
By a Grumpy Upper West Sider
I’m just going to say it: I hate the NYC Marathon.
I don’t get it. Beyond the enormous inconvenience to those of us who live near the finish line on the Upper West Side, I cannot understand why anyone would voluntarily pay to participate.
Don’t get me wrong. I love running. I run multiple times a week. But never once have I wanted to wake up before dawn on a Sunday, trek all the way to Staten Island, stand around in the cold with thousands of strangers, and wait hours for the privilege of spending several more hours running.
As someone born and raised in this city, the closest I ever got to Staten Island was passing it on a ferry during an elementary school class trip. I have never felt the need to improve upon that record.
People say they do it for the challenge. For the camaraderie. To be part of something bigger than themselves. Fine. But personally, I would like to be part of something that starts later in the day and is closer to my apartment.
What really gets me is the idea that completing a marathon is the ultimate proof of physical fitness. Among the people I know who have trained for one, the conversation often seems to revolve around what hurts: knees, hips, feet, ankles. Someone is limping. Someone is seeing a physical therapist. Someone is determined to run despite being told to rest.
At a certain point, I have to ask: Are you enjoying this?
I understand wanting a goal. I understand feeling proud of doing something difficult. What I don’t understand is why running 26.2 miles has become such a celebrated benchmark that getting to the starting line in pain can seem like evidence of dedication rather than a reason to reconsider.
And then there’s the medal. Yes, you covered an impressive distance. But the medal is also, technically, a participation trophy—the grown-up version of the one you got in Little League, except this one comes with chafing and difficulty walking down stairs.
You can wear it as you limp around afterward so everyone knows you ran the marathon. Then you can have brunch with friends, wrapped in tin foil and still wearing the clothes you’ve spent the last four hours sweating in.
I’ll be the person trying to figure out how to get across the neighborhood.
No, thank you.
Subscribe to West Side Rag’s FREE email newsletter here. And you can Support the Rag here.






100%. Thank you! It is a nightmare. All those smug people with their medals and foil make going anywhere impossible. And the noise. For what? It’s a huge waste of money and time. If only our society could spend its resources educating and feeding people instead of things like this.
YES!!! Nightmare! Thank you!!!
The marathon raises a lot of money for charity. It brings in and distributes around 1.33x the total cost of setting up. Please check your facts before saying it’s a waste that doesn’t contribute anything.
A nightmare? Marathon day vibes are always excellent, plus the NYC marathon raised over $100m for charities this year alone and all the visitors are a tremendous economic benefit to NYC. I have no desire personally to run the marathon but its a great event for our city.
I said the same thing in a comment three years ago that was deleted by the moderator
They don’t want to hear the truth.
Hate the marathon too.
Don’t feel bad. I’ve been deleted a lot, even for innocuous comments, such as, “I really miss Capezio,’ lol. In any case, I’m thrilled that this story finally made it into the WSR. 🥳
I miss Capezio too!
Me too!
Weird and hateful post
Grumpy old man post
thumb down
Really? Hateful?
You do know that the author is “By a Grumpy Upper West Sider”? It’s tongue-in-cheek. Relax.
Heartwarming and encouraging to others.
The rest of us love it.
That’s a pretty sweeping statement. I, for one, don’t love it (but I don’t loathe it, either).
No, we don’t. PREACH author!!
“But personally, I would like to be part of something that starts later in the day and is closer to my apartment.”
I love it! That’s my motto about most things in life.
Wow. You must be fun at parties:)
I hate parties more than I hate the marathon.
There you are!! Has the community AGED that much on the UWS !!!
Back in the day, we’d be out til the early hours of the morning at discos !!
Figures!!
So why are you still here… in the UWS>?? !! Haha! .. Time to GO?!
There are opportunities on the UWS that don’t exist elsewhere and everyone wants them.
ha ha
This comment always seems so stupid to me. What’s so great about being fun at parties or even going to them?
Yeah who cares lol ..whoever made this lemming phrase is most definitely a narcissist. Truly terrifying !
Greig is DEFINITELY not fun at parties! 😉
I don’t “hate” it. But last year I had to get to a doctor’s appt in Midtown and it was impossible to find a place to cross an Avenue I needed to cross. I ended up being a few minutes late, when I had intended to arrive early (and left early enough to do so).
.. You had an appointment with a doctor in Midtown on a Sunday! REALLY!?
You’re able to find doctors appointments on the weekend? Great!!
I had the same experience last year. I now make a note in my calendar of the annual marathon date and make sure I plan nothing except staying home and eating chocolate.
I support this message.
.. Yes it can be challenging to get around during the Marathon however how encouraging that people … of all ages still have an interest in keeping their bodies healthy and fit!! Good on ’em!!
