The line at PS 75, where we heard numerous reports of people waiting more than two hours. Photo by Meg D’Incecco.
Upper West Side voters had widely varying experiences at the polls today, with some getting to vote quickly while others stood in line for more than two hours and received confusing instructions.
We heard some particularly frustrating stories from voters who cast ballots at PS 75 on 95th Street.
Ashira Konigsburg met people on line there who had arrived at 8:30 a.m. and were still there at 10:30. “This could have been run so much more efficiently,” Konigsburg said.
One of our commenters said: “I am all for waiting and voting, if it’s an efficient process but I waited for 2.5 hours at PS75, and It was completely disorganized and out of control. The first 1.5 hours we kept moving, only to find out another entrance was then opened. Ended up waiting another hour to allow people who did not have wait as long to join in the mix. Disgusting and completely unfair! In addition this new and improved voting system is completely inefficient and archaic!”
There are numerous other stories like that below.
Konigsburg says to call 866-NYC-VOTE to file complaints. We are hearing troubling things about voting in other parts of the city too, including a polling station downtown with paper ballots sitting out on a table with no one around, so that people could presumably take multiple ballots. It’s not clear why this process is so disorganized — it’s not like we don’t have a tremendous amount of data on how many people vote in each area. We have a call in to Gale Brewer, who oversees the Board of Elections.
The three pictures below are from @FriendsofJodi. The top two are from 97th Street between Columbus and Amsterdam, where Jodi said three of the machines were broken and there were long lines and confusion. The bottom picture is from 77th Street. Below that, we have updates from other West Siders on their experiences via twitter. And read through the comments for more.
@westsiderag 15min at 180 riverside
— Stephen (@sltbaum) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag insanity at PS75. have been in line for 1.5 hrs already….
— Jodi Kendall (@Jodi_Kendall) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag people in line are calling the public advocacy office. waited for almost 2hrs.
— Jodi Kendall (@Jodi_Kendall) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag35 minutes at PS 199.2 scanners, 4 EDs.
— Priscilla (@CillaG) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 111 71st street, the line looks long but it moved quickly and I was done in 25 minutes.
— Bailey Kennedy (@BaileyKennedy) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 35 min wait at Euclid Hall (bway 85/86).
— Kevin Balfe (@kbalfe) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag Schwab House added EDs outside the building and it is out of control long.
— Doug Perlson (@DougPerlson) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 35 min wait at Euclid Hall (bway 85/86).
— Kevin Balfe (@kbalfe) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag view from the line for ED 3 #vote #disorganized #america #deepbreaths twitter.com/vtweetme/statu…
— Vanessa (@vtweetme) November 6, 2012
long line to #vote but generally good spirits and chatty crowd on W102 and CPW. @westsiderag
— Kelle Cruz (@kellecruz) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag i’m guessing 30mins here. EDs 68, 55, & 54.
— Kelle Cruz (@kellecruz) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag PS 163 97th St, little clusterfuckish at first but here about 40 mins, moving ok. Mostly confusing signs for Elec District.
— Taryn Cooper (@TarynItUpNY) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 30 min at 70th & WEA
— Amanda Hardy (@Amhardy2) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 117/Lenox (upper upper west) is about an hour
— leagoldman (@leagoldman) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag SoHa now 90 min line…seems to be getting longer.
— leagoldman (@leagoldman) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 20 minutes at 141 w 73rd.
— Terry Lane (@Terry_Lane) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 20 minutes earlier this morning at 82nd and West End.Don’t let the line scare you.It moves!
— Melissa Marks-Shih (@mmarksshih) November 6, 2012
Ashira Konigsburg had waited 15 minutes to get this close to the polling site at PS 75 on 95th:
@westsiderag some people in here were waiting since 830am! This could have been run so much more efficiently. #vote #UWS
— Ashira Konigsburg (@ashirak) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag Voted at 82nd/WEA and the line was long, but moved quickly. People in good spirits. In & out in 30 mins. twitter.com/rebeccafrey/st…
— Rebecca Frey (@rebeccafrey) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 20 min at 180 Riverside Blvd. (apparently down from 1 hr+ earlier today)
— Rebecca Soffer (@RebeccaSoffer) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 109th st would not be bad if not for workers not knowing the alphabet holding up the process! #VOTENYC #UWS
— mrdcm (@mrdcm) November 6, 2012
@westsideragVoted in a half an hour at JHS 118 on 93rd Street.No issues.
