
UPDATE 8 p.m. Thursday: The scheduled Thursday meeting between Barnard College administrators and student protestors was cancelled less than an hour before its start time. Students and administrators had agreed to the meeting after a six-hour sit-in at Barnard on Wednesday, held to demand that the college reinstate two students expelled for disrupting a “History of Modern Israel” class in January.
According to students, Barnard administrators initially agreed to a demand that the three students they would meet with could remain masked. But on Thursday, a student negotiator, who announced through the now-closed campus gates, said Barnard officials declined to meet “unless they UNMASK and identify themselves—despite ongoing security, disciplinary, and doxxing risks.” Students said the college also declined to allow audio recording of the meeting.
Barnard was closed to non-students today, but in the early afternoon dozens of protestors – some pro-Palestine, some pro-Israel – gathered outside the campus, kept apart by NYPD barriers.
By Marco Postigo Storel
Dozens of student demonstrators, fully masked and wearing the Palestinian keffiyeh scarf, filled the hallway leading to Dean Leslie Grinage’s office at Barnard College’s Milbank Hall Wednesday afternoon to demand the “immediate reversal” of the school’s expulsion of two students.
Barnard said it had expelled the students for participating in a January 21 protest, disrupting a “History of Modern Israel” class. The students have not been publicly identified, but an online letter-writing campaign shows over 110,000 people have called for their reinstatement.
Columbia and Barnard protesters, led by the group Columbia University Apartheid Divest, were initially met with resistance from campus security as they sought to enter Milbank Hall. Staff pushed back and tried to film students’ faces, but the demonstrators reached Dean Grinage’s office and remained there for six and a half hours. Grinage is a vice president and the senior student affairs officer at Barnard. While there, the protestors posted their demands on walls, tagged the walls with graffiti, chanted, and took votes every other hour on whether to remain or leave.
About an hour into the protest, Kristina Milnor, a professor from Barnard’s Classics and Ancient Studies Department, announced that the dean agreed to meet with up to three Barnard students, who would need to unmask and act as negotiators for the group. After some discussion, a meeting was scheduled for Thursday afternoon, and Barnard President Laura Rosenbury was scheduled to join.
Robin Levine, Barnard’s vice president for strategic communications, told the Columbia Spectator that one Barnard employee was taken to the hospital after being physically assaulted by students as they occupied the hallway.
Around 10 p.m. Wednesday, NYPD Strategic Response Group vans arrived at the Barnard campus, and campus security officers passed out written notices to the protestors, giving them until 10:30 to leave the protest or face disciplinary action. Shortly after, as demonstrators left campus, NYPD officers followed the students as they dispersed while holding signs expressing solidarity with Palestinians.
In an email to the Barnard community, President Rosenbury condemned the protest and student treatment of Barnard staff. “Their disregard for the safety of our community and respect for our campus remains completely unacceptable,” she wrote. The same email announced that starting Thursday morning, access to campus would be limited to students with a Barnard ID, and the only entry would be through the gate at West 117th Street and Broadway.
Comments have been turned off on this post.
Subscribe to West Side Rag’s FREE email newsletter here. And you can Support the Rag here.
There are rules. You can protest in ways that do not disrupt daily activity. They used graffiti and injured a person. That is not OK. Lock them up. Do not humor them. This has gone on too long.
And while you’re at it, give each of them a map and ask them to find Israel. Because I bet you half of them don’t have any idea what they are even complaining about.
oh? they’re not happy with their choice of “Not Kamala” for president? oh…that’s weird.
terrorist sympathizers…they should all get expelled as well. Its not a “peaceful protest” when someone is sent to the hospital.
Time for Columbia to break its affiliation with Barnard. People in New York have to learn what breaking the law is.
Why would Columbia breaking its affiliation with Barnard help? Columbia has had more than its own share of terrible anti-Israel, anti-Zionist, antisemitic protests since 10/7. The affiliation between Columbia and Barnard has nothing to do with this topic whatsoever!