..Eating chocolate etc ..sounds like you’re not someone who prioritizes ‘Staying Fit!! .. Jeez… Times have changed on the UWS init! .. My priorities for the last 30 plus years here have been taking exercise classes at NYSC and staying up at music venues in Harlem and throughout the City ’til the early hours of the morning!!
You are offensively judgmental! Some of us are thin, healthy, and eat chocolate with great pleasure.
A friend had to go to the ER – but had to wait hours
Sounds like your friend may have been mistakenly been trying to get to see a doctor at Mt. Sinai!! ………Fergedaboudit!
16 years ago, on this very day, my mother was in New York Hospital dying of congestive heart failure on marathon day and I went through absolute hell trying to get to 68th and York. I was completely frantic and ran in every direction begging police officers to let me cross 1st Avenue. I was in tears. I finally got to 59th street where I could go around to York. I made it in time. But in such instances, it is criminal and CRUEL for the marathon to prevent access to a hospital. Unforgivable. I will always hate the marathon.
Awful.
A few minutes late – the horror!
Some people want to be prompt! It’s a sign of respect.
A few minutes late? The horror
Might be time to move.
Rumor has it that NYC has many events and parades.
He will move on his own record if need be. Doesn’t need the public to tell him that lol I defend his opinion.
When one states their complaint on a public forum, then one is open to helpful and constructive suggestions from the public.
You’re seeing a doctor on a Sunday in midtown? Really!!
In my case I had scheduled a mammogram on the East Side. It was the only appointment available until January.. I guess it was available because other people were smart enough to avoid marathon day. Just so you know, not everything closes down on Sundays and it is sometimes necessary to get across town. You cannot even walk across on marathon day.
Assuming the author is not being ironic, I must say that I have to agree with some of the points raised. Every year I deal with trying to get across town on Marathon Sunday and am constantly thwarted. I can’t take the subway to where I need to go and walking takes too long. I give up!
thanks for reminding me: Yogi Berra said “Nobody goes to that restaurant anymore because its too crowded.”
Walking isn’t possible, you can’t walk from west to east between 138th and at least 59th, probably more like 54th, according to the marathon staff I talked to last night in the park. The subway is the only way to get from west to east, or walking down to 54th and then across (or subway to 50th and across).
Lots of people run in honor of a charity and raise money for that cause. Many people also run in support or memory of a loved one. I was in high school on 9/11 and I still remember watching the NYC marathon not 2 months later–incredibly moving.
I would have rather read one of their stories.
Exactly! WSR needs to focus more on articles that actually matter – and make a difference in our community!
so far this year they have raised $100 million for charity pre-race!
I have raised lots of money for charities without ever running a marathon. Can you believe it?
Wow, good thing I raised $11,000 for Special Olympics to make up for this silly, inconsequential, participation-trophy-earning nuisance!
I agree with all of this. And it’s not just the one day. My friend and I wanted to go see the elm trees at the mall in central park yesterday – a full two days before the race – and were not allowed to pass through. We were told we had to exit the park, go around, and come from a different direction – which, at 5:30 pm, was not reasonable.
Never get between the city & big bucks tourism.
I think there should be a race on the UWS of carts pulled by teams of six cats each. Oh, wait …
Mzybe Chewy would sponsor it!
LOL! Literally!!!!
This “grumpy west sider” column should become a regular feature (if it isn’t already.) Yes, we all love the UWS, but no doubt we all have a list of things we, well, don’t love about it. More Grumpy Upper Westsiders, please!
You don’t have to advertise for this. “Grumpy” is the default setting for a huge chunk of this “community”. I’m surprised they’re still not ranting on about the escalators at Trader Joe’s!
No, we are not ranting about the escalators which are working. But we are ranting about the elevator which is not working.
Agree!!! I’m a lot more comfortable in the elevator than crowding onto the escalator!!
i get grumpy too, however it raises tens of millions of dollars for charity. Every year . last year they raised $80 million and this year they are up to 100 million raised for charities
I am a big fan of the marathon. I love watching it and the sense of community. It is one of my favorite days of the year.
That said, the act of completing a marathon is not as impressive as it once was. A friend was an admissions officer at a top MBA program and they said essays about completing a marathon became a running joke in the office because they saw it so often. If you want to impress, complete an IronMan. Running a marathon was like walking around the block.
Kinda like people traipsing up & down Mt. Everest.
amusing
Without doubt the best day of the year in New York City (if you’re a fan as I clearly am or at least was when I lived in NYC 😁).
I happen to have completed NYC Marathon twice prior to later completing 3 further marathons as part of Ironman Triathlons.
And yes, the comment reminds me of that Ironman sticker … “oh, you completed a marathon … how cute 😁”.
Article definitely worthy of the grumpy moniker!
How about impressing the admissions officer by doing good things for the world, rather than proving your fitness and endurance?
Oh, but I forgot, people who want MBAs aren’t really motivated by doing good things for the world.