— Linda Powell (@misslindapowell) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag At PS 53, problems with scanners. 30 minutes to get ballot, so far waiting almost 10 for scanning, a ways to go yet.
— Ashley Pagnotta (@ashpags) November 6, 2012
Ashley later told us she was actually voting at PS 811, at 466 W End.
@westsiderag at noon, the line at West End & 82 goes from WE to Broadway on 82. It’s moving though
— Erin Pearce (@ereene) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag 1hr at PS9 (84&Columbus) at 6:45 this morning. Hopefully they got better organized after I left.
— Willow (@RockShrimp) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag Just voted at PS9 on w84. Took 1.5 hours to get a ballot and 5 minutes to vote and get it scanned. Disorganized mess.
— Steve Gomes (@stevenwgomes) November 6, 2012
.@westsiderag The line at Schwab House is so long that people are giving up and going home without voting.
— Aaron Judell (@audiomixer) November 6, 2012
Same here RT @stevenwgomes: @westsiderag Just voted at PS9 on w84. Took 1.5 hours to get a ballot and 5 minutes to vote and get it scanned.
— Vanessa (@vtweetme) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag Hoda Kotb in the house. Joined her district line with the rest of the masses. Meanwhile, I’m still waiting to get a ballot.
— Vanessa (@vtweetme) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag West Side High at 102nd was calm and orderly and didn’t take very long around 10am.
— Marc Melzer (@marcmelzer) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag Just under 2 hours at 96th and WEA!
— Nin Kat (@NinKatNYC) November 6, 2012
Even the mayor is reportedly confused by why this process seems to be such a mess:
“I kept hearing, ‘What’s this, a third world country?'” says Mayor Bloomberg, referring to the polling sites
— Dana Rubinstein (@danarubinstein) November 6, 2012
In the afternoon and evening, we heard from more readers:
@westsiderag No wait at all to vote at 180 Riverside Blvd (at 2:30pm)
— Marc Shivers (@mshivers) November 6, 2012
Well despite what I had read it just took me 10 min to vote at an extremely organized site at 132 W 89th #uws @westsiderag @boenyc
— Amy Wilson (@amywlsn) November 6, 2012
90 minutes on district 7 line to get ballot at chaotic ps9 on #UWS. Casting #vote after that: 5 mins. @westsiderag twitter.com/michelefaye/st…
— Michele Hoos (@michelefaye) November 6, 2012
@westsiderag it’s a total zoo at P.S. 84!!!!! It’s 50/50 on organization and I hear only one scanner works!
— Ally M. (@AllyofNewYork) November 6, 2012
Around 6:30 p.m.
Voting line at ps75 is still just as long as before. I’d estimate at least a 2.5 hour wait. #UWS @westsiderag
— Ashira Konigsburg (@ashirak) November 7, 2012
#vote Crazy lines on #uws polls they should keep polls open until 10p @westsiderag on 95th West End
— AfordNYC (@AfordNYC) November 7, 2012
@westsiderag Brandeis HS. Used to vote at Goddard Riverside and it was so much better there. Just too many ED’s and confusion in small space
— Mayor of the UWS (@mayorofuws) November 7, 2012
@westsiderag Line out door/down block@ PS166 this AM.Had to get to work,raced home from office.Physically barred from entering @ 9:02pm
— Ken Lupano (@KLupano) November 7, 2012
@westsiderag I get it. But not really. Two minutes?There were others on the school steps. Lots of peepsstill inside.
— Ken Lupano (@KLupano) November 7, 2012
@westsiderag Apparently polling centers the very last thing still running perfectly on-time in Manhattan post-Sandy.
