
By Gus Saltonstall
The governor of New York made an appearance outside an Upper West Side train station on Tuesday morning.
Gov. Kathy Hochul, along with an array of West Side elected officials, campaigned in front of the West 96th Street and Broadway train station around 8 a.m. Early Voting began on Saturday for elections across New York, including Hochul’s contest against Republican candidate Bruce Blakeman.
“It all comes together in the next week, and it’s an honor to have the support of so many people who are really thoughtful,” Hochul told West Side Rag. “This is an area of the state where people cast their votes with a lot of understanding of the candidates. They do their research. They understand the pertinent issues involved. So, to have the support of this part of the city and state is a point of pride for me.”
Hochul was joined by Rep. Jerrold Nadler, Comptroller Mark Levine, Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoylman-Sigal, Councilmember Gale Brewer, Councilmember Shaun Abreu, Assemblymember Linda Rosenthal, and Democratic Assembly nominee Eli Northrup.
Multiple members of the Upper West Side Three Parks Independent Democrats club also joined in on the Hochul support.

“It’s important to make your voice heard,” Futter said about the importance of getting out to vote despite no presidential or mayoral election on the ballot. “We need to let everybody know that this state cares about its citizens and Kathy Hochul cares about its citizens.”
The reaction to Hochul was overwhelmingly positive from Upper West Siders commuting to work on Tuesday morning. “That’s my girl, Kathy,” one woman excitedly called out before posing for a photo with the governor, while multiple other passersby made sure to mention they had already voted for her despite Early Voting only kicking off a couple of days ago.
In Upper West Side fashion, West Side Rag heard at least two commuters voice displeasure at the entrance to the subway being more crowded than the typical weekday morning. We also counted at least 12 Secret Service and security team members stationed around the 96th Street subway entrance, dressed along the full spectrum of “I am clearly a Secret Service member” to “nothing to see here, fellow civilians.”

“Turnout is very important. Who the governor is. Who the attorney general is,” Nadler told the Rag. “It’s extremely important to the welfare of the people who the legislators are.”
WSR also asked Hochul about the implications of her race against Blakeman on a national level.
“He [Blakeman] has been wrapping himself around Donald Trump since Day One, and when he said he was going to bring Trump-style leadership to New York State, we knew that once New Yorkers learned that, they would reject that,” Hochul said. “They reject it nationally. They reject Trump-type policies getting a foothold in New York State, and this election is a referendum on just that. Donald Trump himself said in New York, vote as if I’m on the ballot, well, indeed he is, through Bruce Blakeman. That’s why I feel very confident about the outcome of this election, but I still need everybody to get out and vote.”
Subscribe to West Side Rag’s FREE email newsletter here. And you can Support the Rag here.






Nice to see real New Yorkers out there supporting Hochul, who while not perfect is doing a solid job. I expect she will win a large majority of the UWS vote. Go get em Kathy!
“Real New Yorkers”?! Who are you to decide who’s a real New Yorker and who isn’t? The arrogance…
I don’t understand why you are offended by that statement of fact. Unless you don’t think the people taking the 123 at 96th street are real New Yorkers?
Doesn’t all the faux outrage get exhausting?
These people think that they themselves are the only ones capable of judging who “real New Yorkers” are and that others aren’t “real New Yorkers” because they see themselves as more enlightened than anyone else. To them, an Ohio transplant who wants a bike lane and parking eliminated on every street is more worthy of being termed a real New Yorker as opposed to someone who lives in Hollis or Canarsie who disagrees with their cultural worldview.
The unmitigated gall! Harumph! Hey, I didn’t get a harumph out of that guy!
Sorry for not following your group think.
Oh, so only Hochul supporters qualify as “real New Yorkers” now? Pretty arrogant coming from a transplant. How very tolerant and progressive of you, but not at all surprising.
I said nothing of the sort. No judgment about who counts as a New Yorker intended, just happy to see people out there supporting her in real life. I expect she will do very well with UWS voters.
This is why people don’t trust Democrats. The Democrats do not care about having a big tent and a broad based coalition, they care about faux progressives that speak platitudes and boast about how self righteous they are from their $10k a month rental 2 bed apartment. When stuff hits the fan, just like what Chi Osse did, they run away and say that woke 1 was crazy. They don’t care about progress, just their ego. They don’t care about diversity, just a superficial version of it to feed their ego. They don’t care about affordable housing, because dare someone who culturally is different than them is able to “make it” to a neighborhood they treasure.