Wow. I hope someone as negative as you are is not my “neighbor.”
Not true. 👎
What a truly NEGATIVE thing to say! Sh-i-i-t!!!
Generalize much? really? MBAs run some of the world’s leading charities. I have several friends who are doctors who are MBAs. What an ignorant comment. I’m sure you’re a regular Mother Teresa…
Wow.
Yeah, spoken like someone who never ran one. It’s not like running around the block.
..Or staggering around the block with a large dog on a long leash!
masochism plus vanity = NYC marathon.
The Marathon is like Harvard. If someone went through it, they’ll let you know.
lol. I too am a runner and I too have never felt compelled to do a marathon (though I’m sure I could have when I was younger!) That said, I also understand the shared experience and I don’t begrudge people their participation trophies. For all the reasons you’ve described including trekking to S.I. in the wee hours of the morning, I think they deserve them.
While I don’t “hate” it, your thoughts closely resemble mine. Every year, I dread this weekend. I hole up in my little apartment and try not to venture outside.
I’ve lived on the UWS for 40 years. I LOVE walking around the neighborhood in the afternoon congratulating random strangers wrapped in silver blankets. I love welcoming them here. Don’t know how anyone can be so grouchy as to deny these people their success.
I’m fine with their success, but if you want to walk any place other than just around the neighborhood, forget it, you won’t be allowed to.
people like this are insufferable. It’s one day let people enjoy themselves you’ll live
I ran it in 2023 and was one of the greatest days of my life. The support from all my fellow New Yorkers was something I cannot even describe. Thousands of people cheering on complete strangers. Running streets and bridges sans traffic. Feeling an accomplishment only those who’ve struggled with all the many weeks of training and determination and setbacks can understand. Seeing thousands of others around you persevere through their own challenges both mental and physical. There really is nothing like the feeling of crossing that finish line. It makes me sad others can’t deal with one simple day of inconvenience for such a great cause that means so much to so many. I suggest maybe going out and watching and cheering on the runners. Witness their joy and pain and victory and maybe you’ll leave feeling a little less bitter.
I make sure to see an orthopedic doctor (if I happen to need one) BEFORE (I watch) the marathon! I feel sorry for all those knees!
I’m not a fan either. In fact, I’m not a fan of most of the outdoor events that clutter our streets these days, whether the Marathon, street festivals, demonstrations, whatever. Enough already!
We don’t need outdoor events to clutter the streets. Don’t get me started. But to begin with — dogs on outstretched leashes — multiple dogs attached (unless off leash) to one person….
So stay inside. It sounds like that’s what you prefer anyway.
Street ‘festivals’ – yuck. Awful food, endless sheets and other junk
.. Perhaps consider becoming someone who becomes a cruise enthusiast instead! and getaway from the UWS streets forever!!
What do YOU do for fun? Asking for a friend….
Move to Nebraska. No clutter on the streets there.
The annoying part is there are those of us who ran marathons decades ago, well before the mainstreaming and professionalization of amateur running, which has effectively turned marathons, not just NY, into circuses.
Indeed, like any number of wonderful NYC events. When I moved to the West Village in 1983 – and for a good number of years after that – the Halloween parade was a joyous, neighborhood-centric event. Local artists created costumes, puppets and displays. Kids and families participated. The atmosphere was friendly. There were no subway stations blocked, very few street closures and neighborhood businesses along Sixth Avenue were open and celebrating with the crowd. By the late 90s-early 2000’s it was this beast devouring the neighborhood – barricades everywhere, up before the event with “no walk” zones, subway stations closed from the afternoon, ditto businesses. And the worst, crowds of 20- and 30-somethings who had already thrown back a few on their way from work planning on more drinking as the night progressed. Everyone who lived nearby made sure they had picked up food, prescriptions, etc. by the previous day and were safely ensconced in their apartments by 6 pm. Though larger in scope, the Pride Parade had a similar decline on that timeline.
Exactly the same thing that happened to watching the inflation of the Macy’s balloons on Thanksgiving Eve.
It had been purely neighborhood families, kids up after dark, non-commercial. Then “security” moved in and established one-way pedestrian corridors, “no you can’t walk there”, and the event turned into a checklist attraction.
We can’t be friends
I’ll be honest, I really thought this was gonna pivot and be like “ha! Jokes on you, I actually love it!” But it didn’t.
Minigia, this was a buzzkill. Well anywho, I’m excited for my Zabar’s bagel, coffee, and losing my mind for 4-5 hours in Central Park (in the best way possible) tomorrow.
Love,
An UWSer
I’ve run New York City twice. We’ll probably run it again next year. Ask me if I care what you think.
Thanks; we already know. And we don’t care that you don’t care.