When you stop to think the damage and deaths caused by Joe Biden’s absolute weakness and incompetence it is unreal. The attacks on Israel and the Ukraine would never have happened under a semi competent President.
because Putin wouldn’t have needed to, Trump’s plan is to disable NATO, which is what Putin wants. When Biden won in 2020, Putin saw no other alternative than to war on his enemy w/o Trump, his ally. Your blind hatred for Biden is worse than your blind obedience to the new Axis of Evil
Ukraine was attacked, beginning in 2014. Israel has been attacked since 1946. Let’s use some brainpower here that’s not generated by the bots at Fox Snooze.
“Let’s use some brainpowers here”? Sam, you are better than that condescending remark.
Actually the Jewish community in what was Palestine has been attacked since the 19th century.
Trump has called for a US occupation of Gaza and permanent expulsion of Gazans from their homeland. Is colonization what you voted for?
Please hold the lies for a while. Trump has not called for an occupation of Gaza and Gaza is not their homeland. The only colonization is what the Arabs have done to the middle east.
Please read the news, for once in your life.
What?! Even Fox News has reported on Trump’s intent to take over Gaza:
https://www.foxnews.com/video/6368595455112
Intent to take over, huh? And I intend to move to Mars.
You are able to comprehend the gap between tossing ideas on the table, vs. practical intent, right?
When he even suggests sending the entire 6th Fleet into the Eastern Mediterranean with orders, you can start talking about Intent.
Agree.
Your logic and proof?
Riiiiiight. Hamas wouldn’t have attacked Israel if Trump were president? And Russia, who Trump has repeatedly said can do whatever it wants, wouldn’t have attacked Ukraine? I can’t imagine how deluded you have to be to believe this stuff.
UWS-er, do you honestly believe Joe Biden actually made decisions in the last 4 years? The Biden Whitehouse was busy hiding Biden’s decline from the American people do much else.
You just changed the subject because you have no response to UWS-er’s arguments
Oh, please.
Absolutely agree with you.
That’s what happens when the Dems run a corpse for President.
Oh but a felon rapist racist is ok with you. Strange logic
UESGurl, You may want to be careful with your slander, Trump has sued for less and won.
I assume you mean impeached President Clinton?
Harris was not a corpse, the fecal matter currently residing in the White House is rotting worse than a corpse.
What does it say about Harris that she couldn’t beat, out-think, out-smart, out-talk, out-reason, etc. THIS kind of winner of the election?
I’ve had plenty of comments censored here that were actually factual but a disgusting comment like this goes thru—interesting…
>a disgusting comment like this
what’s disgusting is slashing funding for USAID, and firing 10s of thousands of good Civil Servants who based their careers on helping people do better. As for you: do better.
I am assuming you consider our current President semi-competent, and he’ s made it clear he’ll let Russia do whatever it wants. So yes, the attacks would have happened, but there would have been no response from the US.
Expulsion for every single one of them. And post every name on the Barnard Careers website, so no future employer ever gets duped in hiring one of these clowns.
This is why the Columbia campus remains closed
I am steeling myself to imagine Columbia’s campus never reopening in my lifetime. When will a time come when there is no potential for protests? Esp if students continue to think that attacking their university will lead to an end to oppression elsewhere in the world. Like, Columbia’s endowment decisions are going to redirect policies of governments or quasi-govts?
Correct. Every time there is a protest only makes it less likely Columbia will open the gates and supports their decision.
This wasn’t peaceful. Property was defaced a d a Columbia employee hospitalized. But yeah, let’s let them walk out and not have face any consequences for their destructive and illegal behavior. Coddling criminals like this is why we have a criminal in the Oval Office.
Sit-in is not the invasion that occurred “ initially met with resistance from campus security as they sought to enter Milbank Hall”. “ tagged the walls with graffiti”, and “one Barnard employee was taken to the hospital after being physically assaulted by students as they occupied the hallway”, do not add up to “a sit-in. It was an invasion at best an attack on the building and its occupants at worst. Arrests should have occurred.
I don’t understand why there are no protests against the ethnic cleansing that Trump has called for? Somehow Biden negotiating was bad enough not to vote for him but on this? Not a peep. I guess Russian/republican bots aren’t at work on these naive students
Define “ethnic cleansing” for us, since you’re using the term?
for the arabs to accuse israel of ethnic cleansing is an absurd joke. the jews know about it, but so do the seleucids, the parsis, the assyrians, the kurds, the armenians, and so many others
They’re chicken. They are literally too scared to confront the bad people so they do this instead and demand milk and cookies.