LOL. Historically – for amost the entire hisory of the country since at least the late 1800s, – it has ALWAYS been the Democratic Party that had the “open tent” and was “inclusive.” After all, isn’t all that inclusion EXACTLY what the right hates about the Democratic Party – not least since it leads to the dreaded “DEI?”
I think you need to do a tad bit more studying of American history, including the two major Parties.
But no comment about the Southern Democrats and Solid South?
No comment on how FDR had to get the support of segregationist Democrats in order for the New Deal to pass, and in order to do that, minorities were initially shut out of many of the New Deal programs, including Social Security. No comment on how FDR acquiesced and supported the internment of Japanese people during World War II, and it was under Ronald Reagan, surviving Japanese internees actually got financial reparations under the Civil Liberties Act of 1988. Also it was under Reagan where we actually got amnesty for undocumented immigrants.
No comment on how Woodrow Wilson oversaw a regression on racial rights during his Presidency.
Tom, I am not sure what conclusion you want us to draw. Shall we vote Republican, thinking that Republicans — pretty much ALL of whom follow whatever Trump says — will promote progress for normal working people? They look like shills for billionaires to many people.
I am personally getting pretty tired of the volume of comments that just broadly stereotype and insult Upper West Siders.
Like: “They don’t care about progress, just their ego. They don’t care about diversity, just a superficial version of it to feed their ego.” are not true or constructive statements.
There are a handful of commenters (who seem to have suspiciously similar writing styles and hobby horses) who do nothing but comment on the news site for Upper West Siders about what terrible, selfish people Upper West Siders are. It makes the comments section pretty unpleasant.
You have no problem doing it to New Jersey!
I do not actually go to the comments sections of New Jersey local news sites and talk about how selfish the people of New Jersey are because that’s a super weird thing to do.
Urbanists do that all the time on the internet to almost every single American or Canadian city, maybe not on paywalled local news sites, but it happens. The UWS, by virtue of being in Manhattan, is part of the collective downtown for many people, so that is to be expected as many New Jersey residents are actually former UWS residents! Many UWS residents have family in New Jersey! As Benjamin Franklin once said, New Jersey is a keg tapped at both ends! By both NYC and Philadelphia!
Many of these so called “progressives” support homeless shelters, abuse of the asylum process and even defunding the police rather than better police. But when any marginalized person achieves a modicum of success and upward mobility and does not exactly fit the curated “diversity and inclusion” that matches the taste of certain big donors in the Democratic Party, then they are made to feel unwelcome. That is very much a true and constructive statement. They want marginalized people who they can control and have a sense of power and superiority over.
Want proof of that, look at how all the anti-car and YIMBY types attack, Mariama James, the First Vice Chair of the Manhattan Democratic Party and a black woman.
“They want marginalized people who they can control and have a sense of power and superiority over.” Just more insane personal insults. Gene is convinced that everyone in the neighborhood hates him because of darkly hinted at but never specified reasons. (He doesn’t “match the taste of certain big donors in the Democratic Party” but never says why exactly).
The UWS is a very big place! You’re welcome here! There are tens of thousands of conservatives, people who own cars, preservationists opposed to YIMBYs, people who hate e-bikes, or whatever other identity you have. Anyone can move here and you can find their people. That’s what I love about the UWS and it’s exhausting listening to someone who chooses not to live here talk about how terrible the people who do live here are.
It’s not a personal insult. This is a very valid criticism and this is something that shows with today’s Democratic Party being dominated by elites who are generally on the UWS, UES, West Village, Brooklyn Heights, Park Slope, the same neighborhoods. Moreover, a lot of people feel they are about to be, are being or have been gentrified out of existence here. The UWS should not strive to be a denser urbanized version of Penn State, University of South Carolina, Ohio State, Fairfield or Quinnipiac University for those over the age of 21, the UWS should be better than that!
Me and Eugene Nickerson were once very fierce political rivals, but we are close allies on the West Side Rag comments section!
Exactly, it’s very tiresome and is certainly not fitting the constructive spirit that is supposed to govern the comment section.
Many of these comments bear the clear hallmarks of a Long Island individual who goes by Eugene….
