
By Andrea Sachs
When I first spotted Jimmy at an animal shelter in 2011, he was a long, lean one-year-old cat. His sister had been adopted separately the day before, and he was already lonesome. When I petted him, he licked my hand.
Troth plighted!
Three weeks later, I skeptically asked the animal behaviorist at a different shelter to find me a young female cat who got along well with other cats. Amazingly, she did. Abby had just delivered two kittens at the shelter and, newly spayed, was ready for a home. She and Jimmy hissed at each other when they were introduced.
By the end of the day, they were best friends.
That was 14 years ago. Since then, I have been the fortunate pet parent of what are referred to as bonded cats. They love each other dearly and spend most of their days spooning or toddling after each other. I have been blessed.
These days, though, la vie chez Sachs is more complicated. Jimmy and Abby are each on three pricey veterinary medicines for different conditions. Sometimes, their symptoms take the spotlight. When that happens, they show unmistakable signs that they have entered what might be indelicately called the “pee-poop-puke” portion of their lives.
Dr. Rich Fried, the founder and medical director of Lincoln Square Veterinary Hospital, has cared for Upper West Side animals for 30 years and has a more erudite way of saying that.
“Pets suffer from many of the same things that we suffer from as we age, only their time frame is very compressed. They get arthritis, and they get cataracts, and they can lose kidney function and so forth; it just happens in a shorter period of time,” he told West Side Rag. “Because of that, and especially in cats, they’re really good at not showing symptoms until their problems are very advanced.”
As a result, Fried says, it’s advisable that pets older than seven be examined twice a year instead of annually.
“We are more likely to do routine lab work during those visits, looking for conditions that owners might not yet be aware of,” Fried explained. “For example, people come in and say their pets are slowing down. They’re walking slower, slower to rise, not as eager to go for walks. It may be because they have arthritis, which is treatable. It’s not curable, but it’s often manageable.”
“Even some incurable cancers in pets, like lymphoma, may also be manageable,” Fried added. And there’s actually a screening test for the early detection of some kinds of canine cancers.
“With aging pets, we’re generally looking to monitor and carefully treat problems as they develop — earlier is always better — and to help them maintain the best quality of life they can for as long as they can. Our goal is not necessarily to keep them alive to the last possible second, it’s to keep them alive as long as they have a good, comfortable quality of life,” he stated.

Having a healthy older pet can be a costly privilege.
Advises Fried, “It is absolutely best to get pet insurance before your pet has anything the insurance company would consider a pre-existing condition. There’s no Affordable Care Act for pets. There are many good pet insurance companies now, and I strongly recommend getting pet insurance at a young age, before they have a pre-existing condition.”
Fried generally recommends that pet owners, at minimum, get the equivalent of major medical insurance, covering major illnesses or injuries. “You don’t need policies that cover every physical exam and vaccine and deworming,” he says. ‘But if your pet hurts itself and needs surgery or it gets a serious illness and needs to be hospitalized, you want that to be covered.”

Returning to my world, something happened down the hall from me recently that brought the issue of aging pets into painful focus. My neighbors Dave and his husband Michael had two friendly dogs, Ray-Ray and Libby, who frisked by my door every day.
In February, they had to put down Ray-Ray, the 13-year-old chihuahua, because of heart problems.
It was an excruciating decision for them. “I know we did the right thing, and my rational mind knows that we would certainly want to have another dog down the line after Libby, our 10-year-old labrador,” says Dave. “But there was a part of me when I was putting Ray-Ray down that was like, I can never do this again. It’s so heartbreaking! Just the thought of getting a puppy and having a great 10 or 15 years and then having to put them down…it’s really tough.”
As for me, my beloved cat Jimmy is no longer lean and lanky; truth be told, he is rather large and lumpy after a lifetime of too much kibble. Abby, the jumper of the two of them, rarely does dazzling feline acrobatics anymore. They sleep more than ever, usually with the other nearby.
I won’t lie — I’ve shed tears for what’s about to come. Who will go first? How will the other one survive the loss? How will I survive the loss? But I am determined to baby them and treat every day with them as the gift it is.
As writer Anatole France wisely said, “Until one has loved an animal, a part of one’s soul remains unawakened.”
Subscribe to West Side Rag’s FREE email newsletter here. And you can Support the Rag here.
Our pets fill our he’arts then break them in half. They are a great blessing. Thank you for your story and the great pet are advice.
Rest in peace, Ray-Ray!
Ridiculous. Veterinarians are eager to exploit the obsession with pets, digging deep into the owner’s wallets, and subjecting animals to medical tortures.
