West Side Rag
  • TOP NEWS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT US
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT
    • ADVERTISE
    • GET WSR FREE IN YOUR INBOX
    • SEND US TIPS AND IDEAS
West Side Rag
No Result
View All Result

No Result
View All Result

Favorite WSR Stories

  • The Ongoing Elevator Saga Unfolding in a 17-Story Upper West Side Building
  • The Curious Case of the White Rolls Royce Parked on an Upper West Side Block
SUPPORT THE RAG
Get the neighborhood news that matters.
Sign up for our free newsletter

UPDATE: Cease and Desist Order Issued; Upper West Side Barn Owls’ Water Tower Home Loses its Roof

October 29, 2026 | 4:46 PM - Updated on October 30, 2026 | 1:50 PM
in NEWS, OUTDOORS
67
The water tower where the UWS Barn owls nested no longer has a roof. Photo by Jacqueline Emery.

UPDATE: Friday, October 30 at 1:30 p.m.: Police, authorities from New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, and elected officials converged Friday afternoon at the building home to the water tower where a family of Barn owls has nested for the past month.

The building management was served with a cease and desist for any work connected to the water tower, an employee from the NYC Bird Alliance told West Side Rag. On Thursday, the building was given a verbal warning related to continuing work, but workers returned to the water tower on Friday.

Despite orders yesterday from the NYS DEC to cease work on this Upper West Side water tank, several workers appeared earlier today and lifted this wood panel onto the top of the tank and did other work. The DEC is here again. https://t.co/gXP98IMxzt

— Manhattan Bird Alert (@BirdCentralPark) October 30, 2026

NYPD officers entered the Upper West Side building on Friday, while a group led by Manhattan Borough President Brad-Hoylman Sigal and State Senator Erik Bottcher attempted to get answers outside of the front door.

The Barn owls were seen Thursday night on and around the water tower.

This remains a developing situation, please check back in for updates.

Police officers stationed outside of the Upper West Side building. Photo by Gus Saltonstall.
Original Story

By Gus Saltonstall

It appears there has been an eviction attempt involving some of the Upper West Side’s most famous new residents.

On Thursday, the roof of the water tower of a building on West 75th Street, between Columbus and Central Park West, where a family of Barn owls has nested since the beginning of October, was removed.

“Upon visiting the UWS barn owl roost today, I noticed that the roof had been removed from the water tower,” an anonymous tipster wrote to West Side Rag on Thursday. “There were no owls in sight.”

Jacqueline Emery, a well-known wildlife photographer, also sent in photos of a man taking the roof off of the tower.

A man taking off the roof of the water tower. Photo by Jacqueline Emery.

“Such a disappointing and deeply concerning turn of events!” Emery wrote to the Rag. “We’re worried about the family, especially the owlets. One of them appears to be perching out in the open on a rooftop — not a safe place for a young owl.”

Here is what the water tower with the owls looked like prior to the roof removal.

5 Barn Owls on an Upper West Side water tower! 🦉🦉🦉🦉🦉What an incredible Manhattan moment! So grateful to witness such fabulous wildlife right here in our city. See my previous post for a close-up!

#birdcpp, #NYCWildlife, #UrbanWildlife, #NYC https://t.co/2IMouFGwnd

— Anke Frohlich Photography (@_AnkeFrohlich) October 10, 2026

As mentioned by the popular social media account, Manhattan Bird Alert, there are laws against taking apart bird nests in New York State. Specifically, active nests of migratory birds are protected under federal and state law, and destroying one without a permit is prohibited. However, the details and reasoning for the roof removal of the Upper West Side water tower remain unclear as of Thursday at 4 p.m.

On Wednesday, J.F. Grossen sent in a video to WSR showing some sort of torch work that produced flames directly underneath the owls’ nest within the water tower. Now, a day later, the roof to the water tower is gone.