What actually is tiresome is you deciding to attack the commenters now that you cannot win on the issues themselves. Before any of these commenters began posting on this site and off this site, you all have absolutely no problem attacking Long Islanders, Westchesterites, New Jerseyites or Staten Islanders. You can dish it to others but cannot take it. That is what distracts from the constructive spirit, attacking commenters and insinuating you know where they live.
Hey Eugene, I try to keep it positive around here. Post whatever you want, just use a consistent user name instead of twelve different pseudonyms, that’s all I ask.
The bike and YIMBY activist crowd have dogpiled and engaged in other forms of harassment of people who disagree with them for many, many years. Yet, the bike and YIMBY crowd do not like it when it is perceived as being done to them. Same thing with offline political rallies, the bike and YIMBY crowd have no problem crashing EVSA steering committee member Andrew Fine’s rally in order to “drown out” dissent. However, not only did the bike and YIMBY crowd not like when EVSA crashed and outnumbered them outside Gale Brewer’s office, but even went as far as to falsely accuse EVSA members of assault when no physical touching ever occurred and NYPD was there.
We should keep it positive around here, but we should also understand that the bike and YIMBY crowd have made transportation and housing policy into a culture war. Not only have they made it into a culture war, but one day they will realize that the ONLY reason why they got as far as they did was not because of genuine popularity for their anti-car utopia, but more because of fear (this crowd privately threatens primary challenges to elected officials who dare push back) and because no one wanted to needlessly make an enemy of them. They are burning this bridge over e-bikes. Once they burn this bridge over e-bikes, they will realize that they are in no different of a position than Andrew Cuomo.
Since the holidays are upon us, I think a good idea for West Side Rag would be to do a holiday party where all the regular commenters on this site actually get together and meet and socialize face to face! I think it would be a good idea for all the commenters to realize that we are all real people with real experiences and real backgrounds behind a computer screen.
I would love to meet Eugene and UWS Dad.
Happily! Thanksgiving dinner at your place Eugene?
Something I’d leave up to West Side Rag’s ownership team. How many commenters would even show up?
She’s shorter than I imagined.
Yep, she comes up short in so many ways.
The first “real” comment on this thread. I had the same reaction.
MAGA Bruce is going down but not before he spends a lot of money on campaign commercials
And according to today’s NYT about discrepancies in his financial statements, it’s not very clear where all that money came from or where it went.
How many of them will actually use the train to go canvass for Cait Conley for Congress in NY-17 rather than driving their own cars from Manhattan or chartering private coach buses?
When you hear of a train to rockland county, let me know
NJ Transit under contract with Metro-North operates them!
https://www.mta.info/schedules/metro-north/port-jervis
https://www.mta.info/schedules/metro-north/pascack-valley
I’m really disappointed with the politics as usual, and so I am going to send a message. Hmm, how to do that? I know! I WON’T VOTE!! That’ll send a message. /
Seriously: we can all find flaws, but our right to vote is central. Let’s all do our civic duty and vote!
Why hasn’t she resigned? She has a responsibility to remove Mamdamni from office and has failed to do so.
Vote Blakeman. He’ll get rid of Mamdani for you.
Maybe we don’t WANT to get rid of Mamdani! Have you considered that?
Who’s “we”? You?
Mamdani is not stupid and neither are the business elite.
Imagine thinking the governor should remove a popular, legitimately elected mayor just because YOU don’t like him. Bonkers.
Year to date murders in NYC:
This year: 224
Last year: 272
Down 17.6%
Projected year end total: 256
Rudy Giuliani’s BEST year, when “he made us safe:” 649
Fire someone? I’d fire the guy who’s lying about this stuff.
Meanwhile all the toothpaste and mouthwash are locked up at CVS. Murders affect very few people, Shoplifting, which no longer seems to be a crime, affects everyone.
What a shallow and cruel analogy. “Murders affect very few people” To all the victims of violent crime and their surviving loved ones, this is the most heartless comment yet published by WSR. Perhaps having some empathy, which seems to be something long forgotten, should be first considered, before shooting off offensive and hurtful comments.
Check felony assaults… not good this year.
Enough with these “statistics” already! You can’t compare crime numbers across administrations without looking at what each one inherited, what was done to bring crime down, and what actually worked.
Otherwise, you’re just cherry-picking numbers to suit your ideological views.
And even today’s selectively presented crime statistics paint a pretty grim picture.
I think Blakeman used to be considered a more moderate candidate. The pivot to praising Trump can’t be helping him a whole lot in NYC or the state as a whole. Certainly wouldn’t have been my recommendation.
