
By Gus Saltonstall
A long-dormant structure at a busy Upper West Side intersection is on the way to getting a new lease on life.
Earlier this month, the New York City Parks Department launched a Request for Expressions of Interest process to repurpose the one-story building on the Broadway Mall at West 96th Street.
The building, directly across from the 96th Street subway station, has sat unused for years other than serving as a space to store equipment for Parks Department employees.
Here are the different concepts that the Parks Department lists as possibilities for the space, but emphasizes that other ideas are also welcome.
- Food Establishments
- Indoor and/or Outdoor Recreational Facilities and Programs
- Markets, Fairs, Events, and Amusements
- Public Art Activations or Performances
- Recreational Activities (eg. bike rental, etc.)
“The interior is unfinished and non-operational from a concession standpoint, but utilities are connected. Electrical service is present, plumbing and gas lines are in place, though the interior requires a full build-out and new fixtures for active use,” reads a description of the current conditions within the single-story masonry structure at 96th Street. “HVAC equipment would have to be updated or installed with proper permits. Interior finishes show typical wear from vacancy, including patched walls and aging surfaces.”
Expressions of interest for the space are due by Friday, December 11, at 2 p.m.
You can email Kat Cognata at katherine.cognata@parks.nyc.gov for information on how to submit your interest.
“Whenever you walk past the building across from the 96th Street station on your way to the train, you can’t help but think how much opportunity it could hold as a community space,” Councilmember Shaun Abreu, who has pushed to clean up the space for the duration of his tenure, wrote to the Rag in an email. “For too long, what could be a vibrant public space has mostly been abandoned to pigeons and rats.”
Upper West Siders who pass by 96th Street and Broadway will be familiar with the pigeon and rat issue.
Swarms of rats and pigeons have congregated on the plaza in front of the storage building for years. The feeding frenzies take place in part due to persistent bird feeding that goes on at the location.


Along with Abreu, Councilmember Gale Brewer has also written letters to the city asking for something to be done with the area.
In September of 2025, Upper West Siders launched a petition aimed at reactivating the plaza in front of the 96th Street storage building into a community art space. Prior to the COVID pandemic, the median in front of the Broadway Malls storage building was rented from the city by the West Side Arts Coalition as a place to display public art.
The launch of the Request for Expressions of Interest process by the city will now allow for changes to happen to the building and the plaza in an official capacity.
The timeline after the December 11, 2026 deadline for the Expression of Interest remains unclear.
Subscribe to West Side Rag’s FREE email newsletter here. And you can Support the Rag here.




















Free (pot) smoking clinic! With art.
I am very happy to see this space turned into something beneficial to the community but hope it’s not anything food related given the rat issues already present.
Already looks like someone is feeding those rats. Maybe the same person who thinks it’s a good idea to feed pigeons
I would suggest an MTA marijuana dispensary called Take A Trip. Let the potheads pay for “free” mass transit.
All but the first are good ideas. But a food establishment would be a VERY bad idea. Imagine all the extra garbage that will collect on that median, attracting rats, etc. (The pigeons have already staked their claim.)
As long as it is non-food, I support it.
As noted above — the pigeons and rats are currently being intentionally fed, as you can see from the photos. A food establishment (if that were the best use otherwise) could presumably properly seal up its garbage, as restaurants (usually) do.
(Once out of frustration but knowing it was hopeless, I said to the person strewing the food to lure the pigeons, “Please stop doing that ! You are feeding the rats !” and she replied, “The rats need to eat too !” )
A police station.
Bed and Breakfast
1 hour limit. For both, to keep it classy.
More like they’re going to try to repurpose it. Someone has to express interest and the MTA and city would have to approve. But hopefully they will!
Bathroom
Why does that one-story building need to stay? Waste of land! Tear it down and build a tall, sliver condo tower. /s
The Westside Artists group ran a public gallery here for its members for years until there was a problem with the structure three years ago. As far as I know they’ve never given up hope, never stopped contacting local city officials that the MTA would fix the problem and they could move back in. But no? Were they even offered the space before the process of opening up the REI?
I was thinking I was delusional in thinking there were exhibits there. I loved it.
A mini rat and pigeon museum seems to be a perfect match.
yes a very large bathroom, so the endless protesters will have somewhere to pee!