Video shared with West Side Rag shows torch work that happened on Wednesday, which produced flames and smoke directly underneath the Barn Owls’ nest on the Upper West Side.

Now, a day later, the roof is gone.

Video by J.F. Grossen https://t.co/fVbkb6wWqG

— Gus Saltonstall (@GusSaltonstall) October 29, 2026

It is also unclear if the owls will vacate the water tower now that the protective roof is gone.

“New Yorkers have spent the past month falling in love with this owl family, and we share their anguish and outrage today,” said Jessica Wilson, Executive Director of NYC Bird Alliance, in a news release. “We’re asking that all work stop now so these owls have every chance to survive, and we’ll keep working with building management, as well as state and federal wildlife officials to make sure they’re protected.”

Following West Side Rag’s first report about the Upper West Side Barn owls, their popularity has swept across the country. The family consists of two adult Barn owls and up to six owlets. The story of the neighborhood newcomers was covered by The New York Times, NPR, Smithsonian Magazine, and others.

Barn owls are incredibly rare in New York City.

This is a developing story, please check back in for updates.

Read More:

  • The Late-Night Birders Flocking to the UWS To Capture a Shot of the Resident Barn Owl Family
  • Multiple Barn Owls Possibly Spotted in Upper West Side Building Courtyard
  • Barn Owl Spotted Outside of Upper West Side Buildings: ‘Extremely Rare in NYC’

Subscribe to West Side Rag’s FREE email newsletter here. And you can Support the Rag here.

Share this article:
SUPPORT THE RAG
Leave a comment

Please limit comments to 150 words and keep them civil and relevant to the article at hand. Comments are closed after six days. Our primary goal is to create a safe and respectful space where a broad spectrum of voices can be heard. We welcome diverse viewpoints and encourage readers to engage critically with one another’s ideas, but never at the expense of civility. Disagreement is expected—even encouraged—but it must be expressed with care and consideration. Comments that take cheap shots, escalate conflict, or veer into ideological warfare detract from the constructive spirit we aim to cultivate. A detailed statement on comments and WSR policy can be read here.

guest

guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

67 Comments
Bill Williams
Bill Williams
20 days ago

water tanks require regular mandated by the city maintenence and inspection. They also sometimes need to be replaced. Normally the work is done internally so the roof removal and use of welding torches would indicate structural issues.

10
Reply
amm
amm
18 days ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

This water tower had been decommissioned.

4
Reply
Carmella Ombrella
Carmella Ombrella
19 days ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

Our building has a similar water tower which requires dismantling and rebuilding periodically as the wood deteriorates. The first step in this process is removing the “roof.” It’s a big job, usually done by a specialist like the Rosenwach Company.
So as much as we love the owls and want them to enjoy their condo, let’s not immediately jump to the conclusion that the building owners are trying to evict them. If they were, there are easier and cheaper ways of doing it.

3
Reply
AMT
AMT
19 days ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

This one had been decommissioned. No idea what the rush was to get up there and mess with it.

9
Reply
Leon
Leon
19 days ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

Were they given a permit?

2
Reply
Observer
Observer
19 days ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

Do you think this could have waited?

10
Reply
Robert
Robert
19 days ago
Reply to  Observer

Waited??? In guess you would have paid all the NYC Gov fines for not making needed repairs/replacement. As well as proved free water delivered to the residents to use

5
Reply
Observer
Observer
18 days ago
Reply to  Robert

The timing is too suspect, especially because the water tower was decommissioned, therefore NOT providing water. Enough.

4
Reply
AMT
AMT
19 days ago
Reply to  Robert

This building has a mile-long list of critical deferred maintenance–the scaffolding is there because it’s a safety risk. Yet there has been zero work since the scaffolding went up. Nothing will happen until the fate of the building is decided in probate court, which could take ages. The building will continue to deteriorate and pose an ever greater risk to its near neighbors.