“OBSESSION” with pets?? Clearly you don’t “get it” and shouldn’t be part of this conversation!
I’m not sure that is what was said in the article. Did you read the part about not extending their lives but giving them the best lives during the time they have? That is the philosophy all my vets have followed. But by all means, if you don’t want to have pets, don’t get one!
I love the Anatole France quote! Beautiful Andrea – Abby and Jimmy have such a great mom!
I had to put my cat down last year after 14 years with him. He was on several medication and prescription food for several years. It was not cheap but he had a good quality of life until his last few weeks when his liver started to fail and he was clearly suffering. There are vets in NYC that will come to your home and perform euthanasia there. Saying goodbye to my cat was excruciating but I’m grateful he got to die peacefully on his favorite corner of the couch.
Peace be with you🙏. I have just experienced losing my buddy of 13 years of pure love and friendship and places we have travel to that I wouldn’t have gone to if it wasn’t for him. One day we will meet again over the Rainbow Bridge for here, between this world and the next,
this is a place where each beloved pet finds rest and waits for his owner from the past world to arrive to cross over The Rainbow Bridge together, never to be separated again.🐾🐾🙏
Condolences—it’s so hard—you really gave him wonderful care
Great to see a bonded pair of cats like Abby and Jimmy who have had their whole lives together—so very sweet—as someone who’s lived thru managing this phase of their life the best advise I can give is to treat them but know when it’s extreme treatment and you should stop—I’m not sure a lot of cancer treatments are worth it unless the success rate is high like in thyroid cancer—modern vet care offers all the treatments but knowing what to do or when to stop can be hard—a lot of experience in this area has taught me to do a little less than the maximum available with low odds of success
Take good care of your pets, they take good care of you, love your pets as much as you can. They love you so much more. They’re only here to show you the way for a very short time..
God’s little angels. 😇
💙I love you Zac, forever 🐾🐾
Lovely cats, lovely story.
I’m on my third generation of cats. I had to put my 18 year old silver tabby to sleep a few weeks ago and now have his 18 year old companion by my side. The vet bills over the past couple of years have been astronomical–but well worth the joy this sweet little man gave me.
Condolences—they’re such great companions—I’m sure everyone is grieving including the surviving cat—they have clearly gotten wonderful care
What a beautiful story. I have a 15 yo dog the love of my life. She was just diagnosed with bladder cancer in the early stage. After I wrapped my head around this I embraced the fact that I am grateful to still have time with her. My heart breaks a little everyday but she’s still has quality of life. We open up our hearts knowing it will get broken.
It’s been 2 years, 2 months since my 17 year old shih tzu dog Sandy passed away at my request.
Not a day goes by since that challenging day that I don’t think of her! Friends and often acquaintances I’ve not seen in awhile, ask me about her or if I miss her! Well hell yes, I do miss her, think of her but will never want to replace her! I live with photos and even videos of her ….and that’s how I deal with finality!!
Yes Steve, It is so very very hard….. May peace be with you.🙏
I feel your angst, in the past two years I had to say goodbye to my two 16 year old dogs. I knew it was coming, did everything I could to prevent it, but in the end it’s, of course, inevitable. After a few months I got another rescue dog, because I missed having a dog around the place, and also, more importantly for me, I couldn’t bear the thought of a dog out there needing a home and me being too sensitive to the thought of eventually losing them to give them one. That, I guess, is the bottom line for me, and I will keep adopting until I can’t do it any longer.
Can folks suggest or recommend an animal insurance plan? I have 2 rescue cats since Covid 2020. Curious Pet insurance recommendations. Than ks
We have been very happy with Nationwide Pet Insurance : https://www.petinsurance.com/
https://www.aspcapetinsurance.com/resources/pet-insurance/
I’ve had the pleasure of playing with Abby and Jimmy in their homestead. Fortune smiled on the duo when their loving benefactor brought them into her UWS world. Andrea ‘s dedication to this gorgeous pair is palpable, evidenced by her unconditional love. And those fortunate felines know how to strike a pose! They will be forever young..
We said goodbye to one our 3 dogs a few weeks ago. She was the 3rd dog I’ve had to put to sleep when the bad days were outweighing the good. Wonderful vet once told me about letting them go… “better a week early than a day late”. I’ve lived by that.
What I do recommend (if possible) is to have the vet come to your home. You and your pet are in familiar surroundings and it gives you an opportunity to say goodbye without the inevitable stress of being at the vet’s office.