— Ken Lupano (@KLupano) November 7, 2012
For our full voting guide, click here. Let us know how your experience went by contacting us on twitter, facebook or emailing info@westsiderag.com.
PS 53/811, WEA at 82: About a half hour (9:30 to 10:00 am), but as disorganized as can be. Too many people in too small a space, and too little guidance once inside. Everybody seems to be good humored so it’s tolerable.
Would move much faster if they steered the crowded lines better, and if more of the scanners present were actually put to use.
The new, “improved” voting system really makes me pine for the good old days of enter the booth, pull the little levers, pull the big lever, leave. Ah, progress!
GOOD!!!!! There should be long lines to vote. Voting matters. Everyone who has ever served in our military did so so that we can vote! Think of those who fought in our wars and never made it home again or those who only partially made it home, think of what they sacrificed. They gave up more than an hour of their time on a beautiful sunny day. Go out and VOTE. NOW !!!!!!!!
Huh?? My father served in World War II — came home and voted in a voting machine that took a couple of minutes. How does the military service of some (which I appreciate) mandate that everyone now needs to wait for hours to do something that used to take minutes??
What does one thing have to do with the other?
Voting has suddenly, inexplicably and unjustifiably turned into a frustrating and vexing process. Yes, we have to vote — but why did it have to be made so difficult when for so many years — so many generations — it worked smoothly and efficiently?
Please wave your flag elsewhere. People are complaining about the sudden confusion of the electoral process. No one is complaining about the obligation — the privilege — to vote.
Yes – 90 minute wait at 8am this morning at the Church of St. Paul/St. Anthony at 86th/WEA…made pleasurable thanks to the Church allowing us to use their sanctuary to come in from the cold…and the homemade muffins and treats and coffee they were freely distributing. Very nice, UWS! Thank you!
“You can’t change Washington from the inside…. You can only change it from the outside.” – O
At 97th btw Columbus and Amsterdam and its chaos. Just awful.
People with nametags/badges kept coming outside telling people that if you knew your district you didnt have to wait on outside line so people got off the line, went in, and then were sent back out. This happened over and over and over. So… wait on line to find out your district (even if you know it), then wait on line to get your ballot (make sure you’re at the right district and the right last name, not clearly marked), then wait on line for a privacy booth (many without pens and so close to the wall that wheelchairs couldnt fit thru), then finally wait on line to insert your ballot into the scanner. And of course find your way out thru all these intersecting lines.
111th/Riverside no line outside but a snaking line inside for over an hour. Do Columbia students go elsewhere? I didn’t see any.
At 35 W 92 it was chaos! no one knew what was going on, I waited 1.5 hours. Not everyone can stand or wait that long!
I am all for waiting and voting, if it’s an efficient process but I waited for 2.5 hours at PS75, and It was completely disorganized and out of control. The first 1.5 hours we kept moving, only to find out another entrance was then opened. Ended up waiting another hour to allow people who did not have wait as long to join in the mix. Disgusting and completely unfair!
In addition this new and improved voting system is completely inefficient and archaic!
Thank you for letting me vent! I look forward to formally complaining.
I was also at PS 75. Waiting an hour and a half to get to the door. Another 20 creeping up the stairs. When we got inside, it was absolute chaos. Almost no signage and bizarre overlapping lines wrapping around tables.
I don’t know how anyone elderly, disabled, or toting young children (which I hear some schools actually encourage for some sort of extra credit) managed to stay through the whole process and actually vote.
The staff I encountered were handling things as well as they could, though. I saw some taking abuse from voters, but managing to be helpful to the next person who came along.
Waited over two hours at PS75 this afternoon. I’ve voted over four times in past here and NEVER lines like this. Too many people from other districts (not displaced, just found it “easier” to vote here!) Not their fault though, physically not enough space to accommodate workers and voters. Could have spread machines and tables out over two rooms. Poor planning. Plus as others noted, the volunteers kept calling some districts to come up and then, didn’t take the people in. All it did was give a pass to front of line for people and pushed the line back even further.