Point is: it’s bizarre and suspicious that all of the sudden there needed to be emergency repairs to a…. decommissioned water tower.

11
Reply
5 cent comments
5 cent comments
19 days ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

But the mob has already weighed in with their verdict!

6
Reply
Ish Kabibble
Ish Kabibble
19 days ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

In other words, you have no idea what happened.

11
Reply
Buster Scruggs
Buster Scruggs
19 days ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

Yeah, sure. Veteran City Dwellers know your post is nonsense!!
I can count on one hand how many times in my 64 years there has been any work at all done to these vintage rooftop water buckets.

We can thank the uninformed ‘citizen’ who reported the owls — but most of the blame goes to THE MEDIA which cannot help itself. They always seem to thrive on outing wild animal sightings and their locations.

Pathetic results due to pathetic, semi-educated Humans.

7
Reply
72RSD
72RSD
19 days ago
Reply to  Buster Scruggs

Tanks are typically replaced every ~15 years, and must be cleaned and tested annually.

3
Reply
Wise Guy
Wise Guy
20 days ago
Reply to  Bill Williams

What on earth are you banging on about? This was simply a mean spirited attack on the owl’s nest. Hope they are prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.

27
Reply
Judy Canova
Judy Canova
18 days ago
Reply to  Wise Guy

Why would a landlord, even (especially!) a crummy one, go to the considerable expense of hiring a crew to de-roof a water tank on multiple days, even (especially!) a decommissioned one, just to displace some owls? Doesn’t make sense unless the work was really essential, or mandated by law.

0
Reply
Tomtom
Tomtom
19 days ago
Reply to  Wise Guy

Bill Williams is a bird hater who also thinks his “knowledge of water towers” is a flex.

3
Reply
Chris
Chris
19 days ago
Reply to  Tomtom

Bill Williams for Mayor!

1
Reply
Linda Mailloux
Linda Mailloux
19 days ago
Reply to  Wise Guy

I agree!

6
Reply
Michael Warren
Michael Warren
20 days ago

Likely the wotk of notorious UWS land lord, Brusco. Evicts

4
Reply
amm
amm
18 days ago
Reply to  Michael Warren

Here is the backstory on the building and its ownership: https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20160920/upper-west-side/how-mob-informant-who-left-witness-protection-got-100m-from-widow/

I’m surprised no one has mentioned the custom purple Rolls Royces and Lambos and Porsches and Maybachs that line the street in front of that building. Do you remember the shooting on a Friday afternoon several years ago? It was a gang/mob hit on a guy in a Rolls Royce. (One of those RRs is purple. Like the Joker, from Batman. You can’t make this stuff up.)

Here is the shooting : https://www.ilovetheupperwestside.com/suspects-arrested-following-west-75th-street-shooting/#google_vignette

3
Reply
amm
amm
18 days ago
Reply to  Michael Warren

My prior comment was not approved, so I’ll try again. The ownership of this building is currently in dispute, which is why it is falling into disrepair. (The scaffolding there is to protect passersby and the adjacent buildings; the deferred maintenance on that structure is a mile long, and it’s all critical.)

The real question for the present situation with the owls: The city contracted out oversight for the building to a management company while the ownership dispute is tied up in probate. But the old super and his family still live there and nearby. So who(ooooo) then is responsible for moving ahead on work in violation of a cease and desist order to a water tower that wasn’t even in use?

Note: The water tower was decommissioned after a horrible and utterly stupid mishap last spring when the maintenance person forgot to shut off the filler and it spilled over for hours onto the building next door, causing major water damage in all the units.

Last edited 18 days ago by amm
3
Reply
AMT
AMT
19 days ago
Reply to  Michael Warren

Good grief. Do five minutes of research. The owner of this building is this guy, and the entire thing is locked up in probate court. https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20160920/upper-west-side/how-mob-informant-who-left-witness-protection-got-100m-from-widow/

His son is the one who parks his Rolls Royce and other assorted mega-luxury vehicles outside and saves his spot with an orange cone. He’s also the one on whom there was an attempted mob/gang hit several years ago on a Friday afternoon. They shot and missed.