He made his bed and frankly it shows lousy judgement.
Hochul is perfectly mediocre, but the notion that she’s to blame for any and everything wrong in NY is nonsense. And his promises are as achievable as were trump’s in 2024.
When I look at these characters, so glad I stopped voting when Bloombucks bought his 3rd term.
How is refusal to vote a step toward solving any problem?
Please. BLAKEMAN!
Thanks, Felicia.
Hochul ‘s only platform seems to be that “Blakeman is with Trump” What exactly does she stand for? If people voted on the issues and not emotion, it wouldn’t even be close with this election as Blakeman the victor. Higher taxes here they come. Hasn’t anyone noticed that home insurance premiums have increased 14% or more despite no claims, auto insurance premium increases, payroll taxes have increased, and all coop or condo owners, get ready for huge maintenance increases to cover the increase in property taxes soon to come our way immediately after the election. NY’s budget is higher than Florida, California and Texas combined – and yeah, let’s continue to support cradle to grave handouts from the open borders policy of the Democrats. That said, of course, Hochul, after all, Blakeman is with Trump. Get real people. More of the same and then some, is yet to come.
We should agree that the Democrats must do more than “resist Trump” and Republicans must do more than follow “dear leader” Trump.
No thanks. Corrupt, power-hungry, would be a republican in almost any other state.
Do democrats talk about anything besides how much they hate Trump? We get it. You don’t like him. But obsession isn’t healthy
I wish she had laid out a more positive agenda in her comments (as she has online). If only we had a serious Rockefeller-style Republican party that ran serious candidates and tried to win over New Yorkers. Some political competition would be a good thing. But we won’t get there with the current MAGA cult in charge.
You only want “some” political competition!
What is that supposed to mean? There’s plenty of political competition it just occurs as infighting within the Democratic party. There should be a serious fiscally conservative option to provide a counterbalance.
Alina Bonsell is a good candidate over on the UES!
Clearly as an UWS dad, I can’t vote her but parts of her platform look reasonable! Think she’s wrong about the pied-à-terre tax & congestion pricing for example. But if the mainstream GOP wasn’t in thrall to DJT, it could be a real contest of ideas for moderate voters such as myself.
I’m saddened as it seems as though I could have met Kathy and crew today at the subway entrance but the station has recently become so full of vagrant men on psychotic drugs loitering around the area and approaching riders that I am terrified as a woman and mother to go to that station at all even in the daytime. I have resorted to taking my kids to school in cabs the past few months. ☹️ I noticed the station was cleaned and graffiti removed yesterday before her arrival. I wish it could go back to how it was prior to this year. I never felt unsafe here any time day or night prior to 2026 and have lived in the immediate area for 10 years.
Here’s the thing about voting. I voted today. Walked in with my driver’s license ready to show. I was told it wasn’t necessary. Seriously?!
They asked for my name, pulled up my address, and asked me to confirm it.
So I asked the woman in charge why no ID was required. Her answer? “But you have to confirm your address.”
I pointed out that plenty of people know my name and address, not to mention other people’s.
And her response? “Oh, but they could also have your ID.”
Seriously?! So apparently, to her and the people who came up with these rules, possessing someone else’s ID is no different from simply knowing their name and address. How does that make any sense?
Hope you voted Republican then.
Your signature must match the one on record.
You seriously don’t see any issue with that?!
It doesn’t. It takes a photo ID plus a proof of address to renew a New York Public Library card. Sense evaporated a while ago
“Hochul was joined by Rep. Jerrold Nadler, Comptroller Mark Levine, Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoylman-Sigal, Councilmember Gale Brewer, Councilmember Shaun Abreu and Assemblymember Linda Rosenthal.”
The Seven Deadly Sins of NY and the UWS.
You could take a pig. Call him Horace. Run him has the Democratic candidate anywhere in the 67th and 69th assembly districts.. Put his picture on the campaign lit. An actual pig. And the Republican candidate could be Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt put together. The pig would win
FYI, Hochul does not have a secret service detail she is protected by the PSU. Protection by the secret service would imply she is running for certain federal positions. (ie President, etc).
I was going to say the same thing! And Nadler would have had Capitol Police protection when he was Chair/ Ranking Member of the House Judiciary Committee though I believe he no longer has that detail.