We’ll pass
Haha! Grumpster. The UWS wouldn’t be the UWS without the Marathon! 😘
That comment makes no sense at all
It was the UWS long before there was a NYC marathon.
The marathon doesn’t bother me at all.
But I’ve grown to loathe Halloween.
I hate pediatric cancer.
It’s once a year and brings a great deal of joy, excitement, inspiration to tons of spectators and a sense of accomplishment and pride to thousands of runners. You are so privileged to live on the Upper West Side, and I would think you would want to share a piece of its beauty with others. Try to be generous instead of spiteful.
If you want to experience a totally useless and obnoxious NYC event, add the 9th Avenue Festival to your list. Mid-June it kills the whole weekend on which it occurs, both Saturday AND Sunday and benefits only its sponsors and the vendors who participate, no charities that I am aware of. The attendees leave the avenue to make themselves at home on our side street doorsteps while throwing food debris, napkins, paper plates and plastic utensils all over the place (What the Hell, they don’t live there!) while dining on (mostly) unhealthy crap. Annually, some jerks turn it into the 9th Avenue extra-loud music Festival. Why is that allowed when it’s supposed to be about FOOD? It turns Hell’s Kitchen into something truly Hellish once a year and they have tried in the past to get permits to do it in October as well but were, thankfully, denied.
I put the date in my calendar as soon as I know it so I can plan around it. A good day to clean out drawers and try a new recipe (but be sure to pick up the ingredients ahead of time!)
Just moved to Westchester. One of the perks is to get away from all the runners, weed , congestion, bikes and e-bikes. Do I miss the City? Of course. I just needed a higher quality of life. The marathon was never for me. Weight training and Kickboxing are and always will be my passion. I do admire the runners. Not for me.
I love the excitement and all the people from all over the world who come here to participate and enjoy the city. I love the energy and vibe. I love how festive the city feels. I love seeing people after the race with their blankets and medals and can’t help but feel pride and maybe a little jealousy towards them for completing this feat! I love the positive spirit the city has (excluding of course the curmudgeons in these comments). I love traveling and meeting people from all over who mention how they ran the marathon. and how wonderful they thought it was. Including the people like us. Years ago I volunteered to help and have terrific memories being stationed and calling. splits on the 59th St bridge. So many runners stopped to ask me to take a photo of them with the skyline in the background. Or giving out medals and those Italian men who insisted that it also came with a kiss. Especially these days, there is so much negativity in this city, I love that we have an annual event that brings out so much good and friendliness in people. Regardless your politics.
Traffic may be bad but tue day isn’t a surprise so plan around it and what you “need” to do. It’s Sunday for heaven sake. Tomorrow you can go back to hating, complaining, and misery AND Tuesday is election day so it will give everyone more to complain about. For 1 day just be lucky you live here and enjoy!! Its a nice sunny day!
Love the comments.
That was hysterical and on point! Thank you for your honesty!
Wow…with all the horrors to turn one’s attention to in this sad world, attacking an event and the people who find it uplifting and meaningful just because you don’t “get it” seems like a real waste of energy.
Great article but it left out the most obnoxious element: all the virtue signaling .
Leave it to the WSR to allow such an article. Shame on you!
Those who are inconvenienced by a one day international sports event – I will point out the inconveniences of closed streets, regularly, specifically Columbus Ave. Get your priorities in order.
I see this commentary indicative more of a mindset, an attitude. Replace the word Marathon with World Series, World Cup, US Open, Pride Parade, Halloween, Macy’s Parade. It’s all possibly disruptive, it’s all subjective. Good points and bad. It’s all in how you CHOOSE to see it. Some valid points here, and certainly entitled to your opinion, but disappointed that negativity won out out over spreading positivity on this beautiful day. So, with that: good luck runners, be proud of your efforts/accomplishments, and thanks to the charities!
Very grumpy❗️
I hate the word “hate”.
Hear, hear!
Name what you like.Not match right?
I stay in; it’s my fall cleaning day. Maybe bake an apple cake. Let them take over the neighborhood, it’s one day a year…I leave them to it.
It is not about 1 day a year . The preset up and post take down are very annoying.
Theres so much hate in the world. Why rxtend hate to this one day? So much $$$ raised for chsrity — and the goodwill extended to over 20,000 runners from around the world.
What a sad life you have. I’ll bet a $100 you voted for Mamdani.
Riiiight. It’s hardly a secret that he and his supporters love the city, he shows it in his work and happiness for all things NYC every day. But you know that.
You could not have spoken more eloquently for me. I dread it every year as an UWSider. It’s not even just about the day. It is about the ore and post setup and take down.
It I terupts the e revise routine of those of us who do not run marathons but like to walk,run or cycle in. The park.
Then there are the crowds of people,e who have no expect for our neighborhood . There is litter everywhere.
I can handle the Macy”s day parade . It s a one off.
Bah humbug!!
Terrible take