If she was killed over birdseed and “eccentricity” — then we certainly are in bad shape as a society. What a tragedy.

0
Reply
Anonymouse
Anonymouse
6 years ago

Aren’t y’all jumping to conclusions to assume this poor woman was murdered because of feeding birds? It could be a myriad of reasons and no reason at all. People do crazy and nefarious things all the time here in the Naked City. Let’s wait till the experts and NYPD finish their CSI – they’ve already collected evidence in the apartment.

0
Reply
Bruce E. Bernstein
Bruce E. Bernstein
6 years ago

Aaron Biller continued his campaign of gross insensitivity with negative personal remarks in today’s NY times article.

Feeding the birds, including pigeons, is a time-honored NYC practice. i’ve never heard anyone complain about it before. it seems like Biller wants to modify our behavior; he wants the whole neighborhood to behave like a bunch of suburban Stepford Wives.

RIP Susan Trott; i am confident that your unique personality was appreciated by most of your neighbors.

0
Reply
JR
JR
6 years ago
Reply to  Bruce E. Bernstein

Regularly scattering 15 lb. bags of birdseed at midnight is not a nyc tradition.

0
Reply
Ed
Ed
6 years ago

Update from the NYT here:

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/23/nyregion/upper-west-side-murder-susan-trott.html

Trott reported being threatened and harassed by neighbors due to her spreading of birdseed throughout the neighborhood.

0
Reply
sylvia
sylvia
6 years ago

That was no reason to kill her sad ppl are crazy ready to kill for nothing R.I.P.

0
Reply
Manny
Manny
6 years ago

She was such a sweet lady! She had rescued an elderly dog, and was the most patient and loving person ever with him. I ran into her again after her dog passed, and she was just walking in the park, made a lovely comment about the dogs I was walking, & was sad but trying to be positive & happy. I didn’t know her well at all, just the occasional similar park interaction, but the way she treated that old white rescue dog – the love and care she showed him, the patience she had with him – was remarkable. I am so sad this happened to her!! My condolences to her friends & family.

0
Reply
John McCabe MD
John McCabe MD
6 years ago

The lack of followup information on this subject is deafening!

0
Reply
Priscilla
Priscilla
6 years ago

I am curious to know if Trott ever filed a complaint against the neighbor for harassing her, or vice versa. Seems like there must to be history before such a horrible event. I hope the 24th provides updated info.

I’ve had a problem with a neighbor and went to the 20th twice but they didn’t do anything except take a complaint. This story is very unsettling.

0
Reply
Galpal
Galpal
6 years ago

All this speculation could be addressed if there didn’t seem to be a gag order on relevant information. A neighbor is currently undergoing psychiatric evaluation yet, no other details have been released. Last update three days ago said that the police had not yet questioned her, a women in her 20’s. Why have her name and circumstances not been released. Money? When the brutal slaying of children by a nanny shocked the UWS, her name was released immediately. She was taken into custody then evaluated, I believe. Does someone have their finger on the scale? This poor woman was murdered in her home. SHE deserves justice!

0
Reply
Juan
Juan
6 years ago
Reply to  Galpal

Why is it your business who did this? The curious side of me wants to know, but if they are choosing not to release the name, that is fine. In the case of the murdering nanny, the police were 100% sure who did it. Based on the limited information available, this seems like a very likely suspect, but there is no certainty. I would rather the police spend their time investigating the case then providing information to neighborhood yentas.

0
Reply

YOU MIGHT LIKE...

20-Year-Old Dies After Stabbing On Broadway; Two Teens Arrested
NEWS

Bicyclist Killed in Central Park After Collision With Pedestrian

June 20, 2025 | 5:33 PM
UWS Weekend: Great Things To Do in the Neighborhood
COLUMNS

UWS Weekend: Great Things To Do In (and Around) the Neighborhood: Movies; Fanatics Fest; Guided Tours of NYC

June 20, 2025 | 7:51 AM
Previous Post

No Longer Nameless, Neil Harris Jr. Will Be Remembered in a Memorial Service With His Family Next Month

Next Post

Openings & Closings: Voila Chocolat, West Side YogaWorks, Pilates House

this week's events image
Next Post
Openings & Closings: Voila Chocolat, West Side YogaWorks, Pilates House

Openings & Closings: Voila Chocolat, West Side YogaWorks, Pilates House

Photos of the Day: Dramatic Clouds and a Rainbow

Photos of the Day: Dramatic Clouds and a Rainbow

Win an UppaBaby at the JCC’s Bump Bash

Win an UppaBaby at the JCC's Bump Bash

  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWSLETTER
  • WSR MERCH!
  • ADVERTISE
  • EVENTS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF USE
  • SITE MAP
Site design by RLDGROUP

© 2025 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • THIS WEEK’S EVENTS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT US
  • WSR SHOP

© 2025 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.