3
Reply
The Field Marshal
The Field Marshal
18 days ago
Reply to  AMT

The building was taken from Alben Sagan and Alben Sagan has nothing to do with the management or ownership of 15 West 75th Street and absolutely has nothing to do with this latest controversy. The finger should be pointed at the current management.

2
Reply
Bronte's Mistress
Bronte's Mistress
19 days ago
Reply to  Michael Warren

The Brusco’s do not own the building in question. The fact that they are being falsely accused here is libelous.

6
Reply
im10ashus
im10ashus
19 days ago
Reply to  Bronte's Mistress

You clearly don’t understand libel laws and how they work.

4
Reply
Barn Owl
Barn Owl
19 days ago
Reply to  im10ashus

If I am wrong I am wrong, but I think it is Adam Jernow that owns this building.

4
Reply
AMT
AMT
19 days ago
Reply to  Barn Owl

Nope. See above.

0
Reply
The Field Marshal
The Field Marshal
18 days ago
Reply to  AMT

Alben Sagan has nothing to do with the ownership or management of the building in 2026 and to tell people otherwise is portraying him in a false light. He lost the building.

1
Reply
marmom
marmom
20 days ago

Horrendous and a crime!

17
Reply
Anonymous
Anonymous
20 days ago

If they destroyed the nest, especially if It was deliberate (as it seems it was), throw the book at these building owners.

28
Reply
Lisa
Lisa
19 days ago
Reply to  Anonymous

I’m confused about where the nest was – was it underneath the roof of the water tank? If so, how did they get into the water tank? Was there a hole in the tank? And, is the nest still there, or is it gone. Gus we need more reporting 🙂

1
Reply
www
www
20 days ago

This building is so incredibly poorly managed. Look into its history. Last spring someone on their maintenance staff started filling up that water tower and forgot about it. It overflowed for hours on top of the building next door, causing extensive damage that affected every unit. I could go on for hours. They are the worst possible neighbors, and you can bet they do not give a single eff about those owls.

20
Reply
Jackeerobee
Jackeerobee
19 days ago
Reply to  www

Someone also fell from that same roof and died in December 2025. No one investigated it. The birds are getting more coverage than the human.

4
Reply
AMT
AMT
19 days ago
Reply to  Jackeerobee

They didn’t fall, that’s why it wasn’t investigated further. The police did their due diligence and it was determined to be a suicide pretty quickly.

4
Reply
Barn Owl
Barn Owl
19 days ago
Reply to  www

The General would never have allowed this to happen!

2
Reply
AMT
AMT
19 days ago
Reply to  Barn Owl

lol. the building is in the shape that it’s in because of The General.

2
Reply
Barn Owl
Barn Owl
18 days ago
Reply to  AMT

It doesn’t matter. The General stopped things from becoming worse, much worse!

1
Reply
Josh
Josh
20 days ago
Reply to  www

Sounds like the Owls didn’t do their due diligence before signing the lease.

9
Reply
Josephina
Josephina
20 days ago

Glad there won’t be so many people hanging around the streets!

1
Reply
Kenneth
Kenneth
20 days ago

The photo in the October 9, Instagram post shows a water tank roof in poor condition – including a section open to the sky. Rooftop water tanks hold domestic [drinking, bathing] and firefighting water supplies pumped to the roof for gravity distribution to the building below. An open roof and nesting birds create an unsanitary water condition. The sparks in the video indicate metal repairs beneath the tank. It would not be surprising to see the entire tank removed and rebuilt in the coming days. The wooden tanks do not last forever and cannot be easily replaced in winter weather. Sadly, bad timing for owls and bird watchers.

10
Reply
AMT
AMT
19 days ago
Reply to  Kenneth

It had been decommissioned.