That intersection is mayhem. Two major bus lines, a big transit stop, cars turning to access the Henry Hudson, pedestrians trying not to get run over…
I can’t imagine what kind of “event space” wouldn’t just cause additional chaos — and danger. The plaza is small. Where would participants gather? Who would want to hang out in the middle of a major intersection, especially in the height of summer when it’s blazing out there?
Plus, right across the way, the “park” area in front to the actual subway entrance is populated by a rotating cast of panhandlers and homeless people, and is dirty and beat down. Can the MTA please fix THAT?
I would be very careful about any choice involving a lot of foot traffic. That intersection is already extremely dangerous, IMO
Lease to the highest bidder. The city and UWS needs a bit of revenue to support those city run grocery stores and free busses.
Dangerous spot for bike rental
What was it’s original purpose?
what about a 311 in person site, where someone can sit across from a City representative and try to resolve any issues they might have with the City bureaucracy?
Hopefully a food establishment. A coffee shop or bakery or ice cream shop
Would people really want to sit in the middle of three-way traffic and absorb exhaust fumes with their cappuccinos?
In N Out Burger. First one in NYC. It would make a fortune. And with all of the foot traffic it would draw, the rats and pigeons would disperse. The issue would be that it would be so popular that the lines would go out into the street.
Regarding the feeding of the rats and pigeons, couldn’t it be made illegal to feed them? Put up a sign and station someone there to arrest people. Very simple.
Anyone familiar with that interesction is aware that its a dangerous intersection/crosswalk. The last thing that intersection needs is a place for people to congregate at.
Do nothing with this building. Jesus Christ this neighborhood is in serious trouble. It’s filthy, one can’t use the mailboxes, and the elderly are frightened to walk outside. Our citizens need help. Rats are everywhere. It’s filthy! Instead, hire more cops to walk the east and west side of Broadway and walk the street up and back down between 96 and 106 all day long. With night-time surveillance. There are a massive amount of mentally ill, serious crime offenders, halfway houses, drug addicts, rehab residents, Rikers holdovers, etc. We have Duane Read drug stores that are robbed daily if not hourly. There is a large amount of empty storefronts. And you are talking about an art installation??? Get real. This neighborhood needs REAL help. This neighborhood is dead! No restaurants, not shoe store, no butcher, etc. Do something meaningful. Leave that building alone. Do something for the people, like make it safe and clean, with that money. Clean this hood up! Do it for the people in this hood.
A multicultural space -ARTIST SPACE gallery space – plant shop a book shop
– There’s a group that meets in front of the structure every Friday to read out the names of those killed or detained by ice
no food, the area is inundated with eateries and will attract more vermin
If you try and beat the lights, it’s dangerous
There needs to be s public service announcements to point out the risks of feeing pidgeons
• Pigeons breed much faster when food is artificially abundant (up to 8 times a year instead of the normal 2 to 3 times).
• Property and Nuisance Damage: Large flocks create heavy accumulations of acidic droppings, damage roofs, block chimneys, and can become aggressive or overly bold around humans.
• Health Risks: Large concentrations of birds increase the spread of diseases (such as histoplasmosis, cryptococcosis, and psittacosis), and dried droppings can trigger respiratory issues like Bird Fancier’s Lung
If it included an entrance to the subway, far fewer people who live north of 96th would have to cross 96th to take the subway.
Rats may be due to the feeding of pidgeons ! Curtail that activity as a starting point!
Set up a flower stand that sells coffee or better yet….Ginjinha (or ginja), Portugal’s famous traditional dark red sour cherry liqueur, sold in shots in the late afternoon, early evening! Very European for the Broadway Mall scene!
How about a gallery for school-age art and science projects? A place where the young could display their creativity??
The last place school-aged children should spend a second more than absolutely necessary for transit purposes is the intersection of Bway and 96th St
That, and Fallujah circa 2005.
It would be wonderful if they could rid this of pigeons and rats. Its really a health hazard from the pigeon droppingss.
Mid point for an elevated sidewalk.
Bring back an art gallery space. It was a jewel, even in its disrepaired space. Passersby would step in to see what this strange space was and be captivated by the art. The West Side Arts Coalition took good care of the building, though whoever controlled the space put form limits on improvements. Bring it back! It was a precious community amenity for local residents and artists.
The lady who feeds the birds could use it to store more birdseed
As for the building, why not a grocery store as sadly Zingone’s is closing.