
By Yana Krasnitskaya
In a previous column, I wrote about how I am, much to others’ dismay, not a dessert person. Give me a cheese plate and a bag of chips over a slice of cake or ice cream any day of the week. There is, however, one exception that I will always, always make and that is basically anything that features Nutella. On a very impromptu visit to Janie’s Life-Changing Baked Goods, my love for Nutella was reaffirmed when I sampled their Nutella Cookie Pie ($6).
The great thing about Janie’s Nutella Cookie Pie is that that’s not even the thing Janie’s is known for. That honor is bestowed upon the diminutive hybrid known as a pie crust cookie. Imagine your classic pie and then shrink it down to about a 2.5-inch round that has a flakey crust, a gooey filling, and the buttery streusel that my favorite kind of pie is known for. And the little pies did look quite delectable behind the glass display—just as everything did at Janie’s—but my eyes immediately zeroed in on the Nutella Cookie Pie.
Slightly bigger than the pie crust cookies, for all intents and purposes, the Nutella Cookie Pie looks like a mini tart. The outer shell is a perfectly browned chocolate chip cookie dough with a large chunk of chocolate dropped right in the middle. Once you break it open is when the real fun begins: There is more Nutella here than I could have ever imagined, its usual melty consistency further amplified by being slightly warmed, and encased by that half-baked cookie dough.
The dough is almost like a short bread crust, and the salt level is a perfect counterpoint to the nutty, sweet cocoa flavor of Nutella. You also can’t forget the added richness of the chocolate chunks that are studded throughout—an explosion of hazelnut and chocolate that will make even a skeptic like me a believer. There’s no denying that this is a rich dessert—I couldn’t have more than a sliver at a time—but boy does it hit the spot. My favorite part, besides the Nutella of course, is the hints of browned butter I picked up on in the cookie dough itself. That, more than anything else, had me coming back for more. Paired with the Nutella, it might be the best sweet bite I’ve had in quite some time.
Even sweeter is the story behind Janie’s. Founded by Janie Deegan in 2015, the bakery had been preceded many years of struggle with addiction and even, at one time, homelessness. As part of her sobriety journey, Janie started baking pies to treat her family and friends, and in the process, regained her self-confidence. Encouraged by loved ones, Janie turned her hobby into a small business, first with Janie Bakes, and then with Janie’s Life-Changing Baked Goods.
Janie’s story–and her unique invention of a pie crust cookie–has been covered by media outlets, and has gotten her quite a bit of recognition in the food industry. What stands out most though is Janie’s commitment to lifting up others who have had challenges in life. In an interview with ABC last month, Janie talked about having an open-door policy when it comes to hiring. “I’m not looking just at your resume,” she said. “I’m looking at, like, who you are.”
It’s no surprise then that the energy at Janie’s on the Upper West Side is so light and inviting. Or maybe it really just the fact that everyone who walks through the door is in for a delicious, sweet surprise. Either way, Janie’s Life-Changing Baked Goods is worth the visit.
The Dish: Janie’s Nutella Cookie Pie ($6)
The Restaurant: Janie’s Life-Changing Baked Goods, 434 Amsterdam Avenue (at West 81st Street). Open daily, 10 a.m. to 11 p.m.