6
Reply
Observer
Observer
19 days ago

Immediately replace the water tower roof and leave some tempting food on it; then prosecute the criminals. They must thrive on perverseness and the public’s hatred, as they can’t get any other sort of attention. If they don’t have anything positive in their lives except perhaps profit, then they think we shouldn’t either. Save these owls!

Last edited 19 days ago by Observer
8
Reply
neighbor
neighbor
19 days ago

Does someone know the address of the building? I’m not seeing it in the reports, only that it’s on 75th near Central Park.

0
Reply
caly
caly
19 days ago
Reply to  neighbor

15 W. 75th, posted by brownstonedetectives on IG.
https://www.instagram.com/p/DenHXOyn1uB/

1
Reply
neighbor
neighbor
19 days ago

Ah, this news has made WNYC, and the district’s state senator is speaking up about it!

5
Reply
Linda Mailloux
Linda Mailloux
19 days ago

I am a resident of the UWS, and I am livid! Let’s SE THE PERSON, who had the final decision on this! It is OUTRAGEOUS! It’s The Grinch That Stole Christmas! Where did these precious birds go? This has evil written all over it. Imagine the ogre! Getting home for dinner sitting at the dinner table telling his little children what he did at work today! Them crying in outrage! BAH HUMBUG!💔💀🦉🦉🦉🦉🦉🦉🦉🦉🦉

5
Reply
ron
ron
19 days ago

The owls have entranced the entire community so I hope that the harshest penalty and fines are given by DEC. Obviously the water tower was not in use, so why couldn’t they wait a bit to allow the owls to be strong enough to migrate to a better landlord.

7
Reply
BirdLover
BirdLover
19 days ago

It was clear from the moment that the owl’s location inside a water tank was “outed”, that their home would be destroyed for human sanitary reasons.
Loved to death.

0
Reply
SCPNYC
SCPNYC
19 days ago

Jail!

1
Reply
Adam H
Adam H
19 days ago

Here’s a solution. Maybe Mamdani can mandate installation of owl boxes on rooftops as part of water tower repairs.
https://www.barnowlbox.com/?srsltid=AYCX9vLeQ7PfFkXgqXj1MhrhE9IkhiXrlR5slnwh9ZW1WzWAx_CA8yHU

1
Reply
72RSD
72RSD
18 days ago
Reply to  Adam H

Mandating bird houses on top of critical water supply infrastructure seems like it might not be the best idea. These tanks are designed to keep water sealed in and keep-out things like birds.

1
Reply
Observer
Observer
18 days ago
Reply to  72RSD

This one wasn’t part of the water supply infrastructure.

0
Reply
BillyBob
BillyBob
19 days ago

I’m sorry to read this news, but my guess is that the building’s management decided that a family of wild animals living in/around their fresh water supply could be unsanitary.
I don’t know that’s true or not, but it reminds me of the case of Pale Male, the famous Red Tailed Hawk, who was nesting on stonework on 927 Fifth Avenue @ 74th Street years ago. The co-op decided didn’t want a hawk’s nest – and the associated rodent and pigeon bits that came with it – as part of their building. After a public outcry, they relented, restored the nest and the hawks stayed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/927_Fifth_Avenue

1
Reply
amm
amm
18 days ago
Reply to  BillyBob

The water tower had been decommissioned a while ago.

4
Reply
Wise Guy
Wise Guy
19 days ago
Reply to  BillyBob

I don’t think they relented. I think they were legally forced to make accommodations. The same should occur here – together with legal prosecution of those who already caused harm.

3
Reply
Tom
Tom
19 days ago

The owls will find another home.

3
Reply
Eugene Nickerson
Eugene Nickerson
19 days ago

The improper and unpermitted removal of this nest is something I can agree with the urbanists on as something that is uncalled for and must be properly investigated!