Ethnic cleansing? This is why the Democrats are in trouble nothing left but lies.
If you’re completely ignorant about the situation, it’s better to just not comment.
I wouldn’t bring up lies If I were you: it’s poor salesmanship.
https://www.vox.com/world-politics/398894/trump-gaza-clean-out-riviera-egypt-jordan-palestinians-netanyahu
https://meidasnews.com/news/trump-pushes-plan-to-clean-out-gaza-moving-population-to-jordan-and-egypt
https://www.lawyersgunsmoneyblog.com/2025/01/trump-advocates-ethnic-cleansing-of-gaza-strip
https://newrepublic.com/post/191166/trump-plan-ethnically-cleanse-take-over-gaza-world-reaction
https://www.salon.com/2025/02/05/like-a-bad-sick-joke-plan-for-a-gaza-purge-amounts-to-ethnic-cleansing-critics-say/
https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2025/feb/05/trump-gaza-take-over-reaction-israel-netanyahu-middle-east-latest-live
https://www.lawyersgunsmoneyblog.com/2025/02/trump-ethnic-cleansing-in-gaza-should-be-total-and-permanent
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/feb/13/rabbis-ad-trump-gaza-plan
https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2025/02/trump-gaza-ai-slop-post-elon-musk-ethnic-cleansing-hotel-israel/
Wait I thought they had to remove their masks? Oh right, they can’t be disciplined for anything at all, ever, since nobody can apparently identify them. Convenient for all!
I can only hope we are approaching the line where Columbia says enough.. This is a private organization. A business. Private property. I’m all for education and free speech but how is this behavior their right or entitlement? There is a code of conduct when you enroll. Why is this being tolerated?
Who are the adults in the room? How much are they being paid to run this organization? How much better would it be for everyone, including the students who attend in order to get a proper education, if these terrorists were just removed? I’m sure they must scan their ID to access the buildings. It can’t be a secret who they are?
Lastly, this whole refusing to unmask themselves is just ridiculous. Imagine if their markings revealed they were KKK? Would there be tolerance or outrage and histrionics? Or is the issue that the target of their hate is a different demographic where hated is now acceptable?
So, to ckarify: They are protesting the student expulsions for priven violations of the school code of conduct, but they are NOT protesting Trump’s proposal that the US occupy Gaza, expel the Gazans, and turn the area into a tourist resort?
Yep. They’re brainwashed cultist idiots.
Barnard and Columbia have both put out statements that call this “unacceptable.”
Those responses, themselves, are unacceptable.
If the protestors are students they should be expelled immediately. If they are no longer considered minors by the state of NY, their names should be published. No “ifs, ands or buts.”
If the schools are not willing to expel each and every one, their federal funds should be withheld.
Make no mistake, when you align yourself with terrorists, you too, are a terrorist.
Even for the sake of argument their cause is noble these actions do not constitute freedom of speech. This is disruptive violence.
If these clowns are so proud of their protests they should have the courage not to mask.
The NYPD needs to protect students and faculty at Columbia from these thugs as the administration is apparently unwilling or unable to. Furthermore, Jewish alums should withhold donations to Columbia until the administration takes serious action against these protesters (I know several alums who have ended their annual donations).
This was at Barnard, not Columbia
Well, their absolutely cowardice at hiding their faces means they’re not really committed to anything and are simply hell-raisers. Make each of them take a test on the history of the Middle East, and if they fail, flunk them.
They continue the “resistance” after forensics has uncovered that Palestinians killed Bibas babies with bare hands. How humane.
Arrest. Imprison. Deport.
Loons like this are why Trump is in the Oval Office.
And if Columbia’s acting president cannot maintain a safe environment for students, staff, security, and neighbors, perhaps he should be replaced as well.
And if Columbia, as an institution, cannot manage its student body in a sane way, cannot manage campust security competently, and cannot manage institutional operations……
perhaps the Federal government should assume control of the institution, its investments, and its real estate holdings, reviewing, all research grants and federal contracts, student visas, professorships, and make funding and immigration decisions accordingly.
Guessing Elon Musk would make a fine university president.