Worse, people with walkers, canes, etc. NOT told they should go to head of line. Had to find a volunteer to help woman behind me. Not everyone who wants to vote can stand in line, nor should they have to
Note to the governor: We need to be allowed to vote in advance and you need to get people in to overhaul the whole process.
Once you got in, nobody at many of the tables, just physically not enough privacy booths and machines to scan. Poor planning.
One hour 45 minutes at P.S. 75. Lines have doubled since I went in, now stretching down West End Avenue to 95th St. and another 50 yards down 95th St. Completely unnecessary, just crammed too many voting districts into one tiny school gym. The tables to check in were actually empty, workers idle, booths and scanners free — they just couldn’t let more people into the gym because it was packed.
An hour and a half at La Guardia High School for ED 28. But only for those (like me) whose last names start with A-L! Voters M-Z in ED 28 and those in other districts had much shorter waits. People dropping out of line, pledging to come back later. Hope they do!
Waited from 1:38-3:55 for a ballot at PS75. Mercifully filling it out and scanning took 2 minutes.
At PS 84 (92nd street between CPW and Columbus) it took a total of 50 minutes (arrived at 3:15 pm). When I left just after 4 pm the line was a bit longer. There were 4 scanners at the facility but only one scanner is working. People were very frustrated but I personally don’t think an hour in line is too bad. There should have been a special line or accommodations for elderly voters.
45 minutes this morning at PS 165 on 109th Street (8:20 – 9:05 am). It was pretty chaotic and felt like there were too many districts in one too-small (and hot) space. My district had one of the longest and slowest lines, while for others people could just walk right up to the table, which was a bit frustrating. When I got to the front of my line I realized part of the problem was the poll volunteers were spending too much time arguing about how to hand out the ballots rather than just doing it. There were not enough privacy booths (and people didn’t want to wait on yet another line) so people were just marking their ballots in the open while waiting on line to drop them in the scanners. This was my first time voting on the UWS; I was formerly a Battery Park City resident for 6 years and usually just walked in and out there. Not a terrible experience, but it definitely seems like efficiency could be improved.
voted at around 3:00pm at West 92nd street school. Really, I don’t understand why there ca’t be signs posted clearly and in a range that most people can see that tell you what line to be in. Also, very disturbing – when I got to the scanner, the man took my ballot and started to read it – NOT HIS BUSINESS. I and a few other people were startled that this man was doing this and he was apparently the supervisor. He kept saying he was only helping but how about you tell people how to scan rather than trying to take the ballot out of people’s hands, reading their ballots and scanning them in. The invasion of privacy is very, very disturbing.
After facing lines out the door and down the block on 89th street at PS 166 this morning and having to get to work, tonight we were barred from entering the building at 9:02pm. There were two of us on the steps of the school. One man physically blocked the entryway for one set of doors with his body while a second man held the second set of doors door shut from the inside with his hands to prevent us from entering the building. I could see through the windows there were still many people inside. The entire West Side was a parking lot tonight with the Holland Tunnel still closed but we still got there. It was 9:02 on my iPhone. I get it, but not really.
Voted at Marseille House at 103rd off Broadway. Too small and two of the three scanners not working. Went back later with my sister who was voting with an affidavit. There was a woman working there who definitely had some issues. Not sure of the qualifications for working but she shouldn’t have been there. She was confusing things and not helping. Not what we need for voting!
I am not judging but I think she was mentally ill. How does this happen?????
Similarly bad experience at Schwab house. After waiting in line for hour and a half, an entire group was moved to the front so it took an extra 35/40 mins. Very crowded and inefficient. One of the workers mentioned something about a fire hazard because there were too many people in the room. Residents were also given priority voting, which seems unfair in a public election.
Board of Elections never informed people in my building that our polling place had been moved from W. 76th Street to W.73rd Street. Only found out after going to old polling site.
New polling site had poor layout and info table was not easy to find. Once negotiated through the system voting was relatively easy — only about 15 minutes in all.