4
Reply
Charisse Bozza
Charisse Bozza
19 days ago

I sincerely hope there was a structural reason why this happened, but part of me believes that a grinch is afoot. Some people love to be killjoys.

0
Reply
eliza
eliza
19 days ago

Landlords do not care about anything living. It’s appalling. Two trees that were in between mine and another building for who knows how long where chopped down last week. One had died, no one from the other building on whose property the tree was on did anythig to check on the health of that tree. The other tree was alive. I have hope that they will replant but that may be a pipedream given that the stumps are still there and removal of the roots is complicated? I hope those landlords are fined. A**%^$#s. I hope the barn owls can find a safe place. Thank you for updating. I think the local news is covering it too. Where is Nina Pineda, 7 on your side.

1
Reply
Observer
Observer
18 days ago
Reply to  eliza

Good idea about Nina Pineda!

0
Reply
Dariv
Dariv
19 days ago

I hope the owner of the building with the water tower is heavily fined for breaking the law against disturbing a nest of migratory birds

Last edited 19 days ago by Dariv
0
Reply
Wijmlet
Wijmlet
18 days ago

Umm… is this not much ado?

0
Reply
lllljjj
lllljjj
18 days ago

what is wrong with you??? The water tower maintenance IS FAR MORE IMPORTANT FOR THE people WHO LIVE IN THAT BULDING!! The owls will find someplace else! Did any of you offer to help pay the tenants bills for repairing the water damage caused by the tower? Are you prepared to catch it when it collapses in the next big rain or snowstorm? Grow up.

2
Reply
Emailie
Emailie
18 days ago

“people” are losing respect for wildlife and nature, look at our current administration setting an example that this is OK. well, guess what, its NOT OK. i pray for our mother earth!

2
Reply
Dariv
Dariv
18 days ago

Has anyone spotted the birds anywhere?

0
Reply
Snidely Whiplash
Snidely Whiplash
18 days ago

That building is the one with all the flashy cars….

0
Reply
Janine
Janine
17 days ago

Hope the owls are gone — want peace & quiet again.

0
Reply

YOU MIGHT LIKE...

71 Vacant Storefronts Sit on 51 UWS Broadway Blocks: New Count Shows Improvement From Last Year
NEWS

71 Vacant Storefronts Sit on 51 UWS Broadway Blocks: New Count Shows Improvement From Last Year

November 18, 2026 | 3:19 PM
NEWS

Openings & Closings: Library Café by Buunni; Teddy’s Tavern; Blank Street Coffee; Carrot; Spring Nails & Spa; Zingone Brothers

November 18, 2026 | 8:08 AM
Previous Post

Incredible UWS Halloween Decoration Recreates New York Knicks Game Winning Shot

Next Post

WSR Cartoon: Upper West Side Does Halloween

this week's events image

Next Post
WSR Cartoon: Upper West Side Does Halloween

WSR Cartoon: Upper West Side Does Halloween

UWS Weekend: Great Things To Do in the Neighborhood

UWS Weekend: Great Things to Do in (and Around) the Neighborhood

The Upper West Side Streaker Going for a Record

The Upper West Side Streaker Going for a Record

  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWSLETTER
  • WSR MERCH!
  • ADVERTISE
  • EVENTS
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF USE
  • SITE MAP
Site design by RLDGROUP

© 2026 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • TOP NEWS
  • THIS WEEK’S EVENTS
  • OPEN/CLOSED
  • FOOD
  • SCHOOLS
  • OUTDOORS
  • REAL ESTATE
  • ART & CULTURE
  • POLITICS
  • COLUMNS
  • CRIME
  • HISTORY
  • ABSURDITY
  • ABOUT
    • OUR STORY
    • CONTRIBUTORS
    • CONTACT US
    • GET WSR FREE IN YOUR INBOX
    • SEND US TIPS AND IDEAS
  • WSR SHOP

© 2026 West Side Rag | All rights reserved.