For what it’s worth, the Secret Service does not normally protect individuals other than the president, VP, and presidential candidates. They could protect Gov. Hochul if the president requested it…which is not likely. Those were most likely NY State Troopers.
I’m glad to see her – as candidates ought to do – campaigning with the people. Whether you vote for her or not, it is good to see her doing the legwork and giving the voters the respect their vote deserves. On that note, if you can vote, please go VOTE – there are plenty of opportunities now that we have early voting. Let the vote of the people count.
Are you sure there were “Secret Service” present? As far as I knoew, state officials don’t get Secret Service protection. According to the Secret Service website:
By law, the Secret Service is authorized to protect:
– The president, the vice president, (or other individuals next in order of succession to the Office of the President), the president-elect and vice president-elect
– The immediate families of the above individuals
– Former presidents, their spouses, except when the spouse re-marries
– Children of former presidents until age 16
– Visiting heads of foreign states or governments and their spouses traveling with them, other distinguished foreign visitors to the United States, and official representatives of the United States performing special missions abroad
– Major presidential and vice presidential candidates, and their spouses within 120 days of a general presidential election
– Other individuals as designated per Executive Order of the President and
– National Special Security Events, when designated as such by the Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security
I’m a Democrat voting Republican down the ticket. All Democrats proclaim is “no Trump”. That’s it. No ideas, no plans. Just “Let’s get Trump” who, BY THE WAY, was overwhelmingly elected by … who would that be… ahh, AMERICAN PEOPLE!
Same here. A lot of us did, without openly admitting it, for fear of being verbally and sometimes even physically assaulted by the ultra-left.
I’ve been a Democrat since 2000. But that’s it. The party has been hijacked by radicals. I voted for the opposition solely to bring the party back to its senses, not because I’ve suddenly become a Republican or embraced Republican views.
I am a Rockland County Democrat who voted for Mike Lawler. My message to Manhattan Democrats is this, a lot of you all are very patronizing towards people who aren’t like you and then deny it when called out and mock people for it, since that’s how you want to be, my message to the West Side Democrats, the Three Parks Democrats, and any other Manhattan Democratic club is this, please do not come here to canvass for Cait Conley. If you do not truly value the contributions of NY-17 constituents to Manhattan’s economy or take us for granted, please do not ask us to vote Cait Conley. Trump is the President and he is horrible, but you cannot use Trump forever while looking down on us.
…we are so screwed.
Was she discussing the sharp uptick in subway crime over the last year?
Everyday I see more and more homeless people sleeping on the streets on the UWS. Sadly many of them are mentally ill and need help. Being progressive doesn’t mean letting people just sleep everywhere. We need change with sensible policies to actually help these people Vote for BRUCE BLAKEMAN. & SARITHA for Attorney Generall!
Where are all the drug addicts and mentally ill that are there every day talking to themselves, defecating or doing some drugs on the bench while asking for money? That’s what I see every day yet hmmm….. they seem to be gone for the politicians.
It’s their policies that have caused that subway stop to be an abomination and they have a lot of nerve posing in front of it.
Ask your unhoused person that is usually there, inside and out, why they don’t get shelter and they’ll tell you it’s unsafe and dangerous. Doubt me? Go talk to them and ask.
Those are our “leaders” who have spent billions on the unhoused and there are still people at the subways, too scared to go in. Why? Because after spending $81,000/year per person to the “non-profits” who some make up to $400,000 per year, there is no accountability and each of those politicians do NOTHING to change it.
Keep smiling for the camera before one of the unhoused, mentally ill ruin your shot.
That is such a good point. Why are these unhoused people not in the photo opps with the politicians. Most people I know are now scared to take the subway. When addressed with safety issues, Kathy says crime is down. Well that may be the case for major crimes, but people are nervous. Kathy we all dont walk around with armed security like you do. Maybe take some time and live in the real world? VOTE BLAKEMAN for GOV and SARITHA FOR AG
HOPEFULLY God (or someone else) will BLESS AMERICA! Clearly we need it dearly.
What a joke Hochul is. Can’t believe people vote for her just because she’s a Democrat. Her biggest/constant argument is that Blakeman is another Trump. She can’t say anything else because she’s been awful at everything else. The fact that she MAILED out “energy” checks just before election day, to try and buy votes shows how pathetic and desperate she is.
And no, I’m not a rightist/republican or leftist/democratic supporter. I’m just a realist.