Has anyone suggested this idea to President Trump yet? Let’s get the ball rolling!
Keffiyeh is a garment common with multiple Arab groups across the Middle East, not just Palestinians. Non-Middle Easterners thinking it’s uniquely Palestinian is pretty emblematic of the level of misunderstanding and misinformation that surrounds this conflict.
Oh we know exactly why they are wearing them – to show solidarity with Hamas terrorists. The naivete of these kids is sad, the harsh world awaits them….
And the swastika was originally found in Aztec, Maya and Hindu culture. But once it became a Nazi symbol, it’s a lot harder to make the argument that anyone is still wearing it for other reasons – and it would be disingenuous at best if they said they were misunderstood. Arafat intentionally adopted the keffiyeh for the the PLO – designated a terror organization by multiple countries at the time. The Barnard students and other non-MENA pro-Palestinian protesters wearing them are not doing so because they’re embracing pan-Arab love. They’re cosplaying as Palestinian terrorists in solidarity.
And the expelled students weren’t kicked out just for disrupting the class. There were more there who helped in the disruptions who weren’t expelled. These students were handing out flyers showing a boot stomping on a Star of David. That’s not anti-Israel. It’s anti-Semitic, by every definition. There’s a line, and they crossed it.
Your subject headings are usually on point, but this one less so – is it a ‘sit in’ when there’s vandalism and violence that defaces property, and sends a person to hospital? I am all for people voicing their viewpoints, whether I agree with their viewpoints or not. But this was not just a ‘sit in’ and I am curious why the euphemistic softening of the reality of that protest, which was neither peaceful nor lawful.
Muslims on the UWS have suffered repeated discrimination and profiling just due to stereotyping yet the UWS prides itself on being a progressive neighborhood. Muslims who have nothing to do with any of this on the UWS are being treated like garbage and elected officials do not care.
And how do Muslims treat non-Muslims in Muslim countries? Christians are attacked in Egypt, in Syria, in Turkey the Muslims killed millions of Christian Armenians and Greeks. In Iran, how are Bahaiis or Zoroastrians treated? How do Pakistanis and Afghans treat non-Muslims?
do you have a shred of evidence? even a story to tell?
That’s an important point, and I think protests like these – which are overwhelmingly run and participated in by non-Muslims – are only adding fuel to the fire. I know there are a lot of people in the Jewish community (count me as one of them) who would be happy to join in common cause to fight against Islamophobia side by side with anti-Semitism, and to stand with your community in the same way we hope you’ll stand with ours. No one deserves this.
The antisemitic losers at the New School are starting up again it seems too, though less violently. There’s a table set up in the lobby at Parsons with the Palestinian flag and two Parsons students with too much time on their hands wearing keffiyehs and a sign that says ‘Liberation’ in a Middle Eastern language (I don’t know which and don’t care to google it).
Arrest them, expel them, and if legally possible DEPORT them. Chanting “intifada revolution” is an explicit call for the murder of Jews.
Seriously?
Do the commenters here have no understanding that student protests are a fairly common thing?
When demonstrators are masked and violent, they are in no position to make demands. They are simply criminals on a college campus and need to be treated as such. They are immature in thinking that their behavior is acceptable and that there should be no legal and/or academic consequences. But that’s the hard lesson for the two who were expelled.
So brave they are protesting Barnard. They won’t go near any right wing hate rallies but Barnard they’re not afraid of.
Did NYPD have to sick the dogs on them at any point? Or did they all disperse peacefully?
They reap what they sow. Barnard is in the grip of identity ideology which permeates every department and administrative office. The administration is afraid of its faculty and students. They are afraid to act decisively to enforce common sense rules of law and order because that would ruffle the feathers of the ideology police on campus. Shame on the Board of Trustees who give money uncritically. Barnard used to be a great place when I went there, but sadly it is now nothing more than an incubator for the Progressive Fringe.
https://canarymission.org/campaign/Columbia_Intifada#Administrative-Complicity
A comprehensive analysis on what has happened and who these people are. I hope the Trump administration defunds these schools soon.
If you have courage in your own convictions, why hide your face? Its so Hamas.
why not call out the nazis here?
You’ve met Nazis on the UWS? How did it go? What